3 ms·
If there's one thing I know about gamblers, it's that their willingness to bet money on something generally has no correlation whatsoever to their knowledge abo
by mattmaroon 19y ago
If there's one thing I know about gamblers, it's that their willingness to bet money on something generally has no correlation whatsoever to their knowledge about it. Their ability to continue betting over their lifetime certainly does, which of course means that any prediction market that doesn't run on real dollars is essentially useless.
But that doesn't mean the for money ones are useful. This particular one is not. The infrequent nature of bets of this type, plus the small number of people able to get money onto sites like that in any reasonable timeframe keep it (at least where politics is concerned) from becoming anywhere near efficient. It's simply too small for much in the way of smart money to even bother with, so what you see is mostly just the result of sports bettors who watched an hour of CNN yesterday and have nothing else interesting to wager on.
I wouldn't be surprised if they were extremely accurate for European sports, but for American politics they've been way off recently. The good news is, they're very easy to exploit in any close election year. Perhaps I'll blog about how after I do it in November.
- aston 19y agoI assume the technique involves betting on whoever's losing, and inversely so based on how much they're losing by assuming that the numbers will come to 50/50 in the end?
- dejb 19y agoI admit the volume isn't huge. Maybe 10K per day on the presidential nominations. So you might be able to average placing 1K on per day without destroying your odds. If you had even a 10% edge then that's $100 gain which most people wouldn't be giving up their day job for. There are other markets though. Betfair had turned over $3 million on the Dem Nom. The funny thing is the more accurate the market is the less 'smart money' would be attracted to profits and vice versa. Good luck with your trading. By participating you will presumably increase the accuracy of the market. But I think the average trader might be more knowledgeable than you give them credit for (even ones from those non-US places). And you never know... there might actually be something in this 'Wisdom of the Crowds' thing.
- mattmaroon 19y agoMy trading in November (assuming a close race) is more predicated on knowledge of what happens to those betting markets throughout the day of the election than any political knowledge. As you pointed out though, I can't make retirement money on that small of volume. I might be able to make vacation money though. Also I should check to see if there's a difference in odds between betfair and intrade. Might be able to run some sort of cross-site arbitrage if possible.