5 ms·
Can someone explain to me why both cheap oil and expensive oil seem to be bad for the economy? Back when oil was >$100 per barrel everybody seemed to blame the
by adrianN 11y ago
Can someone explain to me why both cheap oil and expensive oil seem to be bad for the economy? Back when oil was >$100 per barrel everybody seemed to blame the weak economy on expensive oil. Now somehow very cheap oil is also a bad thing.
- wrong_variable 11y agoI agree - its sloppiness from our "leaders" in the field of economics.
- dazc 11y agoCheap oil is bad for net exporters of oil and good for net importers. And visa versa. I get the impression the media are always talking about an imminent financial catastrophe because eventually they'll be right and we'll forget how many times they have been wrong.
- danharaj 11y agoon the other hand, we know they'll be right eventually.
- nextweek2 11y agoIt's both good and bad for me. It's cheaper to fill my car up however my pension funds investments in the mineral sector have fallen. Only in the long term will I know how I faired. My hope is that I am buying in the down market and the producers are optimising for the next decade.
- tim333 11y agoThey cause different problems: Expensive oil - costs more as you'd expect. Cheap oil - good but leads to falling prices so savers leave their money in the bank waiting for discounts so spending in the economy falls. The second one is an odd thing that only happens in a deflationary environment.
- dnautics 11y ago"cheap" is "bad" because it encourages "hoarding". Instead, those that run the economy would much rather put you on a treadmill of devaluation, which forces you to keep working harder (better unemployment figures!) and consume. Basically short shrift the working class of the value of their income - it's a backdoor paycut for workers[0]. It also forces the middle class into investing directly or indirectly (through pension funds, 401ks, etc) in the stock market, which is great for the ̶r̶i̶c̶h̶ economy and socializes the downside of entrepreneurial risk while letting entrepreneurs keep the upside. [0] Don't take my word for that, it's in the words of nobel laureate Paul Krugman: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-higher-inflation/?_r=0 http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-hig... "Yet when you have very low inflation, getting relative wages right would require that a significant number of workers take wage cuts. So having a somewhat higher inflation rate would lead to lower unemployment, not just temporarily, but on a sustained basis."
- dilemma 11y agoThat inflation means decreased real wages is elementary and doesn't need a source support the statement. It completely misses the point, however. What is needed to have a strong, growing economy with increasing prosperity for more than the one percent isn't high or low inflation, but stable price levels that makes it possible to plan for the long term and make investments into productivity and efficiency. When witch doctors in the Fed, ECB and BoJ arbitrarily manipulate interest rates and thereby inflation, they promote speculation over investment and move wealth to the 0.01%.
- dnautics 11y agoThere weren't stable prices by any means from 1800-1900 but would you say there wasn't a growing economy? The US even was able to support the freeing of slaves and their entry into the marketplace as laborers over that term.
- lmm 11y agoBig price swings are bad for the economy - everyone ends up wrong-footed.
- cdnsteve 11y agoThey are great for investment opportunities however.
- unknown_apostle 11y agoThe idea is that cheap oil would be caused by a worsening economy with less demand for it.
- singham 11y agoMost likely cheap oil is put Russia in place.
- akerro 11y ago, Norway, Turkey and ISIS.
- green7ea 11y agoHonest question: why Norway? I thought it was more about Russia, Iran, Venezuela, ISIS and that Norway was simply collateral.
- akerro 11y agohttp://www.reuters.com/article/us-norway-economy-insight-idUSBREA4703Z20140508 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-norway-economy-insight-idU...
- oblio 11y agoThat article's lead picture is silly. I'm willing to bet that the woman in the picture is from my country instead of being an actual Norwegian. Shameful journalism, portraying Norway's economic problems like some sort of meltdown.
- richardwhiuk 11y agoExpensive oil is bad for the economy because it's expensive to produce things. Cheap oil is bad news for the economy, because it's an indicator in a fall in production, if the reason it's cheap isn't because of new fields, but because of lower demand. Even if it is due to new sources (e.g. fracking) the perception that it's an indicator of global production may be sufficient to override any realistic benefits.
- jevgeni 11y agoOil price is a symptom of some other underlying problem. During $100+ oil the problem was that supply couldn't satisfy the market (mostly due to Chinese growth and demand for energy). This raked the price up not just for the Chinese, but for everybody. Which was bad if your factory needs oil to produce your widgets: higher production cost leads to either thinner margins (and hence less future investments) or higher prices (and hence lower demand and ultimately - thinner margins). So ok, the oil companies invested in expanding capacities, built refiners, oil rigs, etc. to satisfy demand. But now the world doesn't need as much of it as it used to. Well, shit. That means you still have to pay off loans for your new and shiny oil rigs, but you can't sell as much oil as quickly. What does that mean? Thinner margins. Ad nausem.
- otabdeveloper1 11y agoCheap oil is taken as a signal of deflation, and deflation is very bad because it happens when the economy is too broken to make investing worthwhile.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoIgnoring the obvious climate-change issues just for the moment to focus purely on the relation of oil prices and the economy... From the global perspective, cheap oil is a very good thing. Cheap commodities in general are an unmitigated good thing. Cheap oil means that people spend less money to move vehicles around and heat homes, and can spend it elsewhere. Cheap oil means trade is cheaper, allowing goods to be produced in more-efficient places and then shipped instead. Cheap commodities mean that investors spend less money building oil rigs and mines, and can invest it elsewhere. Final goods and services where oil or other commodities are an input become less expensive, allowing other economic activity to be pursued. The reasons cheap oil could be linked to bad stuff in the world economy are not because the oil itself is cheap, though. Cheap oil could be bad because it is a sign that no one wants to buy oil, which is a sign that people aren't shipping goods and other economic activity is depressed. (This is a cause of cheap oil, though, not an effect.) The other big reason it could be bad is that it is a sign that people have invested too much money drilling for oil and building oil-extracting machines and training people to be oilfield workers and the like. Too-cheap oil suggests that this investment was a bad idea and should not have been made, or at least not made yet, and now that effort has been at least partially wasted. But that's another cause of cheap oil, and not an effect. The people who suffer from cheap oil are those who are involved in the production of oil: oil companies themselves, companies who provide services to oil companies, pipeline companies, railroad companies involved in shipping oil, workers out on the oil fields, companies involved in providing services in those regions (e.g. real estate firms in the right parts of the Dakotas)... and investors in any of those companies (including pension funds). The US is involved in a lot more oil production than it used to be, so some of that suffering partially mitigates against the awesomeness of cheap oil to the rest of its economy. (Partially. Most of the US is not involved in producing oil.)
- vox_mollis 11y agoCheap oil is bad at this precise moment because of the enormous quantity of soon-to-be-impaired debt that was issued by the energy industry on the assumption of perpetually high oil prices. Debt contagion remains as a risk, just as it did in 2008.
- pasquinelli 11y agoi think it isn't that cheap oil is bad for the economy but that cheap oil can be a sign of a bad economy, one where the destruction for the demand for energy has outstripped what should ought to be a tight supply.