4 ms·
> The second was a set of emails from Duncan Murdoch, President of the R Foundation and an R Core member, in which he dismissed my "bug report" (note the skepti
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
> The second was a set of emails from Duncan Murdoch, President of the R Foundation and an R Core member, in which he dismissed my "bug report" (note the skeptical scare quotes he put on it) "about some variable name that you find offensive is clearly an example of nothing more than shit-disturbing" and stated that myself, and those who had commented in favour of changing it, were no longer welcome to participate in R's bug-tracker.
> I independently confirmed that our accounts had been banned and locked - as had the bug, and replied to Duncan explaining my thinking and motivation and asking in what capacity the ban had been made.
> The variable name is still there. I never got any reply to my email.
This bit needs to be emphasized, because the incident is invariably going to be spun as one over-sensitive prude throwing a temper tantrum because he didn't get his way. We need to keep focus on what actually happened: Keyes pointed out something he perceived as a problem, going out of his way to be polite and non-accusatory; Murdoch punished and censored Keyes and anyone who had publicly agreed with him.
- TheLogothete 11y agoBut we don't know what actually happened. Perhaps you can keep your judgement for AFTER you hear both sides of the story?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoKeyes' story was pretty clear and detailed; I don't see much room for misinterpretation. I suppose it's possible that he's outright lying and the locked bug he linked in the article was actually Viagra spam, but I don't think it's reasonable to suspend all discussion on that basis.
- TheLogothete 11y agoOr perhaps it went something like this: A person who has a long history of creating drama wherever he goes sees a very aptly named argument with siblings which follow the same nomenclature. The person opens a bug report to change the name of said argument because he perceives some grand social injustice with it. This person is rather impatient so he hammers it, effectively spamming with emails the maintainers. But that's not enough, he hammers the mailing lists and contacts directly the (very busy) maintainers just for good measure. He doesn't get what he wants because he is being obtuse and ridiculous, so he decides to elevate this to the head maintainer and emails him directly, insisting actions to be taken to indulge his caprice. Maybe he even posts on twitter to get other people with nothing better to do on his side and exert pressure. Maybe, just maybe, this person feels excited and warm inside as he posts on twitter. He did it again. People will engage in meaningless rhetoric about things that are not really there and he is center of it all. Oh, the hours spent going back and forth and back again and all the ATTENTION. But the head maintainer sees right through it and will have none of it, so he just blocks this person from stirring drama YET again in the future. Not saying this happened, just fyi, but it's possible, even probable, one might think. And after all, here we are, creating rhetoric about things of absolutely no significance whatsoever.
- ironholds 11y agoWhat on earth are you on about? I opened a bug report, asked some people on Twitter to affirm it wasn't just me, and that's it. Maybe, just maybe, you're a pulling conspiracy theories out of mid-air.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoThis is not censorship, like, at all; people get a free speech right, not a feeling inclusion in any community right.