5 ms·
Amazon-Macmillan fight heats up: "Available everywhere except Amazon"
- shib71 17y agoI think some form of this confrontation was inevitable. It's good to shake up an industry now and then to shake off outdated practices. Unfortunately for Macmillan I think it will mostly be their practices that fall short. Publishing houses don't have exclusive control of supply any more, and tactics that depend on that control (like price control) won't be as effective.
- electromagnetic 17y agoPublishing houses do, in fact, have near exclusive control of supply. The fact is, the major publishing houses don't cooperate very often, but Amazon has to be exceptionally careful in the game it's playing. An industry wide boycott of Amazon for publishing books would devastate the company, and would be entirely legal. It would also render the kindle exceptionally useless if people can't buy bestsellers or virtually any genre titles available. Publishing houses have 100% exclusive control over the supply of bestsellers, which make up almost 80% of book sales annually. The publishing industry is a very docile group and pulls none of the shit the music, movie and television industries pull. Poking a sleeping bear is a bad idea, and the publishing industry is a $40 billion dollar industry in the US alone, while Hollywood movies are a ~$50 billion dollar industry globally. The UK alone adds another ~$44 billion dollars to the publishing industries pocket (yes, Britons buy ~5 times more books than Americans). Publishing is a gargantuan industry globally. I would seriously hate to see what would happen to Amazon as book sales attribute ~60% of their bottom line, meaning industry controlled best sellers likely make ~50% of their revenue and on $24 billion in sales, they're only posting <$1 billion net income.
- etherael 17y agoYou sound like you have a good grasp on the economics of publishing; what do you think are the chances of publishers being cut out by tactics like Amazon's current 70% royalty for authors selling books through them directly between 2.99 and 9.99?
- electromagnetic 17y agoZero, unless Amazon implements advances. The time inherent in writing a book is immense, some best selling authors only manage 1 entire book inside 3 years, whilst some are rather prolific with multiple titles inside a year. You're never going to attract anyone's attention, even paying high royalties, if you can't pay them for their time in advance. The real issue is though that self-publishing means self-everything. Advertising, marketing, cover design, distribution; everything. You're turning a writer into a contractor, they either have to do everything themselves and take forever, or they have to sub-contract. As most writers are writers by choice it seems, quite frankly, moronic why anyone would think they'd want to be anything else. It took years for most authors to ever get published, so why would they ever accept a deal that meant they'd only spend 30% of their time doing what they wanted? They had that when they were doing a real job. This isn't even concerning the major fact that all the talent is in the publishing industry already. Authors aren't going to be able to release the brilliantly edited books that are well marketed, distributed in multiple countries and often in multiple languages, with artistically designed covers. Doing all of those to a professional degree is as lucky as shooting yourself in the head and having no brain damage whatsoever despite a visible hole through your brain; I believe walking on water is more frequently reported. Simply put a mass self-publishing route would inevitably end up with everything been done by the publishing industry, now retitled as the 'self-publishing' industry that takes an 85%-90% cut of your book sales. Only this way, you don't get an advance and you'll likely have to pay the 'self-publishing industry' thousands to get them to cover all the work in advance of any foreseen profits. Essentially authors have the choice between the publishing industry where you can get paid anywhere between ~$5,000 and $2 million to write a book. Or you can choose 'self-publishing' where you'll likely have to pay a minimum of ~$50,000 to get quality editing, distribution, cover art and most costly of all marketing. With $10,000 being an average advance in the industry for a first novel, who's going to pay $50,000 potentially for nothing? Especially considering that if you go with the industry, if your book doesn't sell a single copy they're out $90,000 plus the $10,000 they gave you and you are legally entitled to keep. Right now the publishing houses don't buy out the first electronic publishing rights from the author or the electronic republishing rights. It's only going to be a matter of time before they do, which means authors advances will increase accordingly. If the publishing industry takes on the similar 70/30 to the author, then the advances could potentially increase dramatically if e-book sales really take off. However, again, after editing and marketing, this would likely be closer to 30/70 to the author.
- jrockway 17y agoI wanted to buy this book, but Amazon didn't have it, so I just bought a different book instead. Basically, if you want me to buy something, and Amazon doesn't have it, you will have to make me really want it. Amazon can ship to my house overnight for $4, and I can buy stuff with one click. (In the case of e-books, the book is sent directly to my Kindle. Nobody else does that.) Making me go elsewhere means I have to deal with inconsistent shipping times, giving someone new my credit card details, etc., etc. Usually, this is way too much of a hassle, and instead I just pass on your product and settle for something from Amazon instead. (And BTW, I'm a published author, and it doesn't matter to me how much Amazon sells my books for. They can pay people to take them off their hands for all I care. I get a fixed amount for every book sold. The publisher, not the author, loses out when Amazon wants the books to be cheaper. But of course, they don't really lose out -- there are a lot of benefits to being available from Amazon.)
- yequalsx 17y agoI've got the same attitude. For many years now I've had the attitude that if I can't buy it on Amazon then I'm not buying it. I don't strictly hold to this attitude for everything but I do when it comes to books.
- padmanabhan01 17y agoReally? If I can't find it in Amazon, I would go to Barnes and Nobles or somewhere else, but I can't imagine buying a different book because it's not available in Amazon.. But then, none I have wanted have been unavailable there.yet.
- electromagnetic 17y agoSeveral I have wanted have been out of stock, but were in stock on Indigo online and in their stores. When I want to buy a certain book, I'm buying it from whomever has it. I love Amazon, I bought several of my christmas presents off of them and I've spent a small fortune with Amazon, however if they don't have what I want in stock I'm going elsewhere. I'm sorry, but if a brick-and-mortar store can have several copies in stock at several stores, why the hell doesn't Amazon have it?
- foobar2k 17y agoI find it amusing that they took out a full page ad in a print newspaper.
- patio11 17y agoDoomed industries have to stick together. OK, that's totally snark. Let me try again: the traditional media industries are very incestuous in both intellectual and business senses. For example, the publishers' pretty much sole marketing resource is trying to get books approved by tastemakers like the NYT reviewers or to get them into the best sellers lists maintained by, again, the NYT. In return, they spend most of their advertising budgets doing big media buys at the same tastemakers. Both sides think this is totally above board and would never influence reviewing decisions. Everyone knows that crass lucre only affects massive multinational companies in bad industries like pharma or cigarettes rather than good industries like journalism or media, after all. Relatedly, both publishers and traditional media are mostly missing the boat with their online strategies, because they're wedded to the physical distribution model, the cost structure they've built to support it, and the revenue models dictated by that cost structure. They're largely resistant to disruptive innovation on top of that, despite the fact that it would present absurdly huge advantages to their business. (For example, upwards of 80% of sales of most books happen within a 3 month release window. That's insane for content that does not rot, but the publishing industry puts out so many books that it is impossible to physically stock them all, and the large channels rotate at a dizzying speed. If they were to embrace online distribution, aggressive crosspromotion, etc, they could still be selling appreciable amounts of books written in 1986. That is pretty close to free money -- they've already got the rights to the book and have long since paid their sunk costs on the book. There is just a massive organizational and cultural failure to take bold steps like this.
- ssp 17y agoThe problem for Amazon is that they don't have much unique value to provide besides their brand and scale. The good experience, the Kindle etc., can all be replicated. If Amazon starts squeezing the publishers, some of them might leave and open the door for niche competitors selling things at high prices that you can't get elsewhere. Once that happens, Amazon loses something important: That you don't ever have to go elsewhere. So the fact that Amazon is so dominant and needs to stay dominant can be used against them. This gives publishers somewhat more leverage than you'd think.
- ebrenes 17y agoAmazon also has the Amazon Marketplace, which allows third-parties to sell goods through the Amazon website. A third-party could just sell those Macmillan books. And there would be nothing Macmillan can do about it since certain jurisdictions protect the rights of third-parties to resell items, like books. So a savvy Marketplace user would realize the potential of stocking Macmillan books and selling them through Amazon to cater exactly to those users who want them but can't get them through Amazon. Amazon would be more limited on the digital front, since that's a much trickier area, legally.
- gte910h 17y agoI am an avid amazon prime user. If it's not at amazon, I doubt I'll buy it anymore.