3 ms·
In both cases you describe, the company with the higher cap is the more "powerful" company though. In example one, they have a lot more control of their destin
by jedberg 11y ago
In both cases you describe, the company with the higher cap is the more "powerful" company though. In example one, they have a lot more control of their destiny since they have debt and not more shareholders.
In number two they have more control because if an opportunity comes up that costs say 10 billion, Company B can act on that and Company A cannot.
- whack 11y ago> In number two they have more control because if an opportunity comes up that costs say 10 billion, Company B can act on that and Company A cannot. You missed the example completely. Both companies raised $10B, either through debt or equity, and both of them spent/invested the money immediately. Net result: both of them have equal amounts of cash in the bank. But one of them has a market cap $10B higher than the other. Simply because of a tactical choice they made in financing. There are minor advantages/disadvantages involved in debt vs equity financing. However, these differences are all 2nd order effects. At a macro level, they have remarkably similar financial outcomes. Read up on Modigliani-Miller Theorem if you don't get this concept.
- jedberg 11y agoRead your own examples again. Example two was the one with the dividends.
- kgwgk 11y ago> In both cases you describe, the company with the higher cap is the more "powerful" company though. In example one, they have a lot more control of their destiny since they have debt and not more shareholders. The company with the higher market cap is the one that raised $10bn using equity and not debt. You could say that the company with more equity has more control of their destiny as it has less debt (equity is owned by the company shareholders, debt is owned by third parties), but this is not what you wrote.