3 ms·
Can someone well-versed in train operation help explain the difference between operating a train on these kinds of routes and schedules and, say, operating a tr
by rconti 11y ago
Can someone well-versed in train operation help explain the difference between operating a train on these kinds of routes and schedules and, say, operating a tractor-trailer or bus?
The article keeps mentioning the difficult tasks of operating the train -- obey every speed limit sign, every trackside control, speed up here, slow down there. But it doesn't illustrate how these demands are different from the demands placed on the operators of other vehicles. If anything, it seems tractor trailer and bus driver schedules are far more demanding, and they have even more things to look out for while operating their vehicles.
On the side of the difficulties of operating a train, I can see how the endless line of tracks unfurling in front of you can be mesmerizing/tiring (like driving in a snowstorm), and how the 'relative' safety of being secured to tracks can lull you into a false sense of security on stretches where speed changes are not required. Furthermore, of course, the demands of keeping a train on the right set of tracks through various switches can be difficult, because trucks don't face the same risk of head-on collisions with no ability to stop or veer off course at the last second.
Still, without knowing anything about the difficulty of operating the train controls themselves, I find myself wanting for more information to illustrate the unusual demands placed on train operators that are not placed on other long-haul motor vehicle operators. I don't dispute that it's a demanding job, and the consequences greater than those of crashing a tractor trailer, but I'm unable to understand how without more information.
- mentat 11y agoI'd guess that the amount of momentum in a quickly moving train makes any changes take a lot longer to take place and mistakes harder to address in time. You don't just stamp the brakes to stop or push the accelerator to speed up. The cycle time on system changes requires "tending".
- rconti 11y agoOthers also pointed out trains are big and heavy, which I thought of more in terms of an advantage (doesn't exactly speed up all that quickly) or neutral in terms of impact on the conductor (if it crashes, yes, it's a big deal, but assuming it doesn't, it's not). I hadn't thought about it in terms of cycle time and 'tending' as you mention. You're right that having to plan things ahead, and watching the consequences of your earlier actions unfold slowly can be quite stressful. I imagine it also demands much more in terms of multi-tasking because you can't just respond to an immediate need, you need to keep more 'balls in the air' at a given point in time because of how slowly the controls respond. Excellent point, thank you.
- Symbiote 11y agoI think planning ahead is the main thing, resulting from the huge momentum of the train and the low friction with the track. It's essential to stop in the correct places, but it's also necessary to keep accelerations smooth (we don't want all the wagons bumping together, or slipping wheels), including up and downhill. Driving must also be efficient, and with good planning it's easily possible to coast many miles on a slight gradient. (Did everyone just get off the train at the stadium? Then the braking distance will change. Except it's raining now, so it's longer.) Acknowledge every signal, and run to time — being early means being stopped, which is wasteful (and annoying for passengers, if this is a passenger train), being late means delaying other trains. -- I read some of the accident reports from the British RAIB, since they're often interesting. It's hardly ever one failure, even for something that seems straightforward. Some of the reports show charts of management structures, since many problems come down to organizational mismanagement — the safety equipment exists, but perhaps wasn't maintained, or a fault wasn't repaired soon enough. By doing 50-page investigations into accidents (or near-misses) with no injuries, hopefully serious accidents will be avoided — and it seems to work, I think it's the safest railway network in the world. List of all publications: https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/catalogue-of-investigation-reports-and-bulletins https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/catalogue-of-inves... Recent example (PDF) https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/491086/R012016_160111_Washwood_Heath.pdf https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm... — a 49 page report for an accident with no injuries.
- djsumdog 11y agoTrains are not buses. They are massive. A train running at full til can take several kilometres to slow down, and it most slow down gradually. The emergency air brake is a last resort and can cause derailment itself. Even trams, much smaller than trains, require quite a bit of stopping room. Rails are so much more efficient and carry a ton more passengers. It's sad the American train infrastructure is in such sorry shape. European rails are an essential form of travel, and even their oldest stock have these basic safety features (although they don't help if they're turned off; like in that recent high speed French wreck on its final test run).
- mikey_p 11y agoI suppose buses are similar, but at least for long haul truck drivers you have much more freedom in the way things are going. Need to take a bathroom break? Pull over at the next rest area? Hungry? Stop and get food. You can't exactly pull a train over at the next gas station if you need to grab a coffee or some Advil. That's a huge difference right there.
- digler999 11y agoOne principle difference is that the rails and momentum dictate where you go. All you can do is gradually speed up and gradually slow down. They have between 2 and 4 tracks on that corridor and they dont necessarily stay on the same one during the entire trip. You need to make sure you are on the correct track. You have to radio in at specific markers to let the controller know where you are. If you fail to radio in, they might assume you're AWOL and order an emergency shutdown of neighboring trains. You have to make sure you have a green light for the particular track you're on at every signal. Tracks are a scarce resource, if you go too slowly or make a mistake, you are delaying every train behind yours (times the hundreds of people in each one). You need to use energy efficiently: too much juice and you will grind the wheels, or waste energy by not accelerating at the optimal rate or braking un-necessarily. You have to control your speed exactly for the particular section of rail you're on.