4 ms·
"Positive thinking", in various forms, is standard practice for therapy with depression and anxiety (both generally highly correlated with negative thoughts and
by Jtsummers 11y ago
"Positive thinking", in various forms, is standard practice for therapy with depression and anxiety (both generally highly correlated with negative thoughts and fantasies; very pessimistic, worst case sort of thinking). The near-term benefits of it are incredibly useful, it can get people out of their current, negative, mental situations. But identifying long-term problems with it is important. It may seem obvious to some, but if there's not a strong link between the two measured over a population, you can't know how bad it may or may not be. It could be that a large percentage ends up slipping back into depression after the original therapy efforts in which case, yeah, the method has problems or needs better follow-up. Or it could be that some (small) percentage gets trapped in the fantasies and fails to actualize them. It's still important to find methods to help them, but the scale of the problem has to be measured to understand what's happening and why.
- sebringj 11y agoI wonder if there is a similarity in this case: Being in a state of hunger makes one feel hungry and long for food, perhaps even dream of it while sleeping. A temporary therapy would be to have the person imagine they are full, pressing in their stomach. Would that work temporarily? Maybe. But the underlying problem is still there. I don't know.