17 ms·
The only big thing that Slack has over IRC is being able to catch up on what was said earlier. However, to be honest, for open source projects, 'chat' of any k
by davidw 11y ago
The only big thing that Slack has over IRC is being able to catch up on what was said earlier.
However, to be honest, for open source projects, 'chat' of any kind should be for quick and unimportant discussions, or help. Important decisions should be hashed out on mailing lists so that people in other time zones can participate, so they get archived, and so people can take their time to write something that is well-reasoned.
- yarrel 11y agoA screen session, a bouncer, Quassel, or ircCloud can all allow you to catch up with irc. And don't suddenly bite you at 10,000 messages. ;-)
- prg318 11y agoTo be fair to your first point, if you set up a bouncer or use a client inside of screen/tmux you can absolutely catch up on what was said earlier in IRC.
- bjt 11y agoAnd then you're back to the "easier to use" point. Maintaining an IRC bouncer is a chore that only an uber geek could love.
- snuxoll 11y agoReally? I just leave irssi running on my linode, I don't even bother running a local client most of the time, I just SSH in and use it. The only exception is when I'm on mobile, and I have irssi-proxy running for that one special case.
- hellofunk 11y agoCool.. but I think you just underscored bjt's point.
- davidw 11y agoI think part of this debate is that for some people, the above is a pretty normal and easy way of doing things, and for others, it's a large barrier to entry.
- prg318 11y agoIf setting up an IRC client is a large barrier to entry for a coder, I would have some serious doubts about the merits of their code.
- an_account 11y ago"Uber geek"
- snuxoll 11y agoReally, having a $10 VPS and using screen or tmux is "uber-geek"? Look, if you can code in virtually any programming language I'd like to think you have the ability to use screen and irssi in under 10 minutes. We are talking specifically about open source projects, not general IM across a business (though I'd still use IRC there, just give everyone hexchat/xchat/whatever nice GUI client you want). For end-user support people are still more than capable of using a desktop IRC client, as evidenced by the WEALTH of people that ask questions on #fedora, #debian, #ubuntu, etc every single day.
- kefka 11y agoNo, having a cheap VPS handle automatable tasks isn't ubergeek. Setting up Node-red on a VPS, and logging a dozen IRC rooms you're interested in, storing in a MongoDB, and creating a search DB... over TOR is being an "uber-geek". And it took me 10 minutes to set up. No programming required, interestingly enough.
- jeena 11y ago> having a $10 VPS Oh yes that is definitely uber-geek.
- mikeash 11y agoWe're talking about chats for open source programming projects, not the local book club. In that context, setting up an IRC bouncer or running a command line client in tmux on a VPS is not really a high bar.
- st3v3r 11y agoIt is if you want the project to appeal to a wide range of people, besides just techies.
- kuschku 11y agoReally? Ever seen IRCCloud or Quassel? Simple "one-click" "just works™" IRC bouncers, perfectly integrating.
- lmm 11y agoIRCCloud costs money these days, and it's no more open-source than Slack in any case.
- kaiizen 11y agoI set my ZNC up in 5 minutes and haven't touched it in 2 years other than to change my silly vhosts.
- st3v3r 11y agoWhich is additional configuration to pay for and/or take the time to set up. And that you have to think ahead enough to realize you need this before you actually need it.
- jeena 11y agoI often have the situation that I asked someone something, then the next day, or next month I have the same problem again and want to search for that one link or answer without bothering everyone again. That is not possible with IRC (yet?)
- WizzleKake 11y agoIRC clients can log.
- zyxley 11y agoAnd if the person who wants to refer to something was offline at the time...?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThen you set up a bot that logs on channel (there are even dedicated services for that). Or use a client on a remote server to which you then connect (e.g. weechat).
- jeena 11y agoIt works mostly like this: I have a problem, let's say with QML, I log into their IRC server, ask the question and it is fixed. Then I don't work with QML for a month or two, then I remember that during the session two months ago they also linked to some cool tool but I can't find the link anymore (for example), I would like to be able to go back there and just search for my conversation. In the meantime I wasn't in that chanel or logged in into that server. But perhaps I'm wanting too much from a chat system.
- zyxley 11y agoAnd if the person who wants to refer to something was offline at the time...?
- bzbarsky 11y agoMozilla solves this by having logs for the developer IRC channels by just having a bot that puts up the logs on a web server. E.g. see http://logs.glob.uno/?c=developers http://logs.glob.uno/?c=developers
- snuxoll 11y agoFedora uses IRC for all the various group meetings and it works out pretty well, IMO.
- LaSombra 11y ago> The only big thing that Slack has over IRC is being able to catch up on what was said earlier. What happens when a topic of discussion is debated intensely on a different timezone and you wake up to more than 500 messages to read? Do you read them all? I think this is a reason for people who really don't engage on IRC for anything other than "Hi, I have a problem, can anyone help me?". If you do anything meaningful and engage on different channels you know there is no keep up with everything being said or discussed. Sorry if I sound harsh but I keep hearing the same tiring argument and keep pointing people to the same thing over and over and over. If you want IRC and history, please use an IRC bouncer. With Docker and cheap hosting solutions it's almost a no brainer. Do one better, add SSL to your bouncer and connect to, at least on Freenode, using SSL as well. Win-win.
- kylec 11y ago> What happens when a topic of discussion is debated intensely on a different timezone and you wake up to more than 500 messages to read? Do you read them all? It's your choice if you want to read them or not. This is better than IRC, because IRC doesn't give you that choice.
- Bjartr 11y agoThe reason you keep hearing the same things over and over is because people keep giving technical solutions to experience problems, and so aren't really solving the problem. IMO this is one more example of a technical community being generally dismissive of the importance of user experience. UX is THE reason Slack gained the traction it did. And I don't just mean in the client, I mean also mean the experience of going from zero to having everything working with the expected bells and whistles and the experience of adding a new feature. There is real value in being able to set it all up in three minutes and a couple of clicks without having to learn the technical underpinnings of a platform well enough to bring up a server and find and configure a bunch of individual bots.
- davidw 11y agoWell, we are discussing chat for open source projects, rather than, say, what to use at a company. Some technical knowledge might be expected in this crowd.
- bluedino 11y ago>> The only big thing that Slack has over IRC is being able to catch up on what was said earlier. What about all the integrations with other services?
- davidw 11y agoWhat do I need that for for my open source project? I could probably get github notifications, or bugs, or something via a bot in IRC if I wanted, but I just don't see the need. Chat is by its nature not supposed to be the hub of an open source project, because it's a real time thing in a distributed group of people who may not be able to do real time. Those things can be kind of cool for a company, but when I'm hanging out, on, say #postgres, it's to ask a question or discuss functionality, not see pull requests roll through the screen.
- Karunamon 11y agoChat is by its nature not supposed to be the hub of an open source project, because it's a real time thing in a distributed group of people who may not be able to do real time. From this, it sounds like the only substantive difference you're hung up on is message persistence. If that's being provided by a stable third party (i.e. a log bot, the technical details of which are irrelevant), what else are you missing?
- davexunit 11y agoPeople have been building IRC bots for decades that integrate with other services.
- bluedino 11y agoVery true, but there is a ton of stuff that Slack provides out of the box.