4 ms·
From the beginning of the story: > In much of Asia and Europe, engineers are protected by a technology known in the United States as positive train control, or
by danso 11y ago
From the beginning of the story:
> In much of Asia and Europe, engineers are protected by a technology known in the United States as positive train control, or P.T.C...Amtrak has been working on its own in-house version of P.T.C., called the Advanced Civil Speed Enforcement System, or Acses, for almost a decade. But owing to insufficient funding and a row with the F.C.C., which Amtrak said had been slow to approve the use of the requisite radio bandwidth, its actual implementation has been piecemeal. At the time of the accident, large portions of the Northeast Corridor, including Frankford Junction, were not online. Practically speaking, that meant engineers were working with no safety net.
Near the end of the story:
> In late May, Joseph Boardman, Amtrak’s C.E.O. and president, promised that the installation of P.T.C. on the Northeast Corridor would be completed by the end of 2015, a pledge he has kept: Today, the system is active on all routes, with the exception of substantial stretches of track owned by the State of Connecticut. (A spokesman for the Connecticut Department of Transportation said it hoped to have P.T.C. installed on all state-owned track by 2018.)
A technology that had stalled for a decade -- for ostensibly "hard" and "complicated" reasons -- is completed within months after a disaster. Just goes to show how much tragedy and politics has an effect on implementation and prioritization of engineering improvements.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoThere are also PTC problems that need to be ironed out so that mistakes don't cause unnecessary delays http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-metrolink-delays-20160201-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-metrolink-dela...
- ewindisch 11y agoReportedly, the P.T.C. system had already been scheduled for a 2015 installation. This accident is likely speeding up the installation on other tracks, but I'm not certain that the Northeast Corridor really got this upgrade much faster simply because of this accident. EDIT: but yes, it's highly political. It's sickening as someone that grew up not far from where this accident happened and still travel the NE Corridor several times a year.
- chishaku 11y agoFor understanding the scope of the political problem, the American Society of Civil Engineers has an infrastructure scorecard. The national scorecard for 2013: Dams D Drinking Water D Hazardous Waste D Levees D- Solid Waste B- Wastewater D Aviation D Bridges C+ Inland Waterways D- Ports C Rail C+ Roads D Transit D Public Parks & Recreation C- Schools D Energy D+ Pennsylvania got a B for Rail in 2014. Michigan got a D for Drinking Water in 2009 (most recent grade). http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/ http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
- vinay427 11y ago>Michigan got a D for Drinking Water in 2009 (most recent grade). As someone living in Michigan, perhaps it was propped up (to the national average, which is already terrible) by the various municipalities that are fairly wealthy and funded.
- e_hup 11y agoI don't know anything about the American Society of Civil Engineers, but don't they have every reason to make these grades as low as possible?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- themartorana 11y agoThis seems unnecessarily conspiratorial considering we know for a fact that the US's infrastructure is literally crumbling beneath our cars and trucks.
- ghaff 11y agoNot to say that there aren't issues, but "crumbling US infrastructure" has been an on-again off-again news story for literally decades during which time we've had periods like the stimulus package for "shovel-ready" projects. I suspect infrastructure spending, especially in a country as large as the US, is essentially an unlimited sinkhole.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]