4 ms·
I can't say I'm feeling sorry for the counterfeiters. Now it sucks if you got suckered into thinking you had bought one thing and ended up with another, back wh
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I can't say I'm feeling sorry for the counterfeiters. Now it sucks if you got suckered into thinking you had bought one thing and ended up with another, back when RAM was both expensive and in short supply(and Intel was still making it) it was not uncommon to have "grey market" RAM with Intel markings but substandard chips.
It is always interesting to see the mechanics at play too, people who get counterfeit chips are more often (but not always) people who have released all "quality" requirements in order to achieve the lowest possible price. As being price preferred they put themselves at risk of getting substandard parts, and then when they get parts that don't work or work anomalously, they frame that problem as someone else's problem rather than their own choice.
In the referenced forum post you have a person using "Chinese clone" Arduino nanos which happen to have chips on them that report as FTDI USB to serial converters but are in fact something else. So drop the vendor or have the vendor write their own USB driver for windows but why hate on FTDI for identifying the bogus chip and refusing to work with it?
- bri3d 11y agoBecause they're breaking the consumer's experience, not the vendor's. I guess their assumption is that angry consumers will trickle up to the vendor and cause them to go "genuine," but that seems unlikely to me. Why? Because as a consumer, I have no way of knowing whether the FTDI product I'm buying is genuine. It adds risk to buying anything that says "FTDI" on it. I'm not going to vote with my wallet for some nebulous, unverifiable assertion that a chip will be real FTDI before I get it. I'm going to vote for something I know I can plug in and use. Already a lot of counterfeit users of FTDI (i.e. knockoff Arduinos and cheap "VAG-COM KKL" auto diagnostic cables) are switching to CH340 instead of buying real FTDI.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI agree, and then the consumer decides it isn't worth buying the knock-offs, and the vendor switches to something which costs more than their counterfeit but isn't as expensive as the FTDI parts and we're back to competing above ground rather than below ground. I'm hoping we can train consumers to not buy things based on "lowest price" without understanding what was done to achieve that price.
- tzs 11y ago> Already a lot of counterfeit users of FTDI (i.e. knockoff Arduinos and cheap "VAG-COM KKL" auto diagnostic cables) are switching to CH340 instead of buying real FTDI. The driver situation for CH340 seems a bit sketchy. Whenever I've considered buying cheap Arduino Uno R3 clones via aliexpress.com, but then first went searching for CH340 OS X drivers, all I've found have been drivers on random sites whose provenance seems to be "I found this somewhere". Often these are unsigned drivers so I'd have to disable driver signing to use them, although last time I looked there was a set of signed drivers floating around. For Arduino knockoffs, I prefer something that uses the same hardware that a genuine Arduino would use, or something that works with the CDC driver that comes with the OS. For Uno R3, this is the clone I'm using for development [1]. It uses an ATmega16u2 to handle the USB, which is what a genuine Uno R3 uses. [1] http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00P2FX9WY?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_search_detailpage http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00P2FX9WY?psc=1&redirect=t...
- kabdib 11y agoThe counterfeiters aren't the ones being punished. They're getting off scott free. The only thing the counterfeiters are losing is one of the chips they are fabricating. They're fabbing other fakes, they'll move on. And they can always try to push their pile of fake FTDI parts (it's sunk cost, and you can always find a sucker). FTDI is punishing everyone except the bad guys.
- CountSessine 11y agoThe counterfeiters aren't the ones being punished. They're getting off scott free. Why do you think that? A lot of players in the supply chain are enabling the counterfeiting. It's going to be very difficult for any of them to move inventory on those counterfeit chips.
- st3v3r 11y agoIf you're not able to use the counterfeit chips, then yes, they get punished, because people will stop buying them. And I'm sorry, but I cannot see fit to blame FTDI for not wanting to talk to counterfeit chips.
- CountSessine 11y agoI agree. And in a way, end users have to bear some of the responsibility for this mess too - we all benefit from lower-priced components because of the electronics supply chain in China that freely mixes in counterfeit parts. No one who benefits from a crime or from immoral behaviour can be said to be completely innocent. We don't absolve people who buy diamond jewelry of all responsibility for buying 'blood diamonds' - we say that consumers have to be aware of where diamonds come from and hold jewelers responsible for sourcing diamonds carefully. I think the really unfortunate lesson for small parts suppliers like FTDI is that if they really want to protect their IP from Chinese counterfeiters free-riding on their driver development work, they need to begin building designs that require software uploads, binary blobs, and key exchanging, none of which are good for open hardware development and open source software.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>No one who benefits from a crime or from immoral behaviour can be said to be completely innocent. Then there is no innocent person in existence and the term becomes meaningless. So, to avoid having to fully deprecate the term, we veto the above definition.