3 ms·
There are two main assumptions in those "where are they?" Scenario. One is that self replicating probes are feasible and the other is that ots practical for the
by simonh 11y ago
There are two main assumptions in those "where are they?" Scenario. One is that self replicating probes are feasible and the other is that ots practical for them to travel interstellar distances.
I think the problem of designing and building self replicating probes, capable of recreating themselves from asteroidal matter, is greatly underestimated. We currently have little to no idea how to design such a thing, and no real idea what the lower bound on the mass of such a thing might be.
The next problem is nterstellar travel. The difference un scale between traveling to the moon and travelling to a nearby star is about the same difference in scale between throwing a rock down a typical garden and launching astronauts to the moon. The Daudalus project did down good work on this and their very modest proble of just a few tons, doing a flyby of a nearby star, took a large to portion of the mass of Neptune to construct in terms of fuel. The resources available in a typical planetary system might not be up to the job.
I don't honk magic future technology hand waves these problems away. Any future technology will have to work with the same elements on the same periodic table we have now, manipulating the same physical forces we work with now. We can't wish magic unobtainable into existence and the limits of what is achievable with matter and energy are already pretty much computable.
So it really may well be that going sustainably interstellar might be impractical.
- poopchute 11y agoThe mass number you through out (large portion of the mass of Neptune) seemed really off to me so I looked it up and found some comparisons. For a flyby: Daedalus mass = 5.0 * 10^7 kg (500 kg of scientific equipment) With a slowdown to stay in the system: Daedalus mass = 10^10 kg Mass of Neptune: 10^26 kg So even for an extended stay, the mass of the Daedalus is no where close to a significant portion of Neptune. I looked for equivalent mass objects, here is a few: 1.4 * 10^18 = all oceans on earth combined 10^12 kg = 1.4km diameter asteroid (Icarus) 3.5 * 10^10 kg = 0.5 x 0.3 x 0.2 dimension asteroid (Itokawa) Estimates put the number of asteroids larger than 1km diameter in the belt between mars and Jupiter at 750,000 These are just straight mass conversions, no idea about the real content of fuel. If all those asteroids were straight fuel then you could launch upwards of a million Daedalus class ships that stay in the orbit of their target star.
- simonh 11y agoI was thinking of the successor project, Icarus. It's not the mass of the probe, it's the mass of the gas giant's atmosphere you need to process to extract the Helium-3.