3 ms·
I believe it's called (job) security by obscurity. UNIX didn't need to be full of obscure commands that are impossible to guess. The fact that it is locks out
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
I believe it's called (job) security by obscurity.
UNIX didn't need to be full of obscure commands that are impossible to guess. The fact that it is locks out outsiders, but doesn't necessarily improve efficiency.
It's perfectly possible to make dev systems that are useful but not too complicated for beginners. Hypercard and VBA are just two examples.
But the language syntax is a small part of that. Ease of availability, and direct applicability - being able to see a clear personal benefit to writing code - are at least as important.
VBA isn't an outstandingly fine language, but a lot of people got a lot done with it - because it's obvious how you can save time with it, and that provides a motivation to use it.
The point of Haskell is more obscure.
> You make it easier by expanding them
I think it depends on the language and the target audience. You make it easier for developers by expanding them. But there are forces in CS that benefit from obscurity and Yet Another Framework - not least academic CS, and the GitHub scramble for self-promotion.
CS pretends to be mathematical, but languages and development systems are cultural and social phenomena, designed as much to promote or deny certain kinds of relationships with other devs and with technology as to get useful shit done quickly and easily.
- moron4hire 11y agoYou know, I recently had reason to implement a BASIC interpreter (A bit of an art project, a bit of code archaeology. I wanted to be able to get a specific, 40-year-old code listing running without change) and in the process, ended up with something that was surprisingly simple, fun, and productive. I was surprised with myself how little I missed case-sensitivity, or how natural "LET" and "CALL" felt for variable assignment and subroutine execution. I ended up extending my demo further to discard manual line numbering, unify functions and subroutines, and even started on a basic object system. It was quite a lot of fun and I am considering returning to the concept some day. > You make it easier for developers Right, that is correct. But kittens eventually grow to become cats. I think you can have a simple base-system that doesn't require knowledge of the more complex devices, but still has them in the tool box for when the user grows.
- eastWestMath 11y agoI don't think you understand that a programming language is a formal language that gets interpreted by a machine. It's pretty much mathematical logic the whole way down, and the fact that you can think they're a cultural/social phenomenon is a testament to the amazing work PL researchers have done over the years.
- naasking 11y ago> UNIX didn't need to be full of obscure commands that are impossible to guess. Why should commands should be easy to guess? That seems like a bizarre property to expect of a command language. UNIX provides exploration and discovery via man and apropos commands. > The point of Haskell is more obscure. That's a ridiculous assertion. The point of Haskell is to be rigourous. If that makes it obscure, it's only because the problems it's solving are also obscure and poorly understood.