"What I think Dawkins has done is brought back a particularly virulent form of original sin. He’s actually a deeply religious thinker – ‘We are born selfish the

"What I think Dawkins has done is brought back a particularly virulent form of original sin. He’s actually a deeply religious thinker – ‘We are born selfish therefore let us try to teach altruism’, 'If your genes are selfish, you are.'" Both are surely not the quotes from Dawkins but Newman's own and wrong conclusions. Genes != whole animals (or humans). Especially the "interest" of the genes doesn't have to reflect in all aspects of the behavior to eliminate cooperation.