8 ms·
Born Poor? Santa Fe economist Samuel Bowles says you better get used to it
- mtalantikite 17y agoHe's an interesting guy, he used to teach econ over at UMass Amherst when I was studying it there. One of his colleagues/research partners has a good evolutionary game theory book available for free on his website for anyone interested: http://people.umass.edu/gintis/ http://people.umass.edu/gintis/ It's called "Game Theory Evolving"
- evgen 17y agoUnfortunately, the book is not available but only a few pages from each chapter. Too bad, it looked interesting...
- mtalantikite 17y agoOh, sorry about that -- he used to have all of it up there last I looked through it. Or maybe that was because we were students and it was at a course page rather than his personal page.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- emilind 17y agoIt's a great book, and of all the game theory books I've seen it's the easiest and most enjoyable to read (not that it's easy).
- MarkPNeyer 17y agoThe article repeatedly contrasts Bowles with Friedman, but Friedman also supported a 'Negative Income Tax': http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax
- emilind 17y agoA demogrant and a NIT are different ideas.
- isleyaardvark 17y agoThe article makes some interesting points but there seems to be a flawed use of statistics. Particularly the part about "the percentage likelihood that a bottom 10 percenter will ever make it to the top 10 percent. For 99 out of 100 people, rags never lead to riches." Well, what would you expect? There's going to be a pure mathematical limit to that sort of movement, nevermind issues of income mobility. To take an absurd example, say there's a 50/50 chance of going from rags to riches. That would mean half of the bottom 10%, 5% of the population would move up to the top 10% of the population. And somehow the middle 80% don't manage that feat. You would expect the probability of going from the bottom to the very top would be low. Instead, the article tries to paint a negative picture. It points out there's a 32% chance a child born in the bottom 10% will stay in the bottom 10%, when you could just as well point out that child has a 68% chance of moving out of the bottom 10%. Bringing in statistics about how many of them move from that percentile to the highest percentile obscures rather than clarifies the issue of income mobility. Then there's his universal welfare idea, which at $250,000 per person and a quick back-of-the-envelope calculation would only cost about 56 trillion dollars. Plus another 2 trillion or so per year with population growth. That said it's worth reading, the “individual development accounts” idea is definitely interesting.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agotrying to paint those statistics as negative is hilarious on the articles part. we have insane mobility compared to any other society at any time in human history.
- eru 17y agoWhile our situation is quite good (and in absolute term probably the best ever), I doubt that we (=US 2010?) have "insane mobility" --- measured in actual turnover between quantiles of wealth from one generation to the next. Does anybody have some sources? (I'd guess it would be interesting to look at societies in great turmoil (e.g. England after 1066, French Revolution, Communist revolution in China) or societies with more equality of wealth than the US (e.g. Scandinavian countries). They may well have more mobility (at least in a purely technical sense).)
- apsec112 17y agoWhere is his proof? He has this whole elaborate theory of economics and inequality worked out, and not once does he present any proof.
- llimllib 17y agoI'm curious what form you expect that such a proof would take.
- apsec112 17y agoTo name but one example (of dozens), a study showing that countries with higher Gini coefficients are more prone to rioting, strikes and civil disorder, after accounting for income (third-world countries are obviously more prone than first-world) would qualify as proof of at least one part of the theory.
- llimllib 17y agoI agree with you 100% that the linked article sucks awfully. Your proposed study, however, is so riddled with confounding factors that to call it a proof is nonsense. The man the article talks about does have lots of papers giving evidence for his views, and you should indeed read them if you're interested. However, neither the study you propose nor any other study would constitute proof (of what? it's unclear what we're even discussing a proof of). All I'm trying to say is, this is about human affairs, not physics, and we're not about to start finding proofs of human affairs.
- ibsulon 17y agoI'd start at http://tuvalu.santafe.edu/~bowles/ http://tuvalu.santafe.edu/~bowles/ and his actual papers, not what a reporter writes. :)
- mynameishere 17y agoYou know damn well that's not useful. "Here, read through every single thing this guy wrote. The proof's gotta be there somewhere, I figure." No, of course, there's no proof for anything in any soft science, so there's the answer. The only good experiment would have to be on a grand scale: give everyone 15K a year for free and see what happens. My guess: An increase in the velocity of money, since the whole thing is basically a devaluation.
- chipsy 17y ago"Basic income" has been pilot-studied in Africa to great success. The reasoning is very simple: If you are living hand-to-mouth with unreliable income - so unreliable that you can essentially expect "the end of the world" to come at any time - then you cannot make any future plans around earning and saving; consuming as much as possible immediately holds more value. But if you have a government-guaranteed income, you can build plans around that - you can pursue the risky project, you can start the startup, you can go to school, etc. One anecdote I read(this was years ago) involved a woman who built up a flock of chickens from basic income. This lifted her out of poverty, since the chickens can pay for themselves with eggs in just a few months.
- teej 17y agoFor those more interested on the results of the pilot program in Nambia, you can read more about it in their report here: http://www.bignam.org/Publications/BIG_Assessment_report_08a.pdf http://www.bignam.org/Publications/BIG_Assessment_report_08a... I read through it and was pretty surprised at the findings. The increases in education and health are particularly staggering.
- coliveira 17y agoThe big decrease in poverty in Brazil in the last few years is due to a similar policy. The government in handling a salary to people living under the poverty level. It really has been the best investment that the government ever made.
- Perceval 17y agoWe have a rough approximation of that in the United States with the Earned Income Tax Credit. If you have a job but make less than a certain amount, the government sends you a tax return to supplement your income up to that level. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_Income_Tax_Credit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_Income_Tax_Credit
- viggity 17y agoI love how he tells his staffer to buy the printed book and not the version on the kindle. The author goes on to say that the printed book is marx, the kindle book is rand. History makes it pretty clear how your economy will wind up using marx's theories. Capitalism is the worst kind of economic structure out there, until you look at all the alternatives.
- tphyahoo 17y agotimtoady.
- emilind 17y agoDon't everybody gonna get hung up on the $250,000 demogrant. Bowles is a super interesting thinker (same for his frequent co-author, Herb Gintis). Bowles (and Gintis) are trying to synthesize agent-based modeling, evolutionary game theory, behavioral economics, mainstream economics together with the other social sciences. It's an ambitious project and absolutely necessary. Come to think of it, ff there's one economist who would appeal to functional programming eccentrics and polymaths it'd be Bowles. His papers are pretty readable for non-economists so if you're curious check out his homepage.
- snagage 17y agoI think the site might be down at the moment. Here's the link to the google cached page: http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache:ra7632stXRsJ:sfreporter.com/stories/born_poor/5339/all/+sfreporter.com+born+poor http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache:ra7632stXRsJ:sfreporter...
- nandemo 17y agoWhat’s troubling about this research is that poverty tends to persist through generations, no matter how individuals try to improve their circumstances. "Poor" young Americans are much wealthier than their grandfathers. The claim that "the poor stay poor" is largely an artifact of defining "poor" as "bottom 10% income".
- Perceval 17y agoThis article is pretty embarrassing in its use of numbers/statistics. The second number is how many jobs the state Economic Development Department claims to have created in Santa Fe last year. As if the state's economic development department were the main driver of job creation! Bowles argues that inequality is holding the United States back, but it's not clear that that's the case. You can see the chart of states arranged by gini coefficient, where rich dynamic centers of business like New York and California score highly. In contrast, Utah is the most equal state in the U.S., but is anyone flocking there? Does anyone want to reproduce Utah's social model throughout the rest of the country? Then the statistics for the top and bottom 10%--both groups have an approximately 30% chance that their offspring will stay in the same percentile of income distribution. But this means that 70% of rich kids are going to fall from grace, whereas 70% of poor kids are going to grow up to do better. And that's bad?