3 ms·
War and terrorism are different things. If I am amassing political power by putting people in fear of say, the United States, I ought to depict the US as a bun
by kristopolous 11y ago
War and terrorism are different things.
If I am amassing political power by putting people in fear of say, the United States, I ought to depict the US as a bunch of people to be feared.
So I show the political leaders saying that they want to kill us and I get more power. I show all the repressive state tactics of the Americans on their own people, I get more power. "Look", I say "Even at their sports games, the evil Americans treat their own citizens like they are in a prison!"
Make no mistake, much of this is puppetry in the same way that the cold war, or terrorism, or the reds etc was used as a mechanism to gain political power in the US.
Extreme things like this give an assist to facilitate a foreign orchestration of political attacks on the other (in this case, the US) and help them consolidate power. It's geopolitically and intrapolitically counter-productive --- well that is unless you are trying to control people through the forced-hand of FUD and not their actual consent.
If this is still hard, think of WW2. It was justified historically because of how Germans treated the Jews. Everyone is on board with the presumed necessary large scale destruction of Europe because of the holocaust. It was the internal horrific politics of the Nazis on people they considered foreigners which justify this.
If you want your people on board to what they think is a good, justifiable moral war, depicting your enemy as horrific and anti-freedom is a great effective way to do this. This only has to be true in the minds of the people you need to persuade - not objectively true in any sense.
These tactics enfold hawkism and make a mockery of diplomacy and civility. What kind of world do you want?
One where terrorism campaigns are a smashing success for winning local support or one where they don't actually work so people stop doing them?
- marcoperaza 11y ago>Make no mistake, much of this is puppetry in the same way that the cold war, or terrorism, or the reds etc was used as a mechanism to gain political power in the US. It turns out that protecting people from their enemies is (sometimes) good politics. It's very much a desired quality of a democracy, that politicians pursuing their own self-interests will be driven to pursue the interests of the people. Unfortunately, it can also work when the enemies are imagined or exaggerated. Again, we can only look to the particular circumstances for the answer. I take strong issue with your particular implication that the Cold War threat from the Soviet Union was in any sense overstated. If anything, McCarthy was more right about Soviet infiltration than he was ever given credit for until recently. That doesn't justify blacklists and the horrifying HUAC sessions; those are the self-defeating measures I was talking about. >So I show the political leaders saying that they want to kill us and I get more power. I show all the repressive state tactics of the Americans on their own people, I get more power. "Look", I say "Even at their sports games, the evil Americans treat their own citizens like they are in a prison!" There's a lot of clever propaganda against the US, but I can't imagine this being a big winner. And anyway, the ability of demagogues to twist our actions for their propaganda purposes cannot be an overriding consideration. The US is very rich and very powerful, so people will hate us no matter what we do. And if they can't find any facts to base it on, they'll just make some up. Defending 50,000 people's lives from an attack has to be the primary consideration.
- kristopolous 11y agoMilitary protection is the primary quality of feudalism, not democracy. The cold war threat from the soviet union was factually incorrect and had many theories like the domino theory which are irrefutably wrong. It was more about placing neoclassical economics as the only framework to think about markets. And if you don't know what I'm talking about it's because it was a huge success. And if you don't think anti American propaganda is what created groups like ISIL, I strongly advise you to do a very small bit of research just about anywhere - Wikipedia is probably fine. Heck, even conservapedia might be OK here. And finally, there's thousands of attack vectors daily. You have the subway system, theme parks, universities, tourist attractions, busy intersections, elementary schools, transport hubs, parades, celebrity at the local book store, water towers, shopping malls during the holidays, festivals, sporting events, music concerts... The probability of terrorism is very likely p < 0.001. More people will die traveling to and from the events by many orders of magnitude. Just like how you'll stop mass shootings is when you stop making the shooters celebrities, you'll stop terrorism when the entire world stops reacting in batshit crazy ways to it.
- marcoperaza 11y ago>If this is still hard, think of WW2. It was justified historically because of how Germans treated the Jews. Everyone is on board with the presumed necessary large scale destruction of Europe because of the holocaust. It was the internal horrific politics of the Nazis on people they considered foreigners which justify this. This is just not true. The plight of the Jews was not a major factor in the United States entering the war, or in the war at all for that matter. The US entered in response to a direct attack, though we could say that that was just the tipping point that escalated America's involvement to outright war. The underlying factors were the defense of allied democracies, and particularly the fear of a hostile international order where America would stand alone against the massive totalitarian regimes in Germany, Russia, and Japan, who likely would have controlled the rest of the world (and thus people and resources, and thus industrial capacity, and thus military might) between them. As for how we look back at it, Lincoln's formulation for the Civil War could apply just as well: [...]that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain—that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom—and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.
- kristopolous 11y agoCorrect. I referred to it as historically. I did not claim that the 1945 policies justified a 1941 entry. Unlike with say Desert Storm, the Spanish American War, Vietnam, Iraq round 2, Afghanistan, or the Korean War, nobody I've seen argues in hindsight that we should have stayed out of the European theater in WW2.