3 ms·
> Trust is critical. Almost all of us [GNU/]Linux users run at least a few prepackaged binaries on our systems. But they come from trustworthy sources such as b
by cyphar 11y ago
> Trust is critical. Almost all of us [GNU/]Linux users run at least a few prepackaged binaries on our systems. But they come from trustworthy sources such as big companies like Github. These proprietary binaries are usually vetted by security researchers as well to detect any malicious behaviour.
Speak for yourself. I explicitly have removed all proprietary software from my machine. The whole "vetted by security researchers" is such a vague metric with mixed results. One researcher will find 30 bugs while another will find 5 in the same time.
> Additionally, I'd recommend posting SHA checksums and offering a more traditional "Download" button as an alternative to the one-liner.
> TLDR: You're asking people to take a risk on a new project, without any indiciation of who's behind it or why they should trust you.
Which is why he should just release the source. Then trust isn't a factor. I don't trust random people on the internet. And no, I don't trust GitHub or whoever you want to pick.
- kbutler 11y ago> I explicitly have removed all proprietary software from my machine Video drivers? BIOS? These are possible, but every individual's weighting of the difficult trade-offs may be different.
- cyphar 11y agoI use Intel's free software drivers. I've got libreboot on one or two of my machines (the others are work machines, so I'm fairly sure my employer wouldn't let me flash libreboot onto the BIOS). I wish RISC-V and free hardware design FPGAs would be a thing soon so I can get rid of the proprietary Intel microcode. Not sure what I'll do about video then though.
- dmix 11y ago> I explicitly have removed all proprietary software from my machine. So you don't use a desktop operating system? Or smartphone?
- akerro 11y agoThere are several distributions that come with no binary blobs, it's not only trisquel, but also Arch (-libre- from AUR), he could compile Gentoo himself or any BSD with flags to remove the blobs... It's easier than you think.
- cyphar 11y agoI use Arch Linux, with the proprietary blobs shipped with Linux removed. As for a smartphone, yes I have a smartphone, and yes it does bother me that I cannot run one in freedom. This is a compromise that's necessary, and I am doing my best to find alternatives that are viable. Replicant is great, but it only supports 2G (which is known to be insecure at a protocol level). Ultimately, if someone was pitching a smartphone with free hardware designs and was running completely free (or free enough that it could be made completely free) software, I would totally pitch in >$1000 for such a project, even if the phone was only objectively worth $300. That's how important the future of software freedom is to me, personally. But you might have different views, and that's fine. I just wanted to make clear that trusting a proprietary software vendor is something that I find to be extremely foolish (they will always screw you over eventually).