11 ms·
The Wreck of Amtrak 188
- danso 11y agoFrom the beginning of the story: > In much of Asia and Europe, engineers are protected by a technology known in the United States as positive train control, or P.T.C...Amtrak has been working on its own in-house version of P.T.C., called the Advanced Civil Speed Enforcement System, or Acses, for almost a decade. But owing to insufficient funding and a row with the F.C.C., which Amtrak said had been slow to approve the use of the requisite radio bandwidth, its actual implementation has been piecemeal. At the time of the accident, large portions of the Northeast Corridor, including Frankford Junction, were not online. Practically speaking, that meant engineers were working with no safety net. Near the end of the story: > In late May, Joseph Boardman, Amtrak’s C.E.O. and president, promised that the installation of P.T.C. on the Northeast Corridor would be completed by the end of 2015, a pledge he has kept: Today, the system is active on all routes, with the exception of substantial stretches of track owned by the State of Connecticut. (A spokesman for the Connecticut Department of Transportation said it hoped to have P.T.C. installed on all state-owned track by 2018.) A technology that had stalled for a decade -- for ostensibly "hard" and "complicated" reasons -- is completed within months after a disaster. Just goes to show how much tragedy and politics has an effect on implementation and prioritization of engineering improvements.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoThere are also PTC problems that need to be ironed out so that mistakes don't cause unnecessary delays http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-metrolink-delays-20160201-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-metrolink-dela...
- ewindisch 11y agoReportedly, the P.T.C. system had already been scheduled for a 2015 installation. This accident is likely speeding up the installation on other tracks, but I'm not certain that the Northeast Corridor really got this upgrade much faster simply because of this accident. EDIT: but yes, it's highly political. It's sickening as someone that grew up not far from where this accident happened and still travel the NE Corridor several times a year.
- chishaku 11y agoFor understanding the scope of the political problem, the American Society of Civil Engineers has an infrastructure scorecard. The national scorecard for 2013: Dams D Drinking Water D Hazardous Waste D Levees D- Solid Waste B- Wastewater D Aviation D Bridges C+ Inland Waterways D- Ports C Rail C+ Roads D Transit D Public Parks & Recreation C- Schools D Energy D+ Pennsylvania got a B for Rail in 2014. Michigan got a D for Drinking Water in 2009 (most recent grade). http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/ http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
- vinay427 11y ago>Michigan got a D for Drinking Water in 2009 (most recent grade). As someone living in Michigan, perhaps it was propped up (to the national average, which is already terrible) by the various municipalities that are fairly wealthy and funded.
- e_hup 11y agoI don't know anything about the American Society of Civil Engineers, but don't they have every reason to make these grades as low as possible?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- themartorana 11y agoThis seems unnecessarily conspiratorial considering we know for a fact that the US's infrastructure is literally crumbling beneath our cars and trucks.
- ghaff 11y agoNot to say that there aren't issues, but "crumbling US infrastructure" has been an on-again off-again news story for literally decades during which time we've had periods like the stimulus package for "shovel-ready" projects. I suspect infrastructure spending, especially in a country as large as the US, is essentially an unlimited sinkhole.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pluckytree 11y agoIf this article is completely true, it’s sad to hear he would never pilot a train again even if exonerated. That sounds like how teachers are treated if a student accuses them of impropriety and their careers are over even if they are innocent. Is that a uniquely American thing?
- mturmon 11y agoYour analogy is not really valid. Although the NTSB is not talking, the cause is reported to be "loss of situational awareness". In essence, the conductor was in some degree at fault because he was controlling the speed and the train was going 105mph instead of 55mph. There could have been other contributing factors (rock, tough schedule), but it seems likely that their severity will not be known -- the information just is not there. Surely you would concede that the right course of action here is not obvious?
- bsder 11y agoActually, the right course of action is perfectly obvious--he should be restored to driving trains. No other train engineer has been scrutinized so carefully, and he came out with flying colors. Sadly, he will not be, because the company needs a scapegoat to cover their lack of adopting the technological safety system that can mitigate the human errors that are inherent in the current system. If he never drives a train again, every single manager in his chain should be fired--including the CEO as they made the choices to set the system up this way.
- Someone1234 11y agoCan I ask a stupid(?) question: So this Positive train control system seems super complicated. Dedicated radio frequencies, track signal loops, and so on. And all this complexity has been holding it up for years... So my question is this: Car navigation as a problem set is similar but massively harder than train navigation. My car can tell me speed limits, which lane to be in, and knows information about all major roads in the area. Why don't trains have a Google Maps-like system? You have 1/100th fewer "roads," you have directional assurances, you have speed limits set by a single authority (no city, state, federal distinction, etc), and so on. Heck if you've played Train Simulator you KNOW that they have all of this route information digitised somewhere. So why not just throw it in an app, hook up GPS, and get it deployed tomorrow instead of ten years from now? Is this a classic example of over-engineering the problem?
- dustingetz 11y agoamtrak operates at a loss, any investments need be approved by congress http://qz.com/409824/yes-amtrak-was-sabotaged-by-congress/ http://qz.com/409824/yes-amtrak-was-sabotaged-by-congress/
- mcpherrinm 11y agoThe simple answer: Trains can't stop quickly, and can't switch tracks easily. A car stays in lanes that go one way. Trains don't: they often share a segment of track for both directions, and you better be darn sure you're not going to run head-on into an oncoming train, or into a stopped one. Thus, trains need a lot more communications and coordination to ensure safety, unlike cars which use the rules of the road and quick maneuvering and stopping to adjust
- jonknee 11y agoThat still doesn't explain why a simple solution can't control speed limits (which would have prevented this accident).
- tyingq 11y agoThe barrier is likely the process through which PCT was mandated. Starting with this: https://www.fra.dot.gov/Elib/Document/2189 https://www.fra.dot.gov/Elib/Document/2189 "(3) POSITIVE TRAIN CONTROL SYSTEM.—The term ‘positive train control system’ means a system designed to prevent train-to-train collisions, over-speed derailments, incursions into established work zone limits, and the movement of a train through a switch left in the wrong position." The deadlines, definitions, etc, don't line up well with a "What can we do now, with existing tech, that would add value at a low cost?" approach.
- OliverJones 11y agoThis business of mischief-makers throwing rocks at trains is a real thing and has been for a long time. In 1974, in rural coastal Connecticut, I was on the way to a beach, on a footbridge over the Eastern Corridor tracks. There were two middle-school-age boys. One had a brick in hand, and the other said "hey, here it comes." I intervened and prevented that brick from hitting the engineer's windshield. But they probably waited for the next train.
- ScottBurson 11y agoYeah, I think some cracking down on this might be a good idea, even if it means blanketing hundreds of miles of track with lights and surveillance cameras. Whoever threw that rock at this train is a mass murderer and should be treated as such.
- ScottBurson 11y agoHere's probably a better idea: get rid of the windshields; replace them with steel plates. Put some cameras on the roof and monitors on the inside where the windshields were. You could even use IR-sensitive cameras at night, to better spot people on the tracks.
- jcrawfordor 11y agoThere is some use of cameras instead of windows on the train involved - instead of the conventional wing mirrors, it has rearward-facing cameras for watching the platform. The operators hate it, and have raised concerns about safety. The quality of human vision, related to both resolution and more importantly dynamic range, is much, much better than any extant camera and display system (especially affordable ones). The system you propose simply wouldn't allow the operators to see well enough, even with very expensive equipment used.
- inanutshellus 11y agoWeb designers - Take note of the NYTimes.com header that appears after you scroll down to the content. These dynamically-appearing headers are a good idea, but nobody seems to get the nuance right. If I scroll until the top of the article is at the top of the page, then start reading, I suddenly can't because this inept header just appeared covering the top 10% of the page. Now I have to scroll back up to see the content. If it had appeared when the massive full-screen image WAS the top 10% it'd've been a perfectly seamless header introduction, but instead they wait until there's something valuable at the top of the page to introduce it. </gripe>
- lloyd-christmas 11y agoMost simply, just add a larger space between the image and text for when it attaches. There are better ways to approach it, but this is pretty easily avoided.
- uuoc 11y agoJust open up developer tools, use the "find element" tool to find the header, then delete nodes until the header disappears. Now there's no header at all.
- catbird 11y agoOr use a javascript bookmarklet to remove all elements with position:fixed attribute :-) http://alisdair.mcdiarmid.org/kill-sticky-headers/ http://alisdair.mcdiarmid.org/kill-sticky-headers/
- ams6110 11y agoAll I see is a page demanding that I log in or buy a subscription.
- bbrian 11y agoSame, I guess because I have cookies turned off.
- cesarb 11y agoForgive me for my ignorance, but wouldn't adding a few balises to the track (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balise), and the matching receiver in the trains, be enough to limit the train speed to what the track allows? Or would even a simple system with fixed balises need FCC approval?
- jakob223 11y agoI think this would be a means of positive train control, which, the article claims, hadn't been rolled out yet for regulatory and cost reasons. It seems reasonably cheap to me, too, but I guess the scale is enormous.
- gsnedders 11y agoThe political will has always seemed to be to go for a better solution than a few balises, probably in part given there is so much fight to get anything that installing some balises would likely hold back introducing anything better in the near future.
- bdamm 11y agoSimple, inexpensive, effective. Sounds like a great way to go.
- crocal 11y agoForgiven, three times :). It has been rolled out in France (KVB), Germany (LZB) and Spain (ASFA) for decades. And it's considered outdated stuff. Now everyone switches to ERTMS.
- app 11y agoI was on a Northeast Corridor trip once when the train was struck from the side by a rock. It sounded like a gunshot went off inside the car-- everyone jumped and there were more than a few shouts. I can imagine being hit head-on by a rock at night would be enough to distract an engineer for a few critical minutes. What a shame.
- davidf18 11y agoPart of my work involves healthcare patient safety -- principles learned from aircraft, nuclear power, oil & gas, safety, etc. What I found notable was that two months (March vs. May) prior to the accident, the "optimal" break time for train engineers between runs was reduced to 90 mins from about 2.5 hours. The union had protested this change, but to no avail. If the train the engineer had come in late for any reason, the break could be less than 90 minutes. In my view, it was certainly unwise to have made this shortening of break time for engineers before the completion of PTC on the line (it at all).
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIf you read more of the article, it says that the engineer came in about 30 minutes late due to an issue with a computer system before leaving New York. The article also said that Amtrak declined to speak about the engineer's schedule that day.
- davidf18 11y agoThanks for adding that info...
- rconti 11y agoCan someone well-versed in train operation help explain the difference between operating a train on these kinds of routes and schedules and, say, operating a tractor-trailer or bus? The article keeps mentioning the difficult tasks of operating the train -- obey every speed limit sign, every trackside control, speed up here, slow down there. But it doesn't illustrate how these demands are different from the demands placed on the operators of other vehicles. If anything, it seems tractor trailer and bus driver schedules are far more demanding, and they have even more things to look out for while operating their vehicles. On the side of the difficulties of operating a train, I can see how the endless line of tracks unfurling in front of you can be mesmerizing/tiring (like driving in a snowstorm), and how the 'relative' safety of being secured to tracks can lull you into a false sense of security on stretches where speed changes are not required. Furthermore, of course, the demands of keeping a train on the right set of tracks through various switches can be difficult, because trucks don't face the same risk of head-on collisions with no ability to stop or veer off course at the last second. Still, without knowing anything about the difficulty of operating the train controls themselves, I find myself wanting for more information to illustrate the unusual demands placed on train operators that are not placed on other long-haul motor vehicle operators. I don't dispute that it's a demanding job, and the consequences greater than those of crashing a tractor trailer, but I'm unable to understand how without more information.
- mentat 11y agoI'd guess that the amount of momentum in a quickly moving train makes any changes take a lot longer to take place and mistakes harder to address in time. You don't just stamp the brakes to stop or push the accelerator to speed up. The cycle time on system changes requires "tending".
- rconti 11y agoOthers also pointed out trains are big and heavy, which I thought of more in terms of an advantage (doesn't exactly speed up all that quickly) or neutral in terms of impact on the conductor (if it crashes, yes, it's a big deal, but assuming it doesn't, it's not). I hadn't thought about it in terms of cycle time and 'tending' as you mention. You're right that having to plan things ahead, and watching the consequences of your earlier actions unfold slowly can be quite stressful. I imagine it also demands much more in terms of multi-tasking because you can't just respond to an immediate need, you need to keep more 'balls in the air' at a given point in time because of how slowly the controls respond. Excellent point, thank you.
- djsumdog 11y agoI feel like that article had a massive amount of fluff. I understand trying to build a narrative, but the article felt like one of those modern sensationalized documentaries where they take 45 minutes to explain a 10 minute thing (e.g. everything on the History channel). They do build a narrative around the driver to make him more human and help the reader relate, but for everything else, if I wanted to read a narrative I'd pick up a novel.
- jmilloy 11y ago> It was a tricky series of maneuvers for even the most experienced engineer: speed up out of North Philadelphia Station; slow for a gradual curve at North Second Street; throttle open again for the straightaway, where the speed limit is 70 m.p.h.; and dump speed for the sharp 50-m.p.h. curve. I don't know how to operate a train. Does pushing a throttle up or down count as a "manoeuvre"? What's "tricky" about this? Am I missing something, or is the author embellishing here? edit: grammar
- interurban 11y agoI imagine that when operating a ~400 ton machine any operation is at least slightly more complicated than just pushing a lever. Especially when combined into a series in a short period of time at night in poor lighting while having rocks thrown at your windshield.
- dtparr 11y agoI'm similarly ignorant on all the intricacies of driving a train, but my understanding is that the coupled nature of a train vs. a rigid body make the dynamics more difficult to deal with than you might imagine. That being said, I don't know how much that affects the difficulty of the operator at this point or whether that's all worked out in the train's control software. You can see what the engineer's station look like in the type of train discussed in the article here: http://www.eweek.com/mobile/slideshows/amtraks-new-siemens-locomotive-with-digital-controls-cruises-rails.html http://www.eweek.com/mobile/slideshows/amtraks-new-siemens-l... Looks like there is a combined throttle/braking control on the left side, then (multiple?) brakes on the right. Also FYI, maneuver isn't an error, it's the American English spelling.
- jcrawfordor 11y agoYes, if I'm correct you are seeing the dynamic control on the left (forward for acceleration, reverse for dynamic braking) and the air brakes on the right - the big left handle is the train brake (sends the change down the brake line to the cars as well) and the smaller right handle is the locomotive-only brake (often used to get slow down the loco first so the coupler slack will get taken up and prevent bumping the passengers around or damaging equipment). The little LCD display shows some calculations to help the engineer make good braking decisions. Above the dynamic control on the left you see a small rotary lever - if I'm not mistaken this is the reverser, which simply selects between forward, neutral, and reverse. As a fun fact, this lever pops out and is used as the "key" for the train. For safety reasons, the engineer removes it when they leave the cab so that it's difficult to get it out of neutral. The big red button left of the dynamic control is the alerter acknowledge. This is the dead-man protection on locomotives and I suspect may factor into the conclusion on this investigation. When an alarm sounds, the operator has to press that button. The alarm becomes very jarring so it might have brought a confused or unconscious operator back to attention.
- chrismartin 11y agoSo, microsleep? Absence seizure?