5 ms·
> Yes, without robotic construction to build cheaply underground, that is an expensive proposition. That's not a perfect solution either: all the rock you dig
by mschuster91 11y ago
> Yes, without robotic construction to build cheaply underground, that is an expensive proposition.
That's not a perfect solution either: all the rock you dig out has to go somewhere. Dump it in the ocean and you destroy the sea life. Dump it on the country side and you'll have NIMBY squads in arms.
- Symbiote 11y agoYou just need to plan where you put the spoil. There's plenty of ruined shore than can benefit. London used the spoil from the most recent tunnel to make a 680ha wetland / nature reserve. There's some pictures at the bottom: http://www.crossrail.co.uk/news/articles/crossrails-final-shipment-of-earth-arrives-at-wallasea-island http://www.crossrail.co.uk/news/articles/crossrails-final-sh...
- zimpenfish 11y ago> The RSPB will require more than 10 million tonnes of excavated material to create the reserve and is currently seeking partners to provide the remaining 7 million tonnes. If Crossrail is only providing 3M tonnes from 42km of tunnels, where on earth do the RSPB think they're going to get another 7M from?
- stretchwithme 11y agoIs there a big "I don't want a hill in my backyard" movement?
- detaro 11y agoIt is an issue in big construction projects, especially since you neither want to store the stuff for ages nor ship it large distances. If you build something like a highway it's relatively easy to balance dirt production with dirt usage, but for projects that heavily skew in one direction it can be difficult. The put a hill somewhere you need to own the land, transport everything there, probably do landscaping, ...
- stretchwithme 11y agoSo it can be done. As long as the value created is much greater than the costs, it works.