3 ms·
I don't think this particular comment gets enough coverage "With enough effort, you can automate every job out of existence." The example I've used has been s
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I don't think this particular comment gets enough coverage
"With enough effort, you can automate every job out of existence."
The example I've used has been self scanning checkout lines at grocery stores. They replace 16 cashiers at $10/hr with one "supervisor" at $16/hr. The additional margin goes to the grocer. If instead the productivity went to a basic income program then, the price of groceries would be the same, the grocer's income would be the same, but now there would be money "appearing out of thin air" for a basic income program. But what is really happening is that you've automated a human job, captured all that GDP in the process.
If you think about it that way, it changes how you see automation, and productivity gains.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 2muchcoffeeman 11y agoIn Australia we have a supermarket chain called Coles. After they brought in self checkouts, they started bringing in new bakeries, cafes, etc _into_ the stores. I am not sure the number of staff went down by all that much.
- firethief 11y agoThat's a red herring. It's not the absolute number of staff in a particular supermarket that we're talking about, but the ratio of people employed to work done. Using their lowered operating costs to expand their business doesn't negate the fact that their checkouts are operating with less human labor.
- lxmorj 11y agoProductivity gains mainly happen when there is a profit motive to create them. What incentive is there to create self scanning machines if you can't sell them for a profit? Why would a grocery store buy them if they don't gain from the purchase. It's all the same to the store: employ 10 people or use robots and pay more in taxes so those 10 people get basic income and don't work.
- sangnoir 11y agoWell, the government could increase the tax to levels that force the matter: automate or get no profit. However, I dont think this could be stomached in the US (by both politicians and self-sabotaging voters). Automation is inevitable, but unfortunately for the American working class, all of the benefits of improved efficiancy will be going to a few (shareholders), just because you were conditioned to think 'socialism' is a bad word. I already see the sentiments being expressed here on HN rehashing the 'welfare queen' argument. I tell you what: a whole lot of you will be arguing for basic income when they automate your job, but it will be too late then. Good luck finding another job that's yet to be automated and pays anything in the same ballpark as your old one.
- seanp2k2 11y agoThe machines also break, use electricity (possibly more than the clerks with their registers and belts and lights), require infrastructure to support (e.g. price changes must now also be updated in their possibly-separate pricing database, also consider stores labeling prices by hand or only on the shelf), and can't immediately replace 100% of cashiers (some customers will prefer human interaction, some states e.g. require that liquor is sold not by a machine, etc). It does also create needs for different jobs. Instead of 10 cashiers @$10/hr, you now need 1 supervisor @$16/hr + a consulting company to install and integrate the machines @$300/hr + technicians to re-stock the machines and service them @$90/hr + customer support to help with software bugs in the new pricing system etc etc. Of course, you can then go and automate all of those jobs as well, but it seems a bit fractal until we have AI strong enough to build more AI where it's needed and consolidate existing AI, which I guess is what people are supposing leads to the extinction of humans since we're so inefficient.