9 ms·
How they did come up with number that high? I know that Switzerland is expensive country, but still. That's 2,256 EUR or 2,443 USD.
by nabla9 11y ago
How they did come up with number that high? I know that Switzerland is expensive country, but still.
That's 2,256 EUR or 2,443 USD.
- planetjones 11y agoI don't think that's a high number at all for Switzerland - infact it would be quite a struggle to live on that amount after paying for rent, health insurance, utilities and food. I think the amount being proposed would still give quite a high incentive to people to work, as the standard of living on the minimum would be basic to say the least.
- seivan 11y agoWhat if you've paid off your mortgage and now housing is essentially only maintenance and utilities. Removing rent cost would make that money last. I wonder if the people behind this have that notion.
- tonfa 11y agoHome ownership isn't very high in Switzerland (and at least in urban areas there aren't many apartments below 1M). And you have to pay income tax on your rent anyway (even if to yourself).
- seivan 11y agoExactly For those lucky enough to have managed to secure a place without rent/mortage -> essentially those lucky few with ownership <- will get the best out of basic income.
- tonfa 11y agoNot necessarily if income tax rates are offset to compensate. Also 2k/mo might not make much of a difference for wealthy people (so they'd still need to earn money to support their lifestyle).
- gaius 11y agoIn Switzerland money that you're not paying in rent/mortgage because you own the property, is considered income and taxed accordingly.
- themartorana 11y agoIsn't it in most countries? In the US the interest paid is at least a write off. But principal payments have already been taxed as income...
- chimeracoder 11y agoNo, this is different from what happens in the US. Let's say I buy a house in the US and pay cash (no mortgage, no financing). I now own this house and decide to live in it. I will have to pay local property taxes, but I do not have to pay any income tax. Now, let's say I instead rented out the house to someone else (and lived somewhere else), I would be making income on the rent, and therefore paying income tax on the rental income. In Switzerland, if you live in the house that you own (the first example), you are considered to be renting it to yourself. So you have to pay income tax on the market rent for your home, even if you are both the tenant and the landlord. EDIT: For the record, I don't know why you're being downvoted for asking for clarification.
- themartorana 11y agoThanks, I see what is meant now. Don't know why I'm getting downvoted either. Seems a rather innocuous question by someone not native to Switzerland.
- seivan 11y agoYou're missing the point completely. Not having to deal with rent means the money from basic income can go further than for anyone who doesn't own their own housing. Meaning it's essentially for rich kids who've inherited their own housing, or those with enough dispensable income to pay off their place. Basic Income in this scenario wouldn't help the poorest, it would help the rich enough to get further with that money. I am not against Basic Income, but it has to be in a situation where the poor will benefit from it, not the rich enough to make the best out of the money. This seems like just another shit the modern bourgeois leftist have cooked up for themselves thinking it applies to the poorest. What a joke.
- igama 11y agoIt might sound like a lot, but in the Swiss context, it's not that much. It's a really expensive country to live in, especially in the main cities like Zurich and Geneva. For you 2,256€ is great, but in Switzerland, it's considered good income for a student/intern, that's how expensive it is. (compare that to Portugal where they can pay a intern 150€/month).
- zerr 11y agoYep, I know a couple of senior engineers working at Google in Poland for the same salary (as that min in Switzerland). Not that it's great salary there, but that's the market and big companies like Google use that situation to get cheap labour.
- dogma1138 11y agoThat's shit whats worse is that those companies exploit the EU market even further by moving them around the EU while keep paying them in their home countries even with some extra payments for sustenance it's still several times cheaper than hiring local engineers in the UK, France or Germany.
- chkuendig 11y agoIt's half of what you'd get for flipping burger at McDonalds, working as a supermarket cashier etc. 2000.- isn't poverty level and more than wellfare would pay - but not much more.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoFlipping burgers can earn you $5000 a month? Sign me up, that's more than I make.
- occamrazor 11y agoNot sure about flipping burgers, but all supermarket chains pay a minimum wage of 4000 CHF (4200-4400 USD) per month, with 4 weeks of paid holidays. Taxes on such a low income would be quite low (15% payroll and 10% income tax). Health insurance is around 200 CHF/month per person, with a 2500 CHF yearly deductible.
- tonfa 11y agoNote that rent, food, etc is also scaled accordingly. (Not a bad deal in the end, especially considering the cashier/waiters/etc earn enough to live decently).
- tenfingers 11y agoI live close to switzerland's borders, and it's incredible the disparity in terms of salary/cost of living between switzerland and all it's neighbors. I do not consider myself poor, but there's no way I can afford any sort of holiday in switzerland. I have friends and some colleagues in switzerland: for them, a year's rent of my house would equal for roughly a single month of their salary. For those living close to Geneve, sometimes less. It's mind-blowing, really.
- thallian 11y agoYeah, in Switzerland I live decently but I am not rich by any means. To visit friends I frequently travel to Germany and everytime I realise just how big a difference it is for many things. In the beginning I always had the feeling of something wrong when going to a supermarket there, because for me the gap was so crazily big.
- themartorana 11y agoBut wouldn't you also make less for the same job in Germany, making the relative ratio of income to cost not all that dissimilar?
- Muted 11y agoI lived in Zürich for a year and remember seeing an ad on the train for work at a grocery store that paid 4k CHF ($3910) per month. The college I was attending paid 35CHF ($34) an hour to students who did work for their department. Just to put it in some perspective. The cost of living is also ridiculously high.
- themartorana 11y agoWhen the cost of living is high but the income of blue collar jobs are adjusted accordingly, isn't everything relative?
- rhino369 11y agoThat's why when discussing income and things like that the Purchase Price Parity is used. The PPP for Switzerland is 1.6. So even after you convert from Francs to Dollars you have assume everything is 1.6 as expensive in Switzerland. So 2250 dollars in Switzerland roughly gets you the same purchase power as 1400 in the USA.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dre85 11y agoSwitzerland is brutally expensive. If you go to a restaurant for a steak you'll pay like 100 USD just for the steak. If you aren't rich you'll probably become almost vegetarian just from the prices of meat. People often go to France to buy groceries if they live close enough to the border.
- mkuhn 11y agoIf you only eat Wagyu that might be true ;) Switzerland is expensive but not THAT expensive.