4 ms·
Wow. I never imagined an in-frame motor/battery would produce that much power. 250W for 30 minutes is more than most non-racing recreational cyclists can mana
by alistairSH 11y ago
Wow. I never imagined an in-frame motor/battery would produce that much power.
250W for 30 minutes is more than most non-racing recreational cyclists can manage.
- resoluteteeth 11y agoMy first thought was that it should be impossible, too, but the answer is that the battery isn't in the frame. It's either in the saddlebag or (in the fancier version) disguised as a water bottle.
- nl 11y agoThere's plenty of room in a frame for a battery. You don't need to run the motor 100% of the time - 1 minute bursts at critical times is more than enough. Shimano, Campagnolo and SRAM all make batteries designed to fit in the seat tube for electronic gear shifting.
- resoluteteeth 11y ago> Shimano, Campagnolo and SRAM all make batteries designed to fit in the seat tube for electronic gear shifting. Electronic shifting uses almost no power; the derailleur just has to periodically move a few millimeters. There's absolutely no comparison. In total, there is "plenty of room in a frame" and so it's probably theoretically doable, it would just require much more work to pack it with cells and wire everything up. The companies currently making these motor kits are probably using off-the-shelf battery packs. Maybe you're right, though, that a smaller battery providing "bursts of power" would be enough to make a difference though.
- alistairSH 11y agoAbsolutely - in a climbing stage of le Tour, a racer would just need a few bursts to match the acceleration of the other tops riders as they try to drop the peloton on the steepest sections. 20-30s bursts, 100-200W, would be more than enough to stay in the race. In something like cyclocross, the difference from a frame motor would probably be even bigger. The races are shorter (60 minutes vs 4-6 hours) and the power bursts are short and intense - power through a mud pit, stay on bike instead of running a super steep hill, etc.
- userbinator 11y agoLook at some of the brushless motors used in RC cars and planes ("drones" as the terminology seems to be today...) --- the power densities are absolutely amazing. Here's a 4kW (more than 5HP!) motor that's less than 5cm in diameter and 10cm long: http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__21967__turnigy_c580l_580kv_brushless_inrunner_motor_4000w.html http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__21967__turnigy_c5... One problem with fitting these into a bike is that they require plenty of active cooling to not overheat, but it shows that such power densities are definitely possible. Especially if for intermittent use with long periods of cooling. 4kW is also extreme overkill if all you're after is a small competitive advantage. As for batteries, 250W for 30 minutes is 125Wh, around the same energy as a typical 9-cell laptop battery.
- hengheng 11y agoProblem with those motors is you have to get from 10krpm down to 60-110rpm at the crank. This carries a surprisingly huge penalty in weight and efficiency, up to a point where it's a good idea to just choose a different motor.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]