6 ms·
Death of a Troll
- xyzzy4 11y agoSo did he actually die or not? The article was somewhat unclear.
- chris_wot 11y agoIt was crystal clear. He faked his suicide. He's a massive jerk.
- jbssm 11y agoSincerely, it was kind of funny, specially taking into account the dark mood that sets in in the beginning of the article.
- jbssm 11y agoWhy the fuck is this being downvoted? Fucking retarded idiots in your moral high horse.
- xyzzy4 11y agoHN users are well known for their lack of sense of humor.
- dang 11y agoPlease stop posting comments that break the HN guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- pavel_lishin 11y agoIt probably wasn't very funny to most of the people who thought their good friend had died, especially those who've dealt with actual suicide in their lives.
- mrkipling 11y agoThe article was entirely clear - he did not die, he faked his own suicide.
- xyzzy4 11y agoI'm on my phone so it wasn't easy for me to see that.
- lmm 11y agoMafia/werewolf is one of those games that tends to get out of hand (Diplomacy is the other big one, at least for me). I played a few games online, but realised it was bad for me - whichever side I was, I thought about nothing else while the game was running. When I was hospitalized my thoughts weren't on my physical problem but on how I'd be letting my team down. Games are fun because they're games, they're supposed to remain circumscribed - when a game starts to take over your life, it's time to stop.
- busterarm 11y agoDiplomacy is the only game where I've deliberately toyed with an opponents mental state in order to win. I knew that a key backstab combined with some carefully worded global press would cause the player leading the opposing alliance to have a meltdown. I did it anyway. Best German victory game I've ever had. It worked so well that he got despondent and stopped talking to anyone in the game. Within two phases my global victory was assured. Diplomacy is the most absolutely fascinating game, but I have mellowed out some and stopped playing - some newer games also have great strategy without the time commitment and mentally/emotionally taxing gameplay.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- beobab 11y agoDiplomacy was banned at my house because it always caused tears and angry outbursts, often within moments of the first set of orders being revealed, always before the third set, and I can't even remember a game going further than five moves. The lesson I learned from this game: Don't play it with people you like.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoMaybe that's why my experience was pretty boring. I played with a group of people I'd met specifically to play a game of Diplomacy, and their inevitable betrayals didn't hurt at all.
- tronje 11y agoThis was a lot more interesting and than I thought it would be. I never thought I'd see such a romantic story about a forum troll... Seems like most people involved are now in a better place than before. Good for them.
- krylon 11y agoI have to say this article was quite well-written. I couldn't stop reading, even though I really wanted to.
- herbig 11y agoReally interesting, but a lot of grammar errors and runwithfire gets doxxed by the author within the article. Don't papers have editors anymore?
- talideon 11y agoYou might want to do a search for the term 'The Grauniad'.
- herbig 11y agoHa, that's pretty awesome. Still going strong. My main issue with the article is that despite only using pseudonyms, the author easily revealed the real life name of one of the individuals by quoting her Twitter account. Maybe the author doesn't understand technology, but this shouldn't have slipped by editing. Which really leads me to believe there was none.
- mdni007 11y agoI feel like I just watched a whole movie
- VLM 11y agoBetter than a movie. Its not a remake, reboot, sequel, or formula. A startup should be able to disrupt Hollywood. There are stories out there. The author needs an editor, and an agent.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoYeah but in my version of the story Eris dies at the end.
- VLM 11y agoToo predictable, too morality fable. Better off with the truth.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoNope, audiences expect a certain level of payoff and just when it seems like he's in the clear, like things have turned around and they can maybe sympathise with him, BAM.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TheBranca18 11y agoThe article was well-written and gave me the feeling that I traipsed all over the various subjects' lives. As someone who has done his fair share of what I feel to be innocuous trolling, I'm glad I've grown up.
- buro9 11y agoOn the forums that I have run, I have seen 2 deaths faked. The most recent was in December 2014 where a person claiming to be the partner of the guy who had allegedly died was then asking for contributions to help cover a funeral. At the time it sowed a fair degree of mistrust, and the only way the community was able to move on was to pull together in secret to prove conclusively whether or not the person had died. What this meant is that about 50 people spent a chunk of time checking morgues, hospitals, location hints, police reports and other details until not only did we have an overwhelming amount of evidence it was faked, but could actually prove he was alive and well. But then what? What do you do with someone who has done that? The only answer that was palatable to us is that the person should be permanently excluded from the community. It's taken the real death of another person to remind us that not everyone is like that and to restore a lot of the trust and faith in each other. The damage a fake death does to a community is significantly more than the damage the person who faked it does to themselves. And you can be sure that the person who does it will lose a lot of friends forever and find it hard to find a place in which someone doesn't know someone that knows. The world isn't a big enough place for someone to get away with this now, it's all interconnected.
- theorique 11y agoSo their physical death is faked, but they are effectively dead to the community because of the breach of trust.
- hga 11y agoBut then what? What do you do with someone who has done that? Report him to his local police? Collecting money on that basis is criminal fraud in lots of localities. Otherwise, ugh, yeah, not much you can do besides serious shunning.
- Spearchucker 11y agoIt felt a bit surreal reading that, and reading the comments here. I know that many of us seem to spend more and more of our time seeking validation online (a state of mind I already struggle to understand), but this is a lot darker than I'd imagined.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoSpeaking of dark, I see this story as somewhere in the middle. Here's the dynamic: There's the 'feel good' stuff of raising money for good causes or getting people to send letters to a sick child - all of which takes online validation to spread - and then there's the 'dark side' where those who are vulnerable and seeking validation online can be exploited and driven to suicide. A Mother-bullying-neighbor-girl case comes to mind, and I don't think it'll be the last. It's not a new phenomenon to be seeking attention - that's pretty much hard-wired in some people's composition - but the online dynamic (+ influences by Kardashian-esque mentalities of fame uber alles) has added a new wrinkle to figuring out how to deal with such compulsions.
- 6stringmerc 11y ago>His real life and his virtual life were completely separate. Whoa, whoa, whoa - that's maybe something a person like Eris would say, as some kind of defense, but even after faking suicide, getting a fresh start, and going back? No, they're not separate. That's an addiction[1]. This whole story reads like a functioning heroin addict who finally can't hold it all together anymore. I completely understand there's a great deal of trauma and history to acknowledge - depression and physiological issues are not minor things to be brushed aside in discussion. Context does matter. All that noted, what a selfish way to go through life. What a perfect example of lessons to teach young people about interactions online, in that shared community values (morals? ethics?) aren't baked into the online experience - in fact, quite the opposite. The freedom can be abused, and having some personal buffer zones is important, otherwise a person will end up lying to themselves and others like Eris, saying that they have a real life, which is just one of the many lies they will tell to make themselves feel better. [1] Speaking from experience in online gaming community multiplayer Half-Life, which was a significant social outlet in conjuntion with the GamersX and eventual stand-alone [R]age Board for Elites. A lot of this story is familiar, both good and bad memories. RIP Neo Babson Maximus.
- EC1 11y agoSome people just like it. It's not an addiction, there's no "reason", it's just fun to be a dick online. Why does nobody ever think of this? There always has to be some sort of grand underlying psychological reason. You're reaching much too deep into it, even comparing it to Heroine addiction. Just, wow.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoAs noted I was basing some things on personal experience and observations, so while he might "just like" being a dick online there's this thing called biology which can influence why we like the things we like. >You're reaching much too deep into it, even comparing it to Heroine addiction. Just, wow. If you're going to talk down at me, at least spell heroin right or don't bother. I'm already familiar with the Greater Internet F-Wad Theory.
- 11y ago
- at-fates-hands 11y agoEM doesn't really sound like a place for unhealthy, depressed people. Yet most of the characters in the article all seem to have psychological issues themselves, including the main character, Eris.
- Kenji 11y agoThat stuff happens in every community, but it's particularly present in communities with high occurrences of mental health problems. That's why you don't trust unconfirmed information. I cannot take it seriously anymore when people 'die'.
- danso 11y agoA bit pedantic...but I couldn't help but think, WTF is going on with the Epic Mafia's website? The article describes the troll as effortlessly hacking the site, including locking mods out of their own forum, and sending them emails with links that unban friends upon clicking. The smallest site operator can throw up a phpBB board without such issues...It sounds like Epic Mafia is running on a custom written app that is full of SQL injection vulnerabilities. I hope they've gotten them fixed up before trolls external to the community prey on them. This is not to say that the troll is just some script kiddie. It sounds like he has some serious social engineering chops, besides programming experience. I'm guessing this is the fake newspaper website he made to post his own obit? http://www.sctribune.com http://www.sctribune.com
- bshimmin 11y agoIf you visit one of their fora (eg. https://epicmafia.com/forum/36 https://epicmafia.com/forum/36) and open your browser's console, the message displayed indicates the kinds of troubles it sounds like those poor moderators have had to deal with (specifically addressing the "social engineering" part of your comment, I think). From a quick look at the source, it seems like the forum pages have the same fairly minimal markup as the rest of the site, which is slightly indicative of its being a custom forum app rather than something battle-tested (but I could be completely wrong, of course).
- SFjulie1 11y agopero non vero pero bene trovare EDIT : Ho! The comments seems to say the guy really existed. Btw; should I tell the author that Eris means the goddess of discordia (misunderstanding that becomes conflict) and not of chaos. Which make the choice of the pseudonym even more interesting ... for a troll. I would have chosen Hermes (god of the pranks, liers, merchants, ambassadors, thieves, crossroads, boxing, and messengers). And that is brother Ares is the god of war // dreadful conflicts (he is re-used as the leader of the knights of the apocalypse in the bible). So bad St John never took the time to be versed enough in greek mythology to know that the goddess of intelligence always win vs Ares/Ires. I sometimes think the christians/jews/muslims lacks something compared to the greek civilisation when it comes to dealing with our fears.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI've moderated forums before. Small ones, nothing like the scale of Epic Mafia, but there was still drama, there were real friendships, and there were trolls. Fuck this guy. Even in "death", trying to do something he thought might be helpful, he ended up hurting a lot of people. I have no sympathy for him. The article mentioned that he talked about getting into therapy, but I had a hard time understanding whether the depression was something he actually battled with, or if it was just part of his persona; regardless, I hope he gets into therapy and knocks this kind of shit the fuck off, lest he die friendless and alone. I don't hope for this so that he can live a full and happy life; I hope for this so nobody else gets harassed and doxxed.
- iSnow 11y agoAww, come on. That idea that therapy is not going to help anything and ridiculing the therapist is absolute bog standard behavior of depressed persons - I'd go as far as saying it is part of being depressed.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoSure, but Eris lied about anything and everything. Pretending to be depressed and suicidal is probably the easiest way to get sympathy, which is cruel not only because you're an asshole for lying about being depressed, but also because it casts doubt on people who are actually suffering from depression as well. I wonder how much of what Eris told the author was verified. Is he actually going to church? Does he actually have a Pennsylvania girlfriend?
- dawnbreez 11y agoI can appreciate the skill involved in faking his suicide. Kind of a dick move, though. I've had someone threaten to kill himself before; that one was a bit more selfish, as he was pretty clearly trying to guilt me into staying in a relationship with him, but I digress. I don't know what to feel about this story.
- bobby_9x 11y agoI think one of my problems with all of this is that many communities allow people with unchecked mental illnesses to continue to manipulate and harass everyone around them. I ran a meetup group with a few other co-organizers and it's amazing the amount of abuse people will take. We had members that would come into the group, harass the rest of the members and continue with inappropriate behavior during our meetups. We had one guy that would come in and basically corner any girl in the group and ask them out. During the meetup he looked like he wanted to hurt someone (he had angry looks on his face all the time), and wouldn't really talk to anyone or get to know the members. After confronting the member, it continued. Since I was running the group with other people, I told them we needed to kick this guy out of the group. They outright refused. They felt that we shouldn't be exclusionary and that this would be 'mean'. This guy eventually left when he was trying to get into an ivy league school and he sent us a blank entrance form and wanted us to fill it out for him. He sent us all angry emails and never came back. I left the group shortly after this because I couldn't be part of a group that didn't protect its members. More communities need to kick people out for inappropriate and harmful behavior.
- amoonki 11y agoI've heard that this is somewhat common in nerdy communities, or at least common enough that someone felt moved to write about "geek social fallacies": http://www.plausiblydeniable.com/opinion/gsf.html http://www.plausiblydeniable.com/opinion/gsf.html
- CM30 11y agoIt's not really common in nerdy communities as such, just mostly those somewhere between the mainstream and the incredibly niche. There's an interesting TV Tropes write up on that here: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheLawOfFanJackassery http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheLawOfFanJackas...
- tamana 11y agoThat article would be better if it removed all the "geek" spam. It isn't a "geek" phenomenon.
- dragonwriter 11y ago"In real life, ..." "His real life and his virtual life were completely separate." I think we need to stop validating the delusion that the activities one engages in online are somehow not part of "real life".
- nsns 11y agoThis is certainly correct vis-à-vis the real implications, but usually not the behavioral tendencies. In a way most "virtual lives" seem more similar to the real life of actors and public figures, i.e. persona-oriented.
- taurath 11y agoIts certainly more experimental. Thats what you lose when privacy goes away.
- ketralnis 11y agoDespite the name, "real" and "virtual" here are actually communicating something. What would be a better name?
- Nadya 11y agoOffline and online are the terms I (try) to use when referring to "real life" and "online" for similar reasons: online is still "real life". I say (try) because hold habits die hard and an occasional "real life" slips in here or there.
- lucidrains 11y agoHaha I'm the owner of the site. Surprised it made it to hacker news. There's a whole world out there with countless stories unravelling that the naked eye can't see. I'm very happy to have had a special glimpse into one of these worlds.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoIf you've got the time, I'd like to get some reflective thought from you: Based on your glimpse, what did you learn about people, online communities, or morals and ethics that you believed or didn't consider before?
- lucidrains 11y agoI wish I had something eloquent to say here. But what I've realized that the online world is not any lesser or greater than the real one, it's just a completely different one with it's own social dynamics. People impart virual actions on each other with real consequences. Otherwise I don't think I have special insight into people's morals and ethics. People remain complicated. You just get a better chance to see them in a different light when you expose them to a different medium. Can't wait to see how people will behave in VR worlds, if it were to take off ;)
- malkia 11y agoThank you for being honest in your answer. Often such questions feel to me like - so how does the wine taste, or the beer - it's fuckin' hard for me to describe - it usually goes - well bad, or good...
- orionblastar 11y agoI am mentally ill and have to stay away from some forums. They are not moderated and when someone finds out I am mentally ill they call me names and troll me. I would try to report the abuse and nothing is done. I would try and troll back. It is very unhealthy and these sort of environments just socially conduction people into becoming trolls. Hacker News is different were the users mod posts and comments and flag them for administrators that do a good job at moderating. I don't have the same problems here that I have on other sites. If someone is being a troll a dick or a jerk, moderate their comments and posts, and let them know why you are moderating them. Ban then if you have to.
- CM30 11y agoI've seen quite a few cases like this online, where people on various forums have faked their own death. Sometimes it's for attention (someone literally faked that they were dying of cancer to get people to make Youtube videos of a game they were working on), sometimes it's just wanting to leave the community (someone else faked their death in a car accident to stop working on a project that others were pressuring them about). Either way, the linked article was an interesting read. Least partly cause it felt like watching a documentary with the wildlife or civilisation replaced by forum/online game goers.
- malkia 11y agoThe Boy Who Cried Suicide?