4 ms·
Prediction markets on Obama's chance of winning nomination
- far33d 19y agoYesterday it was 55% on Clinton.....
- dkokelley 19y agoAnd tomorrow, even after the voting, it will still be uncertain. There's an idea for a startup. Create a good, secure voting service (web-based, local machine, etc. who knows?) that calls results immediately and reliably and you'll probably be doing pretty well.
- far33d 19y agoExcept you'd have to sell to the government. And convince technophobes that it's secure. And safe. And reliable.
- Hexstream 19y agoAnd all this time I thought we were trying to convince people that electronic voting (without paper audit trail) is insecure, unsafe and unreliable...
- mrtron 19y agoAnd put money in the right pockets, which are tough to get access to?
- rms 19y agoThat's what lobbyists are for!
- marcus 19y agoThe problem is I'm not sure the 2 requirements can be mixed, are we sure the government wants a fair and secure election? They are certainly working very hard to hack the system from within (redistricting for example), that we can't really casually ignore gaming outside the rules.
- rrival 19y agohttp://politicalmarket.cnn.com/ http://politicalmarket.cnn.com/ is another one, and it's from InklingMarkets (a Y-Combinator co)
- rms 19y agoHe slipped to 54...
- mechanical_fish 19y agoRichard Feynman: This question of trying to figure out whether a book is good or bad by looking at it carefully or by taking the reports of a lot of people who looked at it carelessly is like this famous old problem: Nobody was permitted to see the Emperor of China, and the question was, What is the length of the Emperor of China's nose? To find out, you go all over the country asking people what they think the length of the Emperor of China's nose is, and you average it. And that would be very "accurate" because you averaged so many people. But it's no way to find anything out; when you have a very wide range of people who contribute without looking carefully at it, you don't improve your knowledge of the situation by averaging. I think tarot cards are a lot simpler and more accurate. Mine suggest that Barack Obama should beware of the tall tower with the lightning bolts, and that a hooded figure carrying three sticks will bring him five golden discs. Meanwhile, Hillary Clinton will be menaced by a demon-like creature with the face of Rudy Giuliani, and will fight back by swinging swords at it while blindfolded. Or something.
- byrneseyeview 19y agoYour point? If they have no predictive power, you are guaranteed a profit by shorting front-runners and/or buying long-shots. If you believe that -- what are you waiting for?
- mechanical_fish 19y agoWhat does "no predictive power" mean? The Emperor's Nose technique has a certain amount of predictive power: it's very unlikely that it will be off by more than an inch, for example. Similarly, in the hands of a conscious reader such as myself, my tarot deck has lots and lots of predictive power. Right now it tells me that Mike Gravel does not have a 50% chance to become President this year, that Barack Obama will not live to be 200 years old, and that Bill Clinton, with 99.999% certainty, has not invented a perpetual motion machine. I'm not saying these markets are wrong. I'm suggesting that, at best, they're as correct as an off-the-cuff guess by the average reader of the New York Times. That's not all that impressive, but it's just good enough that I can't consistently outguess them without doing some research -- and, given that the total size of most of these penny-ante markets is less than a postdoc's annual salary, I'm never going to make any money doing that.
- DocSavage 19y agoHe's now down substantially (37 to Hillary's 63). This Irish Intrade.com website is interesting. Seems like their site markets securities per the Howey Test, but I'm not sure. They say the user should know: "Is it Legal for me to use Intrade where I live? The simple answer is that we cant be sure and this is why we require you to confirm to us that your activities are permissible from your own location. If you are in any doubt if your activities are legal from your location then you should not use our service until you take suitable professional advise." Anyone know the current US regulations on betting games of skill and would this speculative market fall under that domain?
- xirium 19y ago> "Anyone know the current US regulations on betting games of skill and would this speculative market fall under that domain?" I believe that it is currently illegal to gamble on US elections while in the US. This probably applies to US citizens outside of the US too. It doesn't stop it happening, though.
- mattmaroon 19y agoThey've done a terrible job this year, having been almost as far off as the polls.
- davidw 19y agoSo, finance guys, how do you make money from volatility? This thing is bouncing around all over the place, as results come in. The winning strategy would be one where you make money from the uncertainty, as people overreact to various results.
- dreish 19y agoTheoretically, you would only make money in an efficient market by taking a position on something people didn't already expect, and being right about it. I think volatility as election results come in is about as expected as sunrise in the morning. In fact, I'd say volatility has been less than I expected, because I thought by now either Clinton or Obama would be above 80%, and instead it's still a coin flip. But if you did want to bet on vol, you would need options, and I haven't seen any derivatives on the election futures markets. Some cursory Googling turns up nothing.