3 ms·
There are a number of people who are perplexed. And that leads to a lot of speculation. There is also seems to be a strong survivor bias in economic reporting s
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
There are a number of people who are perplexed. And that leads to a lot of speculation. There is also seems to be a strong survivor bias in economic reporting so everyone wants to be on record as both foretelling doom and not-doom, then depending on what happens they hope you'll remember they were "right".
Either way, there are interesting questions here which are unanswered. Like why do companies have so much money in their cash accounts? Generally, if a company is accumulating cash it isn't re-investing to grow. And while that might mean a planned acquisition of some other company the phenomena has gone on long enough that this seems less likely [1]. So why the cash hoard? For people it might be a 'rainy day' fund but does anyone believe that these companies will sit there, paying salaries, while selling few goods, waiting for the demand to return?
Or is it that the rent seeking transactions have become such a burden that it has been completely damping out new demand? One of the interesting thoughts is that if you go back and fix copyright and patents such that their terms expire in a more reasonable amount of time, or in the case of patents they are carefully scruitinized, then you take away this rent stream from big content and a number of license funded entities, that forces them to go out and make new content, or come up with new patented things, rather than just collect license fees. That creates new economic activity and that boosts GDP. It is a point of view that is gaining some adherents as a drag on economic growth.
Shipping as a leading indicator though has a couple of problems, both with isolating improvements in the industry (supermax ships) and shifts in modalities (air freight being acceptable for high margin goods like iphones) and generally the way consumption and manufacturing is changing (China's economic growth has zero impact on shipping if they pulling their bulk goods in over land and shipping locally).
Mostly though I suspect that there are lots of things that are unprecedented and so folks who are trying to plan are in a world of hurt in terms of confidence in their predictions. And like the reference to the movie in the article, it is always safer to predict doom and then report on "avoiding" it, than to mis-predict non-doom and to have it land at your feet. Hence more and more economists are saying "The world economy is toast!" rather than "I wonder if this is what it looks like at the leading edge of the switch away from a scarcity economy?" Sure, we could be approaching the singularity/jackpot what have you, but if you say that and the instead you get the biggest economic depression ever, well that is a worse outcome for the predictors.
[1] In an related note, having 10s of billions of dollars in cash means a company can do dozens of "10 - 50M" acquihire type deals, and that is driving some of the seed investing thinking I believe.
- slv77 11y agoA lot of those oversized cash accounts can be explained by corporate tax structures that hold cash overseas in subsidiaries. Repatriation of that cash would incur significant penalties. Pundits also suggest that shareholders who should be the beneficiaries of the cash through dividends are content to let CEO's and boards invest the cash for them due to a lack of other compelling investment opportunities. Cynics might say with the prevalence of index and other funds who hold shares by proxy and who tend to vote with corporate management there is little pressure for CEOs or Boards to return funds to shareholders and instead hold them as a personal insurance policy and to extend their power base.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThat is certainly a big part of it. But fundamentally it is idle capital. Why doesn't Apple build a German development center? I'm sure they could fill it with solid engineers and they could make it close to the auto centers and put their self driving electric car project there. Or pretty much anywhere in the EU. No need to repatriate funds if you can invest them in the area where they are already sitting and repatriate them as engineering expertise work items.
- slv77 11y agoI'd be surprised if there was a large contingent of unemployed machine learning specialist sitting idle in Germany waiting for Apples investment dollars to unleash them. A billion dollars or even ten billion won't materilize the required skills in the requisite time. An economist suggests this is an example of a skills mismatch.