4 ms·
> It is clear that he did not anticipate the astonishing severity of the legal response [to scraping JSTOR]. This is a key lesson. The transition from protecte
by mirimir 11y ago
> It is clear that he did not anticipate the astonishing severity of the legal response [to scraping JSTOR].
This is a key lesson. The transition from protected academic life to "The Real World" (as we used to style it) can be alarmingly abrupt. It's best to plan for the worst.
- Joof 11y agoWe often call things 'The Real World' when we see how harsh and unethical the current reality often is, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't strive for a more ideal one. We have to work within those real rules, but it would be a shame if those rules define us.
- mirimir 11y agoYes, he deserved slack. MIT dropped the ball, for sure. However, my point is that it's very dangerous to count on slack. Consider the theft of that cannon from Fleming House. Sure, it was a prank. And Caltech didn't press charges. All in good fun. But interstate theft is a federal crime.
- Joof 11y agoThe whole thing seems politically motivated from an outside source. Precedents at MIT effectively encourage this behavior (the law isn't a moral absolute; you've broken the law at least once; I wouldn't be surprised if I've unknowingly committed a few felonies). If the expectation was otherwise he wouldn't have behavied as he did. His mistake was likely that he had become somebody important; something of a political figure. That's when people start about caring what you do (by definition). Remember that bastard that hiked up the price of life saving drugs who got slapped with an old felony? Nobody would have bothered to find it if he wasn't the most hated man in America.
- rasz_pl 11y agoprotected academic life? MIT is known for going after its students and shooting them in the back without second thought (Star Simpson)
- mirimir 11y agoI rather agree with MIT about that. Wearing an LED vest at Boston airport was rather reckless, no?
- icebraining 11y agoSaying privately "that was reckless, you could've been shot" is fine. Publicly accusing her of recklessness for "causing alarm" is not, as she put no one else in danger. MIT should just have kept quiet if they didn't want to support her.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe more idiocy we expect and tolerate from public servants, the more we'll get. LEDs are not dangerous in any sense, and are no more likely to accompany dangerous materials than any other type of object one might encounter. Ms. Simpson's difficulties are better explained by a pathological doubling-down on the part of Boston-area LEOs to their previous ATHF fuck-up than by any rationally defensible risk assessment.
- gaadd33 11y agoWas Aaron an academic at MIT? I was under the impression he was unknown to the administration.
- mirimir 11y agoI don't know the specifics. But it's clear that he acted as if he were part of the MIT academic community.
- dtornabene 11y agoNo, its not at all clear that he acted that way.