3 ms·
> That seems to be pretty clear evidence that things get better There have been many collapses throughout history and attitudes of invincibility usually preced
by mindslight 11y ago
> That seems to be pretty clear evidence that things get better
There have been many collapses throughout history and attitudes of invincibility usually precede them. There's also the evidence of us being born in this period of history, implying it is likely the most populous. I'm not asserting that collapse is going to happen, simply arguing against confidence in either outcome. Past performance does not guarantee future returns.
> The longer it takes for that [challenging the social machine] to happen, the more entrenched and harder to change it will get.
So yeah, let's get those non-molesting pedophiles to stand up next week and publicly proclaim their desires. I'm suuuure there will be some enlightened discourse, after which they will be accepted. (BTW, if you don't want the social machine to become entrenched and harder to change, doesn't giving it omniscience seem like a poor idea?)
> Outliers like people who don't pay fines they were legitimately assessed
Outliers like people who drive too much. Or go to too many fast food restaurants. Or hit the liquor store in the middle of the week. Or who don't go to church. Or who do go to chuch. Or who play hooky from work. And yes, outliers who are going to work so they can afford to pay a ticket. Every specific situation has a direct "fix", but the entire point is that these things should not have to be lobbied for for decades to change everyone's perceptions (or people can simply never agree). Our society is kept moving by white lies that reconcile the difference between reality and the prescriptive model dictated by social norms/government. Your viewpoint assumes that perfect enforcement will cause the prescriptive model to have to adjust to match reality, but would-be social engineers have never worked that way - the entire reason the present model is far off from reality is because they believing that imposing top-down visions is desirable.
> [Government is] an abstract concept with no will of its own
The organisms we call governments do, like all organisms, whether conscious or unconscious.
Getting back to the crux of the matter, we are never going to see eye to eye. The "example" I keep stating and you keep brushing aside is simply that _I_ would like privacy where possible - for at least self-contained situations. I simply do not wish to trust everyone else to completely empathize with me (having similar computational power, how could they possibly simulate me?), but really I need no further justification for my desire. If you cannot respect my (and others' like me) desire, then you are yet another social engineer with a grand plan for everyone - exactly the type of person I desire privacy from!
- imgabe 11y ago>Getting back to the crux of the matter, we are never going to see eye to eye. The "example" I keep stating and you keep brushing aside is simply that _I_ would like privacy where possible - for at least self-contained situations. I simply do not wish to trust everyone else to completely empathize with me (having similar computational power, how could they possibly simulate me?), but really I need no further justification for my desire. If you cannot respect my (and others' like me) desire, then you are yet another social engineer with a grand plan for everyone - exactly the type of person I desire privacy from! You continue to mistake my point completely. I'm not saying that your privacy should be gone, I'm saying that it is gone.That ship has sailed, and continuing to rely on it in order to protect yourself from tyranny is not going to work. If you want to sit idly by, clinging to privacy, while tyrants rise to power, you're going to eventually end up in the situation you fear. Fast food restaurants, church/no church, etc. These are not currently legitimate reasons for the police to pull anyone over or detain them. It's not because the police don't have the ability to collect that data, it's because we have laws limiting what the police can and can't do and we have a court system that punishes bad actors on both sides of the law. That is what we need to protect, not whether there a list of fast food restaurants you visited. The amount of information the government has is irrelevant if they are forced to act transparentlyrics with appropriate checks and balances.