6 ms·
Agreed. This is exactly what the NSA should be doing. This leak has no value to the public.
by ForHackernews 11y ago
Agreed. This is exactly what the NSA should be doing. This leak has no value to the public.
- revelation 11y agoI'm sure the Israelis care that their fighter jets and drones use crypto that can be trivially broken with current computing power? It also of course plays into the whole fix vs exploit debate. Should the NSA inform on weak crypto or subvert it for their own purposes? What if its crypto used by a military partner? Where lies the greater public value?
- tptacek 11y agoThe IDF absolutely knows that their old drone video feeds were insecure. They didn't need The Intercept to tell them that. As for your second question, there is no actual debate about whether NSA should hoard/exploit or "fix" vulnerabilities in foreign signals intelligence. Their charter is to exploit. That's what SIGINT is. The debate is whether NSA should be required to fix vulnerable infrastructure when that infrastructure is used by US commercial infrastructure. That's not what's happening here.
- revelation 11y agoSo since they knew, there is no harm? Your second point seems to miss that whatever the foreigners are using may be a popular choice for naturals as well. (Notice the US selling F-16 abroad only to then having to break their video stream. At least the British don't sell missiles that they can't deactivate when coming their way)
- dogma1138 11y agoNope but great value for people who want to drive political agenda's - mainly to increase the so called "rift" between US and Israel (which always spied on each other mainly because US interests in the middle east almost always directly oppose the ones of Israel) and to "embarrass" the US even further which is something that a large portion of the Intercept's readership wants as it seems.
- 13thLetter 11y ago"which always spied on each other mainly because US interests in the middle east almost always directly oppose the ones of Israel" True. And it's rather sad that they do, given that Israel's interests in the middle east are generally about not having their citizens murdered in the street.
- mkaziz 11y agoI'm pretty sure that's in the interest if every government everywhere. Israel, presumably like the Arabs, hsd other interests less noble than that.
- wavefunction 11y agoI suppose I could mention things that they could do differently to achieve that goal, but what would be the use?
- 13thLetter 11y agoI dunno. What's the use of anything, really?
- jjoonathan 11y ago> Israel's interests in the middle east are generally about not having their citizens murdered in the street. That's what they say, but when I read stories about them demolishing Palestinian neighborhoods, billing them for it, and building real-estate developments over the "confiscated" land the whole "we just want peace" line starts to smell like a rationalization at best and more probably a flat-out excuse.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tajen 11y agoThank you! I often have trouble expressing the problem I see with Isreael demolishing Palestinian neighborhoods, but you've expressed it well and I'll keep your text for future arguments.
- markdown 11y ago> This leak has no value to the public. US taxpayers give the Israeli government billions of dollars every year. Then Israel turns around and publicly disrespects the US president. US taxpayers need to know that their government is willing to stand up to Israel when necessary. This is an actual concern because: 1. US politicians are almost all for sale. 2. The Israeli lobbying group AIPAC has bought and paid for a great number of those politicians.
- 13of40 11y agoI think I worked out once that the average working American spends as much on Israel as they do on their phone bill. (Back when we had phones tethered to the wall, so YMMV.)
- dtornabene 11y agoA specific political party who happen to be in power (barely in power, literally by a single seat in the knesset) disrespected the president, a significant proportion of the Israeli population, including the defense establishment were horrified and embarrassed.
- gozur88 11y ago>Then Israel turns around and publicly disrespects the US president. Yeah... so what? The president isn't the United States. He's just a manager, temporarily. Besides, there was plenty of disrespect flowing the other way, too. When Obama went out of his way to snub Netanyahu, did it bother you, or do you think somehow the office of the American president is worthy of more respect than that of the Israeli PM?
- markdown 11y ago> did it bother you, or do you think somehow the office of the American president is worthy of more respect than that of the Israeli PM? Much more worthy, obviously. If you come with me hat in hand accept my aid, you damn well better be nice to me. If Israel wants to crap on the US president, that's fine, but don't then accept handouts from them. At least the beggars in my town only swear at you if you don't give them money.