3 ms·
Article is interesting for the part it leaves out. Unions essentially inflated the cost of labor so much that doing the work in another country and shipping it
by brightball 11y ago
Article is interesting for the part it leaves out. Unions essentially inflated the cost of labor so much that doing the work in another country and shipping it across an entire ocean before redistributing it to various points across the country was CHEAPER that manufacturing it closer to the central point of domestic delivery.
That is the point that always gets left out. Cause and effect is a very real thing.
EDIT: This was apparently controversial. Voted up quickly and voted all the way back down at the same speed.
- notahacker 11y agoUnions didn't create the cost of living differences between the US and China. The average Chinese worker earns less than $5k per annum, and that's despite unusually long work weeks and sustained wage growth over the last couple of decades. The average US worker isn't a union member but couldn't live on $5k per annum
- bradleyjg 11y agoCost of living differences are real but almost always overstated. It isn't as though a family in China can live the same lifestyle as a middle class American on $5k/year because everything there is so much cheaper. The average Chinese worker is very poor by US standards, even after taking into account cost of living differences. In fact, if you swapped a family with a cash income of $5k/year from China to the US, in many way they'd be better off as they'd have access to more and better socially provisioned goods and services. When you make this sort of argument you are implicitly saying "Chinese people don't mind being poor as much as Americans do" even if that's not what you meant to say.
- notahacker 11y agoI agree cost of living differences are complicated and even low paid Americans expecting to drive a car to work, for example, plays a big role in pushing salary expectations up at the bottom end. But I don't think there are many parts of the US where you can comfortably rent a house and feed a family on $5k per annum. And I don't think most assembly line workers in export processing zones in China earn anywhere near that.
- Mvandenbergh 11y agoIt's more accurate to say that the cost of shipping something across an ocean dropped so low because of containerisation that virtually any disparity in the cost of input factors (not just labour - energy, land, etc as well) is worth exploiting via geographical arbitrage. Even without unions, the cost of living disparity is such that in many cases if American firms matched the wages of even relatively well paid Chinese workers they simply couldn't survive on them in the US.
- dharma1 11y agoCost of shipping stuff around the world is also so cheap because the externalised costs are not priced in. This era of massive fossil fuel use in an incredibly short time is like borrowing from the past and the future at the same time.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoOne man's "inflated the cost of labor" is another man's "raised the standard of living." Labor is expensive in the US because the standard of living is high. Labor is cheap in China because the standard of living (at least among the cheap laborers) is much lower.