3 ms·
Then the company will become a vessel to voice the opinion of the corporate charter. The charter was agreed to by all shareholders. Those who found it unaccept
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Then the company will become a vessel to voice the opinion of the corporate charter.
The charter was agreed to by all shareholders. Those who found it unacceptable chose not to buy shares.
Again the company now is acting as an inhuman entity. It has interests characterized by a charter, not by a human being's potentially malleable opinions.
The company is acting as a group of people who have agreed to devote a certain amount of their wealth (their initial investment) to work toward a certain purpose (whatever the charter says).
The "company" doesn't actually exist - all there is is a set of contracts between shareholders. The "company" is merely a legal facade to simplify interactions between the shareholders and other parties.
Yes but some of us can't say no to an iPhone. Should we be forced to indirectly support segregation?
If you choose to buy products from companies supporting segregation, that's on you. Steve Jobs doesn't have mind control rays. He neither forced you to buy shares or an iPhone.
Also, the issue if your trading partners spending money on causes you dislike is not limited to corporations. For all you know, the owner of your local bakery is a secret racist sending money to the Klan.
- chrischen 17y agoI'd also like to add: > Similarly, your computer does not have any rights, but you do have the right to post hacker news comments using your computer (provided pg lets you). You're supposed to only have one account. PG gives YOU a right to post hacker news comments, not your computer. The computer is a direct representation of you. A company is a distinct entity created from the collection of people. Your analogy is faulty. > The charter was agreed to by all shareholders. Those who found it unacceptable chose not to buy shares. Yet the charter which is agreed upon is a distinct entity concocted by human beings. At best it's a monster like frankenstein. > The "company" is merely a legal facade to simplify interactions between the shareholders and other parties. Yet the company is also a distinct entity. Look the US government guarantees rights to individuals, not groups or corporations. Groups that come together for a common interest only amplify their voice by the collective pooling of their individual voices. A corporation pools those individual voices into a mob, which does something else independent of any one person's will. It's a distinct entity. It is not a human. It does not have rights like a citizen. I can't stress this enough: the government guarantees certain right to individual people, not groups that can be arbitrarily formed.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYou're supposed to only have one account. PG gives YOU a right to post hacker news comments, not your computer. And the government is not restricting your rights with it's "no criticizing Obama with a computer" law. It's only restricting the actions of your computer. A company is not a distinct entity. A company is nothing more than a group of people acting together according to some mutually agreed upon terms. Incidentally, the government does grant people the right to form groups - it's called "peaceable assembly". But lets ignore that. Do you believe that after forming a group, you give up all constitutional rights when acting as part of the group? I.e., while the government can't censor me, it can censor papers I publish as part of my association with a larger group (NYU, my employer)? Also, this brings us back to my (and Robert's) original question: if free speech doesn't apply to corporations, can the government censor the corporate media?
- chrischen 17y ago> A company is not a distinct entity. A company is nothing more than a group of people acting together according to some mutually agreed upon terms. People lose their individuality when participating as part of a mob. A group is a distinct entity formed by a mob. It is not like any of the individual singled out people. The mob when formed acquires distinct characteristics and behaviors that distinguish it from any individual human being, who may be governed by neurons, emotions, and psychological disorders, etc. A mob can also be potentially a million times more powerful than a single human being, so how can you give such an entity the rights of an individual? Moreover, humans may like chickens and dogs, but a mob, through some freak compromise, decides to satisfy itself by breeding a half dog / chicken. Such a thing would never be concocted at the individual level, but is potentially possible at the mob level. And if it works out, it could actually be the most logical solution to satisfy the mob (an entity). > But lets ignore that. Do you believe that after forming a group, you give up all constitutional rights when acting as part of the group? I.e., while the government can't censor me, it can censor papers I publish as part of my association with a larger group (NYU, my employer)? That depends. If the sole purpose of you publishing your paper is to advance the factional agendas of NYU, AND if NYU acknowledges that your paper is speaking for NYU, the entity, then yes. But that doesn't mean you can't personally publish the paper. The only thing that can be potentially forbidden is NYU, using it's power to give your paper more voice and merit than it deserves. However if you are publishing it personally, then no such regulation can happen because constitutionally your rights are protected.