3 ms·
Won't happen. Nasa will never do a purely propulsive landing of such a craft. Parachutes cannot act as backup to a rocket-powered landing. Chutes need speed+
by sandworm101 11y ago
Won't happen. Nasa will never do a purely propulsive landing of such a craft.
Parachutes cannot act as backup to a rocket-powered landing. Chutes need speed+altitude to deploy. If the rockets fail 25 meters above the ground, chutes won't save anything. If the craft has chutes+people on board, they will be deployed long before touchdown. Better out than in.
The only fully propulsive landing option, with humans on board, would be to have a second set of engines ready to perform what in an airplane would be called a zero-zero ejection maneuver[1]. This would see the craft reverse course, ascending rapidly to a trajectory where the chutes have time/energy enough to properly deploy. It would basically be a launch escape system. To keep that, and the chutes, and the descent engines ... just use the chutes. It isn't saving much money not deploying them as they will probably require repacking for inspection either way.
[1]A zero-zero ejection seat is one that can save a pilot from a craft parked on the runway, at zero-speed and zero altitude. Older seats required altitude and/or speed. But the dragon would be descending, with a negative alt/speed, so I guess this would be a sub-zero-zero ejection. A descent escape maneuver?
- tempestn 11y agoYou make some useful points about the challenges. However, NASA will never do a purely propulsive landing of such a craft? Is it really inconceivable that over time it could become, and be demonstrated to be, at least equally safe to using parachutes?
- sandworm101 11y agoNever isn't from a policy but a physics standpoint. If the chutes are already there, then it makes sense to use them. They are lighter/cheaper than hauling a full backup rocket system. From what I've seen, it looks like SpaceX plans on using the rockets to cushion a landing already under chutes, like the russians do today. That allows for much smaller chutes and faster landing. If the rockets fail then the landing with be rough but still survivable, with the re-usability of the craft being written off. The propulsive landing of booster stages makes sense only because you already have giant engine/fuel reserves, which aren't going to orbit. And since there are no humans around you don't need any sort of abort option. Also, if you are going to have a potentially rough landing, would you rather do so sitting 6" from a box containing a parachute, or 6" from a tank of rocket fuel?
- tempestn 11y ago> Also, if you are going to have a potentially rough landing, would you rather do so sitting 6" from a box containing a parachute, or 6" from a tank of rocket fuel? The former, of course. I agree that a propulsive landing wouldn't be likely any time in the near future. But if it could eventually be shown to be safe (and therefore the quote above doesn't apply), I don't necessarily agree that it would be more expensive. You wouldn't need large engines or a lot of fuel, as the capsule wouldn't be very heavy. Yes, it would definitely still be more expensive than parachutes in terms of equipment and weight. However, it would mean you could land right back at your facility, rather than splashing down in the ocean and dealing with retrieval. When we're looking into the future of reusable, commodity space travel, that would be a significant advantage.
- sandworm101 11y agoWhy would a parachute not land at the home facility? Some, parafoils, can be flow and landed on runways like a glider. Nasa has been working on this concept for years. The X38 one was massive overkill, a full glider, but the concept of a chute directing the craft to a very specific touchdown point is well within today's tech. http://spaceflight.nasa.gov/history/station/x38/parafoil.html http://spaceflight.nasa.gov/history/station/x38/parafoil.htm...
- mikeash 11y agoDragon 2 has full engine out redundancy for landing already. And even if that's not good enough for NASA, they probably won't be the only customers.
- sandworm101 11y agoIt has the reserves of engine power, but not a full separation of fuel and control systems. For human spaceflight they want to see a backup system that is dissimilar and disconnected from the failing system. So launch abort is a different rocket than that lifting the craft. For chutes, that's an extra chute stored in a different box. For propulsive landing, that would need to be separate rockets using separate fuel tanks controlled by a separate control system. Chutes will be lighter/cheaper.