3 ms·
> I'm absolutely assuming a company is purely a vessel to voice the shareholders opinions, provided that doing so is in accordance with the corporate charter.
by chrischen 17y ago
> I'm absolutely assuming a company is purely a vessel to voice the shareholders opinions, provided that doing so is in accordance with the corporate charter.
Then the company will become a vessel to voice the opinion of the corporate charter.
> It depends. As far as I know, the corporate charter of Apple is the standard "increase shareholder value" charter. In that case, it would not be acceptable for Apple to do this unless somehow segregation increased shareholder value. In fact, pushing segregation would be violating the rights of minority shareholders.
So isn't pushing agendas that have the sole purpose of increasing shareholder value potentially contradictory to the interests of the general public population of citizens, whom the government are obligated to serve?
> On the other hand, the corporate charter allowed Apple to devote 10% of their profits to general racism (or perhaps to general social causes, as agreed to by the board), then it would be acceptable regardless of the opinion of the minority.
Again the company now is acting as an inhuman entity. It has interests characterized by a charter, not by a human being's potentially malleable opinions.
> This is simply a question of contract law. If you don't like the charter of a company, don't buy shares.
Yes but some of us can't say no to an iPhone. Should we be forced to indirectly support segregation?
> This is not an issue restricted to corporations. In general, we allow people to persuade other people to vote in all sorts of ways. Some people have persuasive power accrued through unrelated methods.
Yes we allow individuals to do that. But there is a reason corporations imposing their influence is frowned upon. I think your misunderstanding stems from the fact that you see a company as having the rights of a person. But a company is not a person. A company does not have the same needs as a person and thus it has the possibility of having conflicting interests with those of a citizen. The government is here to provide equal representation for citizens, not arbitrary entities.
> For example, Barack Obama has verbal persuasive power accrued through methods (community organizing and teaching law) completely unrelated to government insurance, union bailouts and cash for clunkers. Should he be forbidden from speaking?
No because Barack Obama is a human, he is not a corporation. He has a right to speak for human beings' interests because he is one (at least the last time I checked). A company is not a human. It has a distinct non-human character defined by your so called "corporate charter." A corporation accruing power (through money) is different from a human accruing power through money, or otherwise. A corporation does it because it has to, a human does it for a plethora of reasons unknown. But we do know that whatever the human's reasons are, they are because he/she is a human. And the government is supposed to represent the interest of human citizens.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThen the company will become a vessel to voice the opinion of the corporate charter. The charter was agreed to by all shareholders. Those who found it unacceptable chose not to buy shares. Again the company now is acting as an inhuman entity. It has interests characterized by a charter, not by a human being's potentially malleable opinions. The company is acting as a group of people who have agreed to devote a certain amount of their wealth (their initial investment) to work toward a certain purpose (whatever the charter says). The "company" doesn't actually exist - all there is is a set of contracts between shareholders. The "company" is merely a legal facade to simplify interactions between the shareholders and other parties. Yes but some of us can't say no to an iPhone. Should we be forced to indirectly support segregation? If you choose to buy products from companies supporting segregation, that's on you. Steve Jobs doesn't have mind control rays. He neither forced you to buy shares or an iPhone. Also, the issue if your trading partners spending money on causes you dislike is not limited to corporations. For all you know, the owner of your local bakery is a secret racist sending money to the Klan.
- chrischen 17y agoI'd also like to add: > Similarly, your computer does not have any rights, but you do have the right to post hacker news comments using your computer (provided pg lets you). You're supposed to only have one account. PG gives YOU a right to post hacker news comments, not your computer. The computer is a direct representation of you. A company is a distinct entity created from the collection of people. Your analogy is faulty. > The charter was agreed to by all shareholders. Those who found it unacceptable chose not to buy shares. Yet the charter which is agreed upon is a distinct entity concocted by human beings. At best it's a monster like frankenstein. > The "company" is merely a legal facade to simplify interactions between the shareholders and other parties. Yet the company is also a distinct entity. Look the US government guarantees rights to individuals, not groups or corporations. Groups that come together for a common interest only amplify their voice by the collective pooling of their individual voices. A corporation pools those individual voices into a mob, which does something else independent of any one person's will. It's a distinct entity. It is not a human. It does not have rights like a citizen. I can't stress this enough: the government guarantees certain right to individual people, not groups that can be arbitrarily formed.