5 ms·
> Or you can continue using your old OS on your old Mac No, that's the whole point. That used to be possible, but it isn't any more (or soon won't be).
by lisper 11y ago
> Or you can continue using your old OS on your old Mac
No, that's the whole point. That used to be possible, but it isn't any more (or soon won't be).
- coldtea 11y agoContinue to run doesn't mean you get free OS updates for life.
- lisper 11y agoWhat on earth leads you to think that I expect free OS updates for life?
- dpark 11y agoThe way I read this, you're not asking for OS upgrades for life, but you are asking for service support for life. You want to be able to use your old OS on your old Mac, but you also want your old software to keep running even if it depends on external services (which are not unchanging). Is that correct? If so, this is not meaningfully different than expecting upgrades for life. This is expecting perpetual backwards compatibility. If anything, lifetime upgrades is easier.
- lisper 11y ago> you are asking for service support for life No. What I'm asking for is to not have arbitrary restrictions imposed on me if I try to maintain old software beyond its service life. For example: I have a legally licensed copy of Snow Leopard. I would like to be able to run it on a VM, but I can't because the license doesn't allow it. (Yes, I know I can run Snow Leopard Server on a VM -- and I do -- but Snow Leopard Server is not quite the same as Snow Leopard.) I also have a legally licensed copy of Mavericks, but I have no way of doing a clean install of Mavericks since it has been pulled from the App Store. (Yes, I am told that some people have Mavericks in their purchased tab in the App Store. But I don't, probably because I bought a machine that had it already installed.) Likewise for iPhoto. I would also like to be able to install a new version of an application while keeping the old version. Or at the very least I would like to be able to roll back to an old version if I don't like the new version for some reason. With the App Store, I can't do any of these things.
- dpark 11y agoI don't disagree with any of that, but that all seems unrelated to "version ratchet". VM restrictions have nothing to do with being pushed to upgrade. The inability to do a clean install of Mavericks kind of does, but that seems like a crappy oversight rather than an intentional push Same for the app rollback scenario. That seems less an intention to push upgrades and more of a lack of investment in exposing older versions. I suspect that many app authors are happy with this one, though, because it reduces their support costs because the number of old installs can only decrease over time.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- plafl 11y agoI wonder why I'm not entitled to free updates that correct bugs in some software I paid for
- dpark 11y agoIn perpetuity? Does your payment of $100 oblige the software manufacturer to provide bug fixes for you indefinitely?
- Silhouette 11y agoSurely that depends on the nature of the bugs and what is reasonable in the circumstances? However, for software bought at substantial cost, where the nature of the defect is such that the software doesn't do what it's supposed to, it seems reasonable to me that someone in the supply chain might be on the hook for all or part of the original purchase price if the defect happens within the reasonably expected working lifetime of the software (which might need defining explicitly somewhere for licences that are in principle indefinite, but could certainly run to many years in some cases). Similarly, if the defect causes other damage through negligence, or results in other losses as a consequence of using the software but then not being able to use it any more, it seems reasonable that someone in the supply chain might be on the hook for paying compensation, possibly exceeding the original purchase price in serious cases if that's what it takes to make good the damage. I'm wary of unrealistic laws that assume bug-free software is something we know how to create, and I'm wary of laws that restrict new business models such as rental/SaaS schemes. But right now the system is so heavily one-sided that it's silly, with the big businesses making the big name software products generating huge profits while their users sometimes suffer real damage because of defects in those products.
- dpark 11y agoThe supported lifespan of expensive software is generally spelled out. The problem is that people want support to go on indefinitely for free, and so they use software that is no longer supported. If you buy software and the manufacturer only guarantees two years of support, then you should plan to upgrade at or before the two year mark, or negotiate a support deal with the manufacturer. If you continue using the software after support has ended, you are by definition unsupported and I'd say absent any malicious damage or major negligence on the part of the manufacturer, any issues are on you. You can't buy a car and then expect that the manufacturer will be on the hook for an engine failure after the warranty period unless the failure is caused by major negligence or malicious design. Perpetual support is not something any other industry provides. I don't understand why software manufacturers should attempt that either.
- davidwparker 11y agoYou must have skipped this line in the article: "but then my old Macbook Pro died..."
- wingerlang 11y agoAnd he got a new one, so he can't run an old OS on his new laptop. So the old+old still works.
- lisper 11y agoBut I can run an old OS on my new laptop. In fact, I can run many old OS's on my new laptop. I run MacOS 6 (using vmac). I run Windows XP (using Parallels). I even run old Apple II software (using VirtualII). But I can't run Snow Leopard (only Snow Leopard Server, which is not quite the same thing) because the license doesn't allow it, and Parallels enforces that restriction.
- coldtea 11y ago>only Snow Leopard Server, which is not quite the same thing Well, it's hardly different. It's Snow Leopard, same kernel and userland and everything, PLUS a number of extra packages.