3 ms·
Taxation of certain viewpoints or topics but not others would, indeed, be a violation of free speech. I.e., a ban or tax on film reels would not be a violation
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Taxation of certain viewpoints or topics but not others would, indeed, be a violation of free speech. I.e., a ban or tax on film reels would not be a violation of free speech. A ban or tax on film reels containing "Hillary: The Movie" would be.
I also don't understand your "hostile takeover" argument. Who is being enslaved? The corporate officers who are free to quit at any time? The shareholders who voluntarily sell to the person taking over?
- argv_empty 17y agoIf expending money is speech, taxes are compulsory speech, which is a pretty serious abridging of free speech.
- Semiapies 17y agoPublic campaign financing would be exactly that.
- tsally 17y agoConsider sin taxes, which Time Magazine calls "an established tactic" to reduce consumption of popular vices [1]. The hostile takeover argument isn't even necessary to make my point. Consider the fact that a corporation can own another corporation. Corporations are people under the law. Therefore, if we literally interpret the constitution, the ban on slavery makes a corporation owning another corporation illegal. Of course this is rather silly and shows why strict constructionist interpretations of the Constitution are irrelevant. I am not trying to make political statements. The one and only thing I want to point out is the flaw in the highest voted comment for this article that advocates a strict constructionist interpretation of the 1st amendment [2]. [1] http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1889187,00.html http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1889187,00.... [2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1098741 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1098741
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI think you are interpreting "legal personhood" in a manner that is incorrect. "Legal personhood" means that the corporate entity is a legal person in the matter of contracts and lawsuits. The "person" of the corporation is just a facade (in the design patterns sense) which provides useful simplifications in contracts and lawsuits. You could completely replace corporate personhood with contract law. You would just have 10,000 page contracts that would specify the liability of each individual shareholders is limited to X, a lawsuit must target all shareholders and damages/debts are limited to Y, etc. Basically, each contract would reproduce corporate law. Then whenever you wanted to collect a debt or sue the company, you'd need to dig into the contract to figure out how. Instead, we've created a useful simplification/standardization: you say "Company X owes me $50,000", and it's up to Company X to figure out internally how to deal with this. It's also standardized to a few specific forms (LLCs, LLPs, S-Corps, C-corps, etc). That's all corporate personhood is. A corporation has no inherent rights except those rights granted it by it's shareholders. Similarly, your computer has no rights, but that doesn't mean the government can pass a law saying "your computer may not criticize Obama." Such a law doesn't violate your computers rights, it violates your rights. Similarly, laws against political speech violate the rights of the owners of the corporation who are ordinary flesh and blood people (as opposed to legal facades to simplify lawsuits and contracts).
- tsally 17y agoFirst, thanks for the specifics on "legal personhood". Definitely helpful for me. I do not believe that restrictions on corporations violate the individual rights of the owners. Aren't the owners are allowed to participate in politics individually, just as every citizen can?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoRestrictions on corporations prevent the owners from using some of their property to participate in politics. Similarly, computers aren't people. So does a restriction on "speech by computers" violate your rights? I.e., a law saying "you can't use your computer to advocate for or against the election of a politician?"