6 ms·
Upgrade or die: Apple's re-invention of the version ratchet
- coldtea 11y ago>This sounds like a positive development, but it's actually an indication of something quite ominous that most people don't realize: for several years now, Apple has been deploying a strategy straight out of Microsoft's Big Book of Dirty Tricks which I am hereby dubbing the version ratchet. A version ratchet is a software deployment strategy that forces you to upgrade even if you don't want to. Nothing dirty about it. If you "don't want to" just use an OS vendor that doesn't force you. Or you can continue using your old OS on your old Mac. It's not like it will stop working altogether -- people use Amiga computers still with 1990-era OS/WorkbenchS from what I hear. The alternative to what Apple does is slower OS upgrade cycles and/or devoting resources to 5 and 10 year old OSes. Which we had with MS -- 15+ years of XP (and a decade of IE6 dominance), holding IT back.
- lisper 11y ago> Or you can continue using your old OS on your old Mac No, that's the whole point. That used to be possible, but it isn't any more (or soon won't be).
- coldtea 11y agoContinue to run doesn't mean you get free OS updates for life.
- lisper 11y agoWhat on earth leads you to think that I expect free OS updates for life?
- dpark 11y agoThe way I read this, you're not asking for OS upgrades for life, but you are asking for service support for life. You want to be able to use your old OS on your old Mac, but you also want your old software to keep running even if it depends on external services (which are not unchanging). Is that correct? If so, this is not meaningfully different than expecting upgrades for life. This is expecting perpetual backwards compatibility. If anything, lifetime upgrades is easier.
- lisper 11y ago> you are asking for service support for life No. What I'm asking for is to not have arbitrary restrictions imposed on me if I try to maintain old software beyond its service life. For example: I have a legally licensed copy of Snow Leopard. I would like to be able to run it on a VM, but I can't because the license doesn't allow it. (Yes, I know I can run Snow Leopard Server on a VM -- and I do -- but Snow Leopard Server is not quite the same as Snow Leopard.) I also have a legally licensed copy of Mavericks, but I have no way of doing a clean install of Mavericks since it has been pulled from the App Store. (Yes, I am told that some people have Mavericks in their purchased tab in the App Store. But I don't, probably because I bought a machine that had it already installed.) Likewise for iPhoto. I would also like to be able to install a new version of an application while keeping the old version. Or at the very least I would like to be able to roll back to an old version if I don't like the new version for some reason. With the App Store, I can't do any of these things.
- dpark 11y agoI don't disagree with any of that, but that all seems unrelated to "version ratchet". VM restrictions have nothing to do with being pushed to upgrade. The inability to do a clean install of Mavericks kind of does, but that seems like a crappy oversight rather than an intentional push Same for the app rollback scenario. That seems less an intention to push upgrades and more of a lack of investment in exposing older versions. I suspect that many app authors are happy with this one, though, because it reduces their support costs because the number of old installs can only decrease over time.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- plafl 11y agoI wonder why I'm not entitled to free updates that correct bugs in some software I paid for
- dpark 11y agoIn perpetuity? Does your payment of $100 oblige the software manufacturer to provide bug fixes for you indefinitely?
- Silhouette 11y agoSurely that depends on the nature of the bugs and what is reasonable in the circumstances? However, for software bought at substantial cost, where the nature of the defect is such that the software doesn't do what it's supposed to, it seems reasonable to me that someone in the supply chain might be on the hook for all or part of the original purchase price if the defect happens within the reasonably expected working lifetime of the software (which might need defining explicitly somewhere for licences that are in principle indefinite, but could certainly run to many years in some cases). Similarly, if the defect causes other damage through negligence, or results in other losses as a consequence of using the software but then not being able to use it any more, it seems reasonable that someone in the supply chain might be on the hook for paying compensation, possibly exceeding the original purchase price in serious cases if that's what it takes to make good the damage. I'm wary of unrealistic laws that assume bug-free software is something we know how to create, and I'm wary of laws that restrict new business models such as rental/SaaS schemes. But right now the system is so heavily one-sided that it's silly, with the big businesses making the big name software products generating huge profits while their users sometimes suffer real damage because of defects in those products.
- dpark 11y agoThe supported lifespan of expensive software is generally spelled out. The problem is that people want support to go on indefinitely for free, and so they use software that is no longer supported. If you buy software and the manufacturer only guarantees two years of support, then you should plan to upgrade at or before the two year mark, or negotiate a support deal with the manufacturer. If you continue using the software after support has ended, you are by definition unsupported and I'd say absent any malicious damage or major negligence on the part of the manufacturer, any issues are on you. You can't buy a car and then expect that the manufacturer will be on the hook for an engine failure after the warranty period unless the failure is caused by major negligence or malicious design. Perpetual support is not something any other industry provides. I don't understand why software manufacturers should attempt that either.
- davidwparker 11y agoYou must have skipped this line in the article: "but then my old Macbook Pro died..."
- wingerlang 11y agoAnd he got a new one, so he can't run an old OS on his new laptop. So the old+old still works.
- lisper 11y agoBut I can run an old OS on my new laptop. In fact, I can run many old OS's on my new laptop. I run MacOS 6 (using vmac). I run Windows XP (using Parallels). I even run old Apple II software (using VirtualII). But I can't run Snow Leopard (only Snow Leopard Server, which is not quite the same thing) because the license doesn't allow it, and Parallels enforces that restriction.
- coldtea 11y ago>only Snow Leopard Server, which is not quite the same thing Well, it's hardly different. It's Snow Leopard, same kernel and userland and everything, PLUS a number of extra packages.
- spc476 11y agoYou need to be very careful if you are too deep into the Apple ecosystem. I have a Mac, iPad and iPhone. There was a feature of iOS 9 I wanted (blocking ads) but when I did that, I was no longer able to connect my iPhone to the Mac, and I pretty much lost a month to that. http://boston.conman.org/2015/10/04-31 http://boston.conman.org/2015/10/04-31
- kartickv 11y agoThat reads like a rant, and I don't understand what the actual problem is — do you have an old Mac that can't be upgraded to the latest OS X? Do you have to pay money to upgrade OS X, and you don't want to? Or do you refuse to apply a free OS upgrade? If it's the last of the three, then that's just a decision on Apple's part to not waste resources trying to support every possible combination of OS X version and iOS version. Yes, that leaves people like you unhappy, but leaves the majority of users happy, with better software.
- spc476 11y agoI had a Mac (a few years old) that I was happy with and saw no need to upgrade (if it ain't broke, don't fix it). Had I known that the upgrade to iOS9 (which had a feature I would like) would make it impossible to backup said phone to the Mac, I would not have upgraded it (especially since once the upgrade to the iPhone happened, it was impossible to downgrade to iOS 8.4, which I was also happy with). Yes, the upgrade was free (monetarily). It was not free timewise, and it took a few weeks to sort out as it completely broke my workflow (it broke the running version of Synergy http://synergy-project.org/ http://synergy-project.org/ and to upgrade that would have required an upgrade of my Linux system (yes, it's an older system---again, it ain't broke so I'm not fixing it and lose even more time and effort). I was able to fix the Synergy issue (http://boston.conman.org/2015/10/15.2 http://boston.conman.org/2015/10/15.2) but the point remains---Apple forcing updates. I know most here just live with the constant upgrade treadmill ("OH MY GOD! YOU HAVEN'T UPDATED IN 20 MINUTES? HERETIC!") but having been burned oh so many times in the past thirty years I've grown to dread it. It gets tiresome relearning how to use something I've already learned how to use yet again. For the tenth time. Because we in the industry have deemed that if a program hasn't been changed in the past twenty minutes, it therefore must be unmaintained and a piece of garbage (with the sole exception of zlib I think). Me, bitter?
- fishanz 11y agoI'm also really purturbed by apple's 'version ratchet' (great term btw). In my case it's the infuriation caused by the 'notifications' to upgrade ... Which you CANT DISMISS! It's either install, or 'remind me later': tonight..tomorrow, but explicitly not 'never for this version'. I've turned off notifications altogether on Yosemite. Ios9 is the icing on the cake.
- ajmurmann 11y agoWhat about security vulnerabilities that get fixed in those updates? You don't want those? This got us Chinese bot nets on outdated XP machines...
- grandalf 11y agoThis is exactly the issue. It is irresponsible for a vendor not to nudge users toward upgrading when older versions no longer make sense to support.
- fishanz 11y ago'Nudging' me to update from Yosemite to El Capitan is just annoying. It's one iteration!
- ksml 11y agoApple continues to release security patches on older versions of OS X for a while. In my case, I am on Yosemite and have not upgraded to El Capitan yet, but I have all the latest security patches.
- fishanz 11y agoNo I totally get it about the security updates; but it's the principle that I can't opt out if my own dumb ass wants to. Ultimately I would absolutely opt-in for security updates, but they don't seem to come stand-alone. If I'm not mistaken, Apple can push critical security updates these days anyway - there's been at least one.
- lisper 11y ago
- Joof 11y agoSo basically the cloud model removes power from the consumer. Nothing new here, but a good reminder.
- voltagex_ 11y agoI'm pretty sure if you can get your hands on the App/DMG version of Lion, it's possible to create an ISO, or at least a bootable thumbdrive. That's what the Hackintosh folk do.
- hobs 11y agoI have an Apple made thumb drive of lion(its tiny!), they do exist, they are just rare.
- tim333 11y agokat.cr have torrents of all the old Mac OSs
- walterbell 11y agoIs there a list of known-good hashes for official Mac installers?
- notpeter 11y agoThere is now. https://github.com/notpeter/apple-installer-checksums https://github.com/notpeter/apple-installer-checksums
- walterbell 11y agoThank you!
- ksml 11y agoI'm not sure why this is being downvoted. My understanding is that it is perfectly legal to download OS X 10.8+ this way; the updates were offered by Apple for free as long as you run them on a legit mac (which I'm assuming you are). The downloads on kat.cr are the same exact DMG files you would get if you downloaded from the app store. If this is not the case, feel free to correct me.
- prewett 11y ago
- mcooley 11y ago> Microsoft implemented it back in their glory days (irony intended) by changing the file formats in new versions of the Office suite so that documents created by newer versions of Office could not be read by older versions, thus forcing everyone to upgrade to the newer version in order to share data. In fact, Microsoft released updates for older versions of Office (back to Word 2000, apparently!) which allowed them to read the new formats [1]. [1] https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Open-a-Word-2007-document-in-an-earlier-version-of-Word-8FE47805-64A9-4CC5-A115-B148625FE043 https://support.office.com/en-us/article/Open-a-Word-2007-do...
- nness 11y agoNot to mention the fundamental differences between pre-2007 and Office 2007 document formats. I tend to think that the format change wasn't a forced deprecation of older software, but rather just a simple business case. Simplify maintenance and support, and create an open-ish standard to avoid competition + support industry.
- Aloha 11y agothe old binary formats for office were the collected history of 20 years of software development, and even Microsoft had trouble with consistent implementation - at least OOXML had a digestible easy to use standard.
- jlawer 11y agoI imagine this is more talking about Word 6 and Office 97 then the later versions. The 2000 upgrade was forced by the aim of making the office XML files the new standard as opposed to the competing OASIS (OpenOffice) standard.
- aftbit 11y ago>When Apple introduced El Cap, it deprecated iPhoto in favor of Photos. Photos is missing a crucial piece of functionality: the ability to export an album as a web page. Apple wants you to share your photos using iCloud. Well, I don't want to use iCloud. I run my own server, and I want to share my photos there. I'm frequently bothered by the shockingly anti-competitive nature of software today. Walled gardens and lock-in are pretty terrifying. If you want to continue to control your data, you can't trade control of it away to a software company for convenience and a shiny user interface. My collection of music managed by beets[1] (and properly id3 tagged) will never be inaccessible to me because all of the data formats are open and standard. If I were using iTunes, perhaps that would someday be untrue. I'm not a big photos person - do any awesome FOSS photo management programs exist? [1] https://beets.readthedocs.org/en/latest/guides/main.html https://beets.readthedocs.org/en/latest/guides/main.html
- cookiecaper 11y agoMany have open-source photo managers have come and gone but imo Digikam is still the best. It's not perfect, but probably the most robust, and one of the few that has shown it can survive the gauntlet and keep users around for years at a time.
- rimantas 11y agoWhere is the anti-competitive behaviour in this? It is not that you cannot export your photos, it just does not have a feature to make a gallery with one click. Your note abou iTunes is also off the mark.
- LeoPanthera 11y ago> If I were using iTunes, perhaps that would someday be untrue. That's simply not true. The iTunes store sells DRM-free AAC, a documented format. You can transcode it into literally any other format, if you don't like AAC. Ripped CDs are ripped to the format of your choice. Only the Apple Music streaming service uses DRM - and buying a DRM-free version of any track is literally one click away. I can think of many things to criticise Apple for, but lock-in of your music is not one of them.
- carsongross 11y agoI've ended up using third party apps that aren't sold through the app store. More and more developers are getting sick of apples shit, and a lot of good-enough alternatives exist out there that you can have a decent setup without dealing with it. The app store is such a clusterfuck anyway, I hardly ever open it except by accident.
- cthulhua 11y agoThis is a logical consequence of non-free software. I'd add that even in the free software case, there's a non-zero cost to supporting legacy software as first-class citizens, to the point where it often just doesn't make sense.
- Aloha 11y agoIts a logical consequence of resource limits, technical debt is expensive, and must be resolved eventually. There is a reason that support for GTK 1.x applications vanished over time, as well as ones that needed old compilers, tied to old library version, and old versions of glibc.
- mietek 11y ago> The only way you can run Lion nowadays is if you find a working machine that has Lion installed on it. No. If you’ve previously purchased OS X Lion, you can still download it via the App Store, but it won’t be included in your list of purchased items by default. To fix this, choose the “View My Account” command from the “Store” menu, and click the “Manage” link next to the “Hidden Purchases” field. You’ll now be able to unhide each hidden item by clicking the appropriate “Unhide” button.
- pcurve 11y agoThat one just sounds like a dark pattern.
- dba7dba 11y ago3 clicks to do just that?
- awad 11y agoReally?
- kobayashi 11y agoOr torrent it. Not a great solution, yet a solution nonetheless.
- lisper 11y agoSorry, I see neither a "manage" link nor a "hidden purchases" field. I have App Store 1.3 on Mavericks.
- jolux 11y ago>You will upgrade because all of your data will be in iCloud and all of your finances will be in Apple Pay, and you will have no choice: you will upgrade or die. You can download all of your iCloud data from the web client, and Apple Pay doesn't involve the cloud at all. It's all stored and encrypted locally and you have to re-add your cards with every new device. (I don't even think they persist over backups?) >Even if Apple doesn't implement this strategy, they could, and that to me is cause for concern. Personally, I don't want the only thing standing in the way of being coerced in this way to buy things I don't want to be the continued benevolence of the largest corporation in the world. I want an escape hatch to keep Apple in check. And right now, I don't see one. Yes, and Microsoft could do the same. Will either of them actually do so? I doubt it, but I suppose it's possible on an infinite timeline. Keep in mind that Apple needs a platform for their own developers to use, and for app developers, and closing the Mac would make that very difficult. Apple also knows how many of its customers are developers and they wouldn't just throw that away for questionable gains. Lock-in is fragile because eventually you get users using your stuff because they have to instead of because they want to, which is never a good situation. >And the tools are set up so that you can only build for supported version of the OS. Near as I can tell, this is false. I can set my deployment target all the way back to OS X 10.4. Will this not work?
- n0us 11y agoI went from iPhone to Android and back again to iPhone. I had no troubles at all with either transition. Tech journalism can be so dramatic sometimes.
- rcraft 11y agoNo problems with iMessage screwing you over when switching from Apple to Android? If you ever participate in any group mms messages its borderline impossible to escape apples ecosystem without serious drawbacks. If you switch to android and want to still receive group mms from friends, every member of the group mms that has an iPhone has to delete the entire thread and start a new thread. Not only that, they each need to add you or another non ios member as the first person in their new mms. Pretty ridiculous and irresponsible if you ask me.
- dba7dba 11y agoAnother good example is exporting Notes files from iPad. You HAVE to have 10.9 OS X on your laptop. With all those engineers on payroll they can't allow exporting to older OS?
- rsync 11y ago"And nowadays everything is in the app store, including the developer tools. And the tools are set up so that you can only build for supported version of the OS. It is still possible to use XCode to build an application for Snow Leopard because you can still get an old XCode install DVD and an old Snow Leopard install DVD, and if you get Snow Leopard Server you can even run it on a VM. So no matter what Apple does, you can run Snow Leopard forever if you want to." Sigh. That makes me very happy. It also makes me very happy that I saved, into cold storage, every single .iso and .pkg and ... everything ... that I ever downloaded from the apple developers site. The old apple dev resources/download site was too good to be true - you knew it was going to go away.
- qzervaas 11y agoYou can download the newest Xcode et al without the App Store, from here: https://developer.apple.com/downloads/ https://developer.apple.com/downloads/ (Edit: You can download Xcode all the way back to Xcode 2.3 from 2006)
- rebootthesystem 11y agoApple scares me. It's like a totalitarian regime. All is well so long as you behave an fall in line. Like them or not, they have a lot to learn from Microsoft. I can't remember many instances of having your entire computing existence obsoleted. MS has always been very aware of maintaining compatibility, which is a sign of respect towards their userbase.
- shurcooL 11y agoThey day I no longer want to use Apple's latest stable versions of software is the day I'll start thinking about migrating away. Also, this is why I invest my free time into pushing open source forward, so it can displace the few closed source things I still use/depend on.
- steele 11y ago>That's fair enough; you can't expect OS vendors to support ancient hardware forever. The direct Microsoft criticism and definition of 'ancient hardware' seems entirely... Apple reality distortion filter
- benevol 11y agoyou can't expect OS vendors to support ancient hardware forever That's funny, because that's pretty much what I've been experiencing with Ubuntu during the last decade. Not only do I really OWN my hardware and get to decide WHEN and IF I want to spend money for a new machine or not, but the hardware support gets even more complete with every passing month. To sum it up, time is on YOUR side, not on some company's side.
- Silhouette 11y agoI like the term "version ratcheting". It captures the essence of a particularly insidious disease that is currently plaguing our industry. There are several other variations that are starting to become widespread as well. A lot of professional software, the kind of stuff that costs 4+ figures for a permanent licence, is seriously defective when first shipped and then receives updates, perhaps via some proprietary tool. What happens if you need to reinstall it but the updates are no longer available, or the update files are available but the tool no longer functions to install them as you could before? A lot of professional software also requires some form of activation, and may provide a related tool to migrate a licence from one PC to another. Again, what happens if you have a properly purchased copy and want to use it according to your agreement but the developers have turned off the lights on the activation server? I suspect laws are going to have to change before too long to keep up with the real relationships involved in modern software. Normal commercial agreements between a purchaser and a vendor don't really cut it in 2016, because the third party -- the software developer -- has a much bigger role in the ongoing nature of how the software works. Turning a blind eye to defective software has worked reasonably well in practice as long as we had the gentleman's agreement that developers would provide free updates to correct the serious flaws anyway, but increasingly that is no longer the case or the updates come with strings attached. In an age of DRM, activation, automatic updates, dependence on remote systems, and the like, it might be necessary to start imposing statutory requirements on vendors and original developers responsible for software, to ensure that users can continue to enjoy what they were actually agreeing to pay for in the first place or receive suitable compensation. It might also be necessary to enforce minimum periods of support for permanent licences, and to limit the kinds of lock-in that can be applied with temporary licences or online components, in order to follow the same basic principles of consumer protection and fair competition as other fields.
- jrbapna 11y agoOn the positive side, a quicker upgrade curve helps developers iterate faster, and improves software quality as a whole. Our team is much more effective when we know we only have to support the latest 2-3 releases of our app, and we can simply prompt anyone using anything older to upgrade.
- notliketherest 11y agoI just don't understand why people cling to the old version of software (barring some crazy malfeasance by the developer or something..). I've got all of my apps on auto upgrade. Also, as an app developer, this is an endless pain in my ass.
- lisper 11y agoFWIW, I'm "clinging" to Mavericks because nothing beyond it will run iPhoto. Also, I really hate the new "flat look."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]