3 ms·
The most commonly cited issue with this line of reasoning is that the root reason for private sector unions (massive power disparity between employers and emplo
by pc86 11y ago
The most commonly cited issue with this line of reasoning is that the root reason for private sector unions (massive power disparity between employers and employees) simply don't exist in the public sphere.
Public sector employees often vote for or against their current bosses directly.
- hackuser 11y ago> Public sector employees often vote for or against their current bosses directly. That's a very weak bargaining position: Give us what we want or our members, a small minority of the electorate, won't vote for you in two years. Why should they be weaker than other unions?
- snomad 11y agoIt isn't just the vote of the membership. It is the dollars of the organization. In California, the California Teachers Union and SEIU are regularly 2 of the top 3 campaign spenders.
- wfo 11y agoSo you're saying now that they've banded together as a union, they have bargaining power collectively whereas without it they would have none?
- mikeash 11y agoAre you really saying that there is no power imbalance between the government and the people it employs? The power imbalance is, if anything, much worse here.