6 ms·
The key to succesful education is involved parents. It's really that simple. No amount of training or methods is going to change that simple but important fact
by ThomPete 11y ago
The key to succesful education is involved parents. It's really that simple.
No amount of training or methods is going to change that simple but important fact. Involved parents means involved kids which means they will learn.
That isn't to say that the education system shouldn't be optimized (it should)
But there is no problem with education as such. There is a problem with how parents are involved with their kids education.
Edit: To clear up confusion. No I am not saying parents are a substitute for education I am not talking about parents intervening either.
I am saying that by being involved intellectually in their kids education they are providing their kids with the best kind of foundation possible and it will fix a lot of the issues that comes out of parents not being involved or outright harmful to their kids education.
- slig 11y ago> The key to successful education is involved parents. That seems to be the case with asian parents/children and they usually get better GPA. Is there any source that proves or disproves that?
- ThomPete 11y agoI don't know how conclusive the studies are but here is something to go with http://www.nea.org/tools/17360.htm http://www.nea.org/tools/17360.htm However I think it's misleading to focus on their scores as a proof of good education, but that's a whole other discussion.
- CountSessine 11y agoNo amount of training or methods is going to change that simple but important fact. Involved parents means involved kids which means they will learn. As a parent of two school-aged children, I couldn't agree more. At the same time, as a single parent, I have to say that it's hard to ignore the effect that ubiquitous divorce and single-parenting is having on children's schooling. In a single day I have to drag my kids out of bed, make them breakfast, make them lunch, get them to school (all the while they're complaining and dawdling), get to work myself, work a full 8 hour day, get to the daycare and pick up my kids, get home, and make dinner for us. And then do everything else that needs my attention, like bills. And then hound my kids to do their homework, help them with it, and then cajole them to do extra studying in math or writing. It's exhausting and demoralizing having to do this all on your own. And I make a lot more money than is the average where I live, so I can only imagine what it must be like doing all of this with money pressures.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stvswn 11y agoI don't think CountSessine was asking for parenting advice.
- p4wnc6 11y ago> The key to succesful education is involved parents. It's really that simple. This is glib and easy to say, but I don't buy it. When parents try to intervene in their child's education, schools are increasingly hostile. They are beginning to treat school children in a manner similar to how the TSA treats travelers. Here's an example: my parents have a young daughter in middle school in the Midwest. She is active in a school choir, but also wants to do the science fair and many other activities. My parents are lucky because here is a kid who actually wants to do these things. Yet, the choir forces kids to show up at 5:15 am (!) on a Saturday in order to travel 45 minute to a nearby school to do a choir competition at 7:30 am. Further, even though my sister's performance is over at 7:45 am, she has to stay with the school until well after 11:00 am and be bused home. The parents are not allowed to pick up the children early or give them a ride a home at all. This is for 6th, 7th, and 8th graders. At the same time, my sister is expected to do work on her upcoming science fair project (which must adhere to an egregiously onerous template provided on the school's website) and also do all of her regular class homework (which is already a lot in its own right). When my parents spoke up about the unreasonableness of the school making middle schoolers travel to a competition at 5:15 on a weekend morning, and also disallowing their parents from even picking them up early or anything, the school was borderline militant in their reply. They chewed out my parents, said they had no business questioning the choir director's choice of which competitions to attend or what the scheduling was, and basically said that the choice was either to put up or shut up. The school was not willing to compromise or even discuss any of their points about how unhealthy and overly burdensome the whole set of affairs was. In smaller ways, this extends to classroom homework (which is at levels way higher than when I was a child, and yet the kids themselves say (and test scores seem to indicate) that they are retaining less and less of it). If a parent writes in to say the homework is too much, that it is stressing out their 6th grade kid who is staying up until 10:30 pm, crying and self-doubting the whole time, just to keep up with a single day's homework, you don't get any degree of reasonableness whatsoever. I feel that schools and teachers have way too much authority over how children are treated and evaluated, what they are required to do, and so forth. They argue that they have to make it this way to comply with state and federal standards, and that's a big part of the problem. But regardless, it doesn't matter if you are a proactive and supportive parent if your attempts to provide a healthy and nurturing learning atmosphere are constantly and aggressively thwarted by the very teachers and school officials you want to try to work with.
- SmokyBorbon 11y agoMyth. Parents are much more involved than they used to be but students are graduating barely able to read and write. The way to fix education is to make poor teachers accountable for their actions. Schools should not be a babysitting service.
- jseliger 11y agoThe key to succesful education is involved parents. It's really that simple. Not really: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/01/what-makes-a-great-teacher/307841/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/01/what-mak.... It's a common myth, though.
- ThomPete 11y agoNo sure how that is disproving what I say as it's not measuring the effect of parents. That the education system can be optimized is obvious but that does not change any of what I am saying.
- moultano 11y agoBehavioral genetics research has found that "parenting" has little or no effect on most measurable criteria. The scare quotes around parenting are because the definition of it is precise: the component of the child's environment that is shared by siblings.
- ThomPete 11y agoI am not talking about parenting in the sense that you are somehow interfering I am talking about being mentally involved. I.e. the kid know that you are interested in their education. Not that you are somehow providing your own educational system.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bpyne 11y agoThis article highlights that there can be vast differences in effectiveness from one teacher to another. (No surprise, it's true in all professions.) I don't think it's in-depth enough to draw a conclusion about how much of a child's education is due to a quality teacher vs. parents/family/community. In fact, I don't think it is even effective in showing that the one teacher, whose students tended to do better, is a better teacher than the other one. The article just doesn't go into enough detail about the communities around the schools, resources available, the families of the kids, etc. We have three elementary schools within one mile of each other. The schools have similar profiles with a fairly high number kids on free/reduced-price lunch. The teachers from the different schools train with one another. They come from the same education programs. Yet, my daughter's school significantly outperforms the other schools. One difference comes from the parents and the culture/education opportunities they can provide outside the school. Parents regularly take their kids to plays, musicals, museums, historical sites, etc. They also read with their kids nightly. Another important difference is the PTA. Ours is very active. We developed an after school program that offers introductory theater, music, visual arts, sports, marine biology, etc. Thanks to a state legislative grant, we can offer these classes for free to kids whose families can't afford them . Our parents knew enough to look for grants when they started the program. Last year we developed a full theater program for kids who wanted more involved productions. If you're looking at economic classifications, the other two schools' communities can be described as working and lower middle class. Our community is working, lower and upper middle class. Again, the stat on free/reduced-price lunches is similar. The schools' budgets are roughly the same accounting for number of students and age of the buildings. We have kids classified as homeless in our school, as I'm sure the other schools have as well. Yet, our school performs significantly better. The difference is the learning that's happening outside the school. Last year I attended a talk by the president of the principals' association in my state. He cited a study that estimated 48% of a child's education comes from outside the school. There is certainly room for improvement for some teachers. There is also room for modernization in teaching methodology. But, we won't improve education for students as long as we're only looking along one axis for improvement. (Btw, I'm not an educator. I'm a software engineer who happens to be very involved in the PTA for my daughter's school.)
- tokenadult 11y agoThe key to succesful education is involved parents. It's really that simple. Are you a parent yourself? (I am, of four children, two now adults.) Have you ever been a parent in more than one country? (I have both here in the United States and in Taiwan.) Do you regularly communicate with other parents about how well school programs are working for their children? (I participate in a national online network of parents of gifted children every day.) Parent involvement of a certain kind is necessary, but it is not sufficient (unless it takes the form of homeschooling, which is something I did for the primary education of all four of my children). With equally involved and caring parents, pupils and students do better or worse depending especially on curriculum design, and depending also on teacher training and school administration. Studies of school districts that had forced changes of administrators of schools under the now-expired No Child Left Behind law showed that changing administrators in a school can improve learning outcomes for the same group of children brought up by the same group of parents. Moreover, teachers often increased their job satisfaction after such administrative changes.[1] Almost every thread about education on Hacker News has a top comment saying, "Parental involvement is the most important thing." I could agree with that statement (I largely do, as a homeschooling parent) without thinking that statement is any more than a middle-brow dismissal[2] of the submitted article's detailed text unless we have something to discuss here about a) what brings about more parental involvement and b) what else can be done at the margin to improve schools for parents who are already well involved. Let's discuss those issues here rather than be dismissive. AFTER EDIT: I have my own top-level in this thread with substantive response to what the original article author said, but it is pushed far down below the fold by the long subthread development here. [1] http://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2015/10/27/443110755/no-child-left-behind-what-worked-what-didnt http://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2015/10/27/443110755/no-child... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4692598#up_4693920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4692598#up_4693920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10103985#up_10106466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10103985#up_10106466
- ThomPete 11y agoI am a parent of two boys. I am originally from Denmark but moved to the US with my family. My wife is part of the PTA group. My oldest is in Success Academy a charter school. I am not saying it's sufficient not sure how you got that idea. I am saying it's what makes the difference for the children getting education is that their parents are involved. You can't always decide what teachers your kids are getting or what school they go to, who they hang out with and so on. But you can decide if you are going to be involved in your kids education.
- darkroasted 11y agoThere is a problem with how parents are involved with their kids education. This is being too harsh on parents. My parents were very much involved with my own brother's education. They tutored him, got him extra help, set up incentives, etc, etc. But he still did far worse than me. Meanwhile they had to pull me away from the books. I never got help with math homework because I never had any trouble with it. School just came naturally to me. I was just born much smarter than my brother. My parents never had to pressure me to learn programming, I picked it up because it was fun and I was good at it. Heck, I taught myself calculus because I found the problem solving fun. And I see this observation over and over again. If a person is naturally good at cognitive work, sooner or later they will go whole hog on learning some economically useful cognitive skills. If a person is just naturally a bit slower, it will always be an uphill battle. These personal observations are corroborated by adoption studies and twin studies. Twins raised separately end up closer together than non-twins raised together. Adopted children end up closer to their biological parents than their adopted parents. Etc. (sources; http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304898704577478482432277706 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023048987045774784... http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2014/10/genes-dont-just-influence-your-iq-they-determine-how-well-you-do-school http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2014/10/genes-dont-just-influ... )
- ThomPete 11y agoWasn't my intent to be harsh on parents. I am simply saying that involved parents on average means more involved children who will then learn more. Of course there are kids who just learn naturally but they aren't a part of the problem the article is discussing and there are parents who aren't involved in their childrens education.
- humanrebar 11y ago> This is being too harsh on parents. You're looking on the wrong end of the spectrum. The thought is that kids with uninvolved parents tend to have external distractions, behavioral problems, an unwillingness to do homework, underage pregnancies, etc.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> The key to succesful education is involved parents. It's really that simple. I don't buy it. Parental involvement has some value in early education (learning to read and write, for example). But beyond that, I suspect "involved parents" is a proxy for wealth.
- humanrebar 11y ago> But beyond that, I suspect "involved parents" is a proxy for wealth. Meaning, what? Wealthy kids with uninvolved parents do fine? Why?
- aianus 11y ago> Wealthy kids with uninvolved parents do fine? Why? For one, the school and teachers your kid gets is determined by whether you're rich enough to buy or rent property on the correct street (at least, here in Toronto).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickbauman 11y agoStudies have found that this is not completely true. US kids who have parents who volunteer at school (like PTA) actually have poorer academic achievement on average than parents who don't. They have also found that the smartest kids in the world have parents who are not terribly involved at school, at least compared to their US counterparts. The strongest correlative of a child's academic success in the US is the income level of their parents. (source: The Smartest Kids In The World http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0061NT61Y http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0061NT61Y)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ThomPete 11y agoTried to expand on what I mean with parents involvement.
- atom-morgan 11y agoWhat about parental involvement at home?
- pc2g4d 11y agoCorrelation. Causation. You know what I'm saying.
- cloudwizard 11y agoParents replacing school education works. My son went through 5 yrs of public education and learned almost nothing. He learned in after school classes, at home, etc. The problem was that public schools are focussed on underperforming kids and my son was above grade level so they did not bother to teach him. He did have a fun time at recess. Lots of time for reading fiction during class.
- borkabrak 11y agoMay I inquire after your basis for the apparent certainty you have for this position?