5 ms·
The more interesting test for me was the hover tests (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07Pm8ZY0XJI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07Pm8ZY0XJI) I keep doing back
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
The more interesting test for me was the hover tests (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07Pm8ZY0XJI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07Pm8ZY0XJI) I keep doing back of the envelope calculations to see if a Dragon2 has enough fuel capacity to land and return from the lunar surface. Granted there is limited ability to leave and re-enter the capsule but it would make for an interesting capability.
If I recall correctly the "land on land" scenario for dragon has it using parachutes most of the way down, then doing a drop and land at the end.
- JshWright 11y agoFar more important than the parachutes is the atmosphere. Even without parachutes, the atmosphere is responsible for almost all of the deceleration the capsule experiences. The atmosphere takes it from orbital velocity (~30,000 m/s EDIT: ~8,000m/s (km/h->m/s conversion fail)) and slows it down to the terminal velocity of the capsule (~100 m/s). The capsule only has to take care of that last bit from terminal velocity down to 0 m/s. On the moon, there is no atmosphere, so the capsule would have to handle all the deceleration from lunar orbital velocity (~2,000 m/s) to 0. So, in ballpark figures, you're looking at 20 times more 'delta V' (change in velocity) that the capsule would have to accomplish in order to land on the moon. It takes _way_ more fuel to manage that.
- baq 11y agoif you replaced the dragon's trunk with a booster, it should be enough. i'm pretty sure it's not feasible, but in KSP world totally would work.
- sathackr 11y agoobligatory https://xkcd.com/1244/ https://xkcd.com/1244/
- zardo 11y agoI doubt Falcon Heavy could throw enough mass to make it work. Dragon is just a poor vehicle to send to the moon. It should work for landing a few tons on Mars though (one way).
- greglindahl 11y agoFH is 117 MT to LEO vs Saturn V 140 MT, Dragon is bigger/heavier than the Apollo capsule, and the even smaller LEM was the thing that landed on the Moon.
- endymi0n 11y agoNevertheless, quick back-of-the-envelope calculation should make an Apollo-style operation completely viable. Launch Dragon into orbit, Launch a fully loaded second stage without payload into orbit with a second FH and dock with the Dragon, Command Module style, then use the second stage for lunar orbit insertion and back. Should do the trick, even with a much heavier capsule.
- JshWright 11y agoUsing more than one launch is very much not an 'Apollo-style' operation. One of the major features of the Apollo program is that is used a single launch, which distinguished it from all the other competing proposals at the time.
- adwn 11y ago> FH is 117 MT No, FH is advertised [1] as 53 mT to LEO (probably around 200x200 km, 28.5°). [1] http://www.spacex.com/falcon-heavy http://www.spacex.com/falcon-heavy
- greglindahl 11y agoSorry, pounds/kilograms brain fart on my part.
- hughes 11y ago30,000 m/s is several times the escape velocity of Earth... most orbits are close to 8,000m/s!
- JshWright 11y agoYep... km/h -> m/s conversion failure, thanks!
- v0x 11y agoHaving played a number of hours of Kerbal Space Program, I can verify that this information is correct.
- martythemaniak 11y agoI think Dragon 2 is a propulsive landing all the way, with parachutes used only in case of emergency. /r/spacex would be a good place to ask this (and the moon landing question), lots of people are quite knowledgeable and like running numbers like this.
- jordanthoms 11y agoYep, Dragon 2 is capable of propulsive landing with no parachutes on earth, although to begin with it'll use parachutes and land in the water (perhaps using the engines to soften the landing). Interestingly, Dragon 2 does have enough fuel to land on Mars, with clever aerobraking. NASA has done some feasibility studies on using a Dragon to land on Mars with a sample return vehicle inside it.
- mikeash 11y agoDragon 2 is going to start out doing parachute landings with no propulsion at all. Once the system is sufficiently proven, they'll switch over to propulsive landings, where the parachutes are just an emergency backup in case the engines don't light or something.
- ansible 11y agoThey also need the parachutes because if there is an emergency during launch, the thrusters will be used to separate the capsule from the launch vehicle. They demonstrated this with their pad abort test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_FXVjf46T8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_FXVjf46T8 Perhaps later this year we will also see an in-flight abort test, which will be very exciting.
- sandworm101 11y agoWon't happen. Nasa will never do a purely propulsive landing of such a craft. Parachutes cannot act as backup to a rocket-powered landing. Chutes need speed+altitude to deploy. If the rockets fail 25 meters above the ground, chutes won't save anything. If the craft has chutes+people on board, they will be deployed long before touchdown. Better out than in. The only fully propulsive landing option, with humans on board, would be to have a second set of engines ready to perform what in an airplane would be called a zero-zero ejection maneuver[1]. This would see the craft reverse course, ascending rapidly to a trajectory where the chutes have time/energy enough to properly deploy. It would basically be a launch escape system. To keep that, and the chutes, and the descent engines ... just use the chutes. It isn't saving much money not deploying them as they will probably require repacking for inspection either way. [1]A zero-zero ejection seat is one that can save a pilot from a craft parked on the runway, at zero-speed and zero altitude. Older seats required altitude and/or speed. But the dragon would be descending, with a negative alt/speed, so I guess this would be a sub-zero-zero ejection. A descent escape maneuver?
- skykooler 11y agoI don't think it can do so. The Dragon 2 has a delta-V of around 400 m/s, and lunar orbital velocity is around 1600 m/s - so you'd need at minimum 3200 m/s to land and take off again. The dragon would need to carry some sort of fuel+landing legs trunk to drastically increase its delta-v to even have a chance.