3 ms·
The plain English wording says that you are safe from unreasonable searches. Everything hinges on the interpretation of "reasonable," which is not a matter of "
by mikeash 11y ago
The plain English wording says that you are safe from unreasonable searches. Everything hinges on the interpretation of "reasonable," which is not a matter of "plain English" because plain English doesn't define "reasonable" with sufficient precision.
- geggam 11y agoonly for lawyers... its obvious the concept is to protect citizens from govt dragnets... to anyone who isnt attempting to pervert the spirit of the law
- mikeash 11y agoYou've gone from "plain English" to "spirit of the law" which is way different. Again, I agree with you, but this position is not something you arrive at by just reading the 4th Amendment and then understanding its words without legal context.
- geggam 11y agoCant reply to your last statement... but read my initial post.
- TrevorJ 11y agoIn what world is using a damn airplane to get the location of mass numbers of people by exploiting their cell phones considered reasonable? It's ridiculous that people aren't in jail over this kind of bullshit.
- TrevorJ 11y agoIn what world is using a damn airplane to get the location of mass numbers of people by exploiting their cell phones considered reasonable? It's ridiculous that people aren't in jail over this kind of bullshit.