3 ms·
I'd be curious to hear how we developed successful pharmaceutical treatments for schizophrenia without knowing how the disease works. Was it just luck?
by CamperBob2 11y ago
I'd be curious to hear how we developed successful pharmaceutical treatments for schizophrenia without knowing how the disease works. Was it just luck?
- DanBC 11y agoI'd go careful with that "successful" label there. Anti-psychotic medications are good at some narrow range of stuff, but come with considerable side effects. People with schizophrenia die earlier (by about 20 years) than other people, and some of that is because of the damage done by medication. The only reason the medication is used is because untreated psychosis is often catastrophic.
- dvdcxn 11y agoJust look at the effects the anti-psychotics have had on Daniel Johnston. That it's preferable to untreated schizophrenia shows just how awful schizophrenia is.
- Tiksi 11y agoWe frequently don't know how the treatments to many ailments work either, especially when it comes to anything related to the brain. There's a lot of "X seems it might make Y better, let's test and see if it does, repeat."
- qrendel 11y agoIt's somewhat controversial, but schizophrenia treatments can be (arguably) completely ineffective and worse than the disease itself. Robert Whitaker has written multiple books[1][2] about it. (See wikipedia[3][4] for reception by the medical community.) The argument is essentially that schizophrenia medications were originally developed as a chemical replacement for lobotomy, the newer versions ("atypical neuroleptics") only had to prove themselves no less safe than those original treatments, the drug companies skewed the research by giving patients one large dose of the old treatments versus several smaller doses spread out over time of the newer ones (meaning the new neuroleptics may have actually been less safe than the drugs developed for chemical lobotomy), and recovery rates are actually much, much higher for patients never treated with anti-psychotic medications. The argument claims the US actually has among the lowest schizophrenia recovery rates (~5% in the US vs ~45% for untreated patients who receive non-medicative care) due to the reliance on medication. (Some charts on that: [5][6][7]. Better sources available through [1] and [2].) IANA doctor or psychiatrist, simply summarizing the anti-medication position. Drug companies and many psychiatrists clearly argue they're necessary medications, and for the absolute worse cases they probably are, and you can certainly find a lot of people who claim they or their family members were "fixed" by medication (though it should be noted that, historically, the same arguments were made for lobotomy and electroshock therapy as well). Schizophrenia also affects people differently, being completely disabling for some and less so for others, which obviously complicates deciding when benefits from medication outweigh the risks. [1] http://robertwhitaker.org/robertwhitaker.org/Mad%20in%20America.html http://robertwhitaker.org/robertwhitaker.org/Mad%20in%20Amer... [2] http://robertwhitaker.org/robertwhitaker.org/Anatomy%20of%20an%20Epidemic.html http://robertwhitaker.org/robertwhitaker.org/Anatomy%20of%20... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mad_in_America#Reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mad_in_America#Reception [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomy_of_an_Epidemic#Reception_and_media_coverage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anatomy_of_an_Epidemic#Recepti... [5] http://images.slideplayer.com/24/7027169/slides/slide_5.jpg http://images.slideplayer.com/24/7027169/slides/slide_5.jpg [6] http://www.madinamerica.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/Harrow.jpg http://www.madinamerica.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/Harro... [7] http://www.yoism.org/images/LongTermFollowUpSchizophreniaOutcome.JPG http://www.yoism.org/images/LongTermFollowUpSchizophreniaOut...
- derefr 11y agoRe: electroshock therapy, the "modern" version of ECT (i.e. the only version allowed for the last 50 years) is effectively just about inducing small seizures in the brains of anesthetized people, rather than frying anything. Less "burning out the bad parts", more "recalibration of synaptic weights" ala how ketamine is theorized to act in the treatment of depression. Actually scares me quite a bit less than the idea of being given chronic doses of antipsychotics.
- superuser2 11y agoPsychiatric medication does not generally target and resolve the "root cause" of an issue, but applies some very blunt instruments to make living with the effects less bad. We have the chemistry to apply some very broad levers to moods/emotions/energy levels, for example, which are helpful in the management of depression. We cannot reach in "fix" the root cause, but often when a patient is allowed to exist in a less-actively-torturous state for a while they get better on their own.