5 ms·
Head of Navy intelligence hasn't been allowed to see military secrets for years
- ma2rten 11y agoPentagon officials said his security clearance would have to be restored by a separate arm of the bureaucracy in a process that usually takes months. You'd think that they'd make an exception and speed up the process for the head of intelligence.
- detaro 11y ago"usually", so yes, I'd assume they would speed it up if they started it. But it doesn't seem like they want to, since they are not convinced he is "clean"?
- leoc 11y agoYes, sounds like a bureaucratic stalling action.
- hudibras 11y agoThe problem is he's not yet cleared from the still-ongoing federal case. The feds need to release him from that before the adjudication authority can make a decision.
- ma2rten 11y agoThe context of the sentence I quoted said: Even if Branch were cleared of wrongdoing by the Justice Department and the Navy tomorrow, he would face a much longer wait to regain access to military secrets.
- ioquatix 11y agoSounds more like the Head of Stupidity.
- jonnybgood 11y agoI don't think this is that big of deal. Most intel officers and especially commanders are first and foremost managers of people. They don't really require access to classified information to do their job.
- dkarapetyan 11y agoThe reason for why is a big deal. A lot of navy officers are currently involved in a bribery scandal.
- vonmoltke 11y agoYes, they do require access to classified information to do their jobs. You cannot manage people effectively if you have no idea what they are working on or visit their work areas. In fact, many basic operational details of units like this are low-level classified information, which would make command without a clearance effectively impossible.
- criddell 11y agoMy health insurance is provided by Aetna. Does Mark Bertolini, the CEO of Aetna, require access to my private health data do to his job?
- Spooky23 11y agoNo, but he does need to know that his company processes your health claims. The existence of many intel programs is a secret.
- superuser2 11y agoIf something exceptional happens, yes, a subordinate needs to be able to raise the issue up the chain and say, "What do I do?"
- vonmoltke 11y agoAs someone else mentioned, yes he does need to be able to access that data should a specific need arise. That said, personal health records at an insurance provider are not the same thing as classified information within the DOD. The DOD classifies lots of operational details in order to protect its operations. Unit locations, security procedures, budgets, even the existence and personnel rosters of certain locations. Do you think Mark Bertolini could run Aetna without access to its complete budget, employee rolls, locations, and functional areas?
- bgilroy26 11y agoIn 2010, UWisconsin professor of history Alfred McCoy was invited to the 8th Annual Western Regional International Health Conference "War & Global Health" held at the University of Washington in Seattle. He gave a lecture mostly on torture and public policy. In this lecture, Dr. Alfred McCoy claims that there was a bitter debate in the 2000s between the Justice Department and the Judge Advocate General's Corps [Famously broadcast television's JAGs] over torture [1]. He alleges that the JAGs were against the vast expansion of Executive power under the Bush administration (continued under Pres. Obama). It is tinfoil-y to make broad sweeping narratives about the powers that be. All the same, on the basis of Dr. McCoy's speculation and public knowledge about John Yoo [2], I presume that if the Justice Department and the Navy are fighting that the Navy are the good guys. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy_jjwid3YM#t=52m21s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy_jjwid3YM#t=52m21s [portion of immediate interest at 53:45] [2] http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2010/04/08/they-did-authorize-torture-but/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2010/04/08/they-did-authoriz...
- cant_kant 11y ago"After a year in limbo, the Navy has decided to move ahead and replace the service's top intelligence officer, whose tenure has been hamstrung by suspected ties to a disgraced defense contracting firm. The Office of the Secretary of the Navy has nominated Rear Adm. Elizabeth Train for a third star and to relieve Vice Adm. Ted Branch as director of naval intelligence, according to two Navy officials. Branch's access to classified information was suspended in November 2013, along with that of a deputy, Rear Adm. Bruce Loveless, the director of intelligence operations, for possible connections to Glenn Defense Marine Asia — the husbanding firm at the center of one of the Navy's biggest bribery scandals in decades." http://www.navytimes.com/story/military/pentagon/2014/11/26/elizabeth-train-nomination-ted-branch-navy-intelligence-boss-relief-ray-mabus/19537939/?from=global&sessionKey=&autologin= http://www.navytimes.com/story/military/pentagon/2014/11/26/... "... Navy officials boarded and relieved Capt. Daniel P. Dusek of his command of the amphibious assault ship USS Bonhomme Richard. Fifteen months later on January 15, 2015, federal prosecutors obtained a guilty plea from Dusek on charges of bribery for supplying classified ship movements in the Asia-Pacific region to Glenn Marine in return for prostitutes and luxury hotel stays worth over $10,000. Dusek arranged for the carrier USS Abraham Lincoln and the amphibious assault ship USS Peleliu to stop at ports where Francis' firm could service the ships. Dusek was released on $200,000 bail pending his sentencing hearing set for April 3, 2015. The previous week, on January 2, 2015, Cmdr. Jose Luis Sanchez pleaded guilty to supplying secret ship movement schedules in return for prostitutes, luxury travel and $100,000 in cash over a four year period."
- buserror 11y ago<sarcasm on>I thought the whole reason for the military budget these days was to funnel public money into large defense contractors for dubious services?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 11y agoAfter a lengthy investigation, lobbyists have determined that neither Glenn Marine nor its CEO "Fat" Leonard Francis have ever given any money to a PAC, super-PAC, campaign, or think tank. Nor have they put up any retired generals at the Four Seasons for the week while said generals made the rounds of the political bloviation shows. This is simply not how it is done in USA military procurement. "Cultural differences" is no excuse. The aesthetics of bribery are at least as important as the amounts. To bribe a C.O. directly is to ignore the chain of command, and that shit ain't cool.
- kombucha2 11y ago"On October 2, 2013, near the end of the three-year investigation, Navy officials boarded and relieved Capt. Daniel P. Dusek of his command of the amphibious assault ship USS Bonhomme Richard.[8] Fifteen months later on January 15, 2015, federal prosecutors obtained a guilty plea from Dusek on charges of bribery for supplying classified ship movements in the Asia-Pacific region to Glenn Marine in return for prostitutes and luxury hotel stays worth over $10,000.[6] Dusek arranged for the carrier USS Abraham Lincoln and the amphibious assault ship USS Peleliu to stop at ports where Francis' firm could service the ships. Dusek was released on $200,000 bail pending his sentencing hearing set for April 3, 2015. The previous week, on January 2, 2015, Cmdr. Jose Luis Sanchez pleaded guilty to supplying secret ship movement schedules in return for prostitutes, luxury travel and $100,000 in cash over a four year period."
- jessaustin 11y agoThis reply indicates that you are several layers of reading comprehension behind the conversation that 'buserror and I were having. Please note that 'buserror's post helpfully began with a <sarcasm on> tag. It would have taken you less time to re-read the thread, than copying-and-pasting that pile of irrelevance took. If the irrelevant block-quote was an attempted meta-comment on a thread that you found irrelevant or confusing, then keep trying! Don't let me discourage you!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ptha 11y agoBranch can't meet with other senior U.S. intelligence leaders to discuss sensitive operations, or hear updates from his staff about secret missions or projects. It can be a chore just to set foot in colleagues' offices; in keeping with regulations, they must conduct a sweep beforehand to make sure any classified documents are locked up. "I have never heard of anything as asinine, bizarre or stupid in all my years," Norman Polmar, a naval analyst and historian, said in an interview. SNAFU/FUBAR come to mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FUBAR_%28disambiguation%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FUBAR_%28disambiguation%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snafu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snafu
- redwood 11y ago$150B budget. Interestingly about two thirds of Apple's revenue
- StudyAnimal 11y ago"That has resulted in an awkward arrangement, akin to sending a warship into battle with its skipper stuck onshore." This seems a bit overstated. Its more akin to the head of NASA not having a space suit, or the head of the Olympics Committee taking 40 seconds to run the 100m. He is basically a pen-pusher at this stage, chasing funding, greasing up to politicians, attending banquets. I think it is good he cannot see secrets, he doesn't need to, he has staff for that.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoIt looks bad to lower ranks, who'd have their security clearances and (most importantly) jobs taken away for much smaller (but at the same time, bigger) infractions. Its like the former sheriff of San Francisco County staying on his job after a domestic violence conviction.
- hudibras 11y agoIt's actually fairly common for military members to lose their clearances temporarily pending the results of an investigation.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoI'm thinking more along the lines of a junior enlisted soldier with a clearance who tests positive for pot during a random urinalysis.
- hudibras 11y agoIt's basically the same scenario: the clearance will get pulled until the investigation is complete. The difference here is that the drug case will be resolved in a few days, as opposed to this prolonged federal criminal case involving millions of dollars and potentially dozens or hundreds of defendants.
- 086421357909764 11y ago
- jxdjsks 11y agoI think you must be crazy to think like this.
- 086421357909764 11y agoI think you must be drastically misinformed about what's necessary to function within those assigned positions.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoPlease don't post uncivil and unsubstantive comments to Hacker News. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10989737 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10989737 and marked it off-topic.