3 ms·
> If some new chess player have beat Deep Blue 4 to 2, would we revert the perceived status of AI to what it was before that match with Kasparov? Not saying I
by sanderjd 11y ago
> If some new chess player have beat Deep Blue 4 to 2, would we revert the perceived status of AI to what it was before that match with Kasparov?
Not saying I disagree with much of your comment, but I think the answer to that question is actually, "yes". As a middling chess player, I think it would have been impossible for "a new chess player" to have beaten Deep Blue 4 to 2, and these days, it requires near-best-in-the-world prowess to pick up any games at all off the best chess computers, which I think proves that it wasn't hype-y or unfair to claim that the machines have beaten us at this.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gambler 11y agoHype is hype, whether it turns out to be justified or not. Not all people can beat even a trivial Go program. You may be missing my larger point. It is not about whether humans can beat the best chess or Go computers. It is about a very strong bias in favor of algorithms in general. The dynamics around human vs computer chess matches simply demonstrated this bias in an easily percievable form. Who cared about Kasparov's later victories and draws against other state of the art programs? They received very little coverage. Chess is just a game. The important thing to consider is what will happen when algorithms start to competre with people in more complex and ambiguous areas.
- sanderjd 11y agoI understand your larger point, but that's just how news works: you report on the new stuff, not the old stuff. Humans beating computers at chess was old news when Deep Blue happened, so it wasn't worth reporting when that happened. Nobody talks about computers beating humans at chess anymore, because that's old news now. It would be (really big) news again if a human started beating the best chess computers again. It is old news for humans to beat computers at Go, but the reverse is still new news. I agree with you that people who infer an impending AI takeover of the world from computer success in specific games are just being silly.