3 ms·
> She's working her ass off to build a company with a mission far more important than email marketing or advertising or Candy Crush or blockchains. And from al
by vkou 11y ago
> She's working her ass off to build a company with a mission far more important than email marketing or advertising or Candy Crush or blockchains.
And from all accounts, she's too busy playing PR games, as opposed to treating this like a mission far more important than email marketing.
Theranos is in the business of medical testing. This is not an industry where you can half-ass your way through certification... Or where scrutiny like "Does the product you've been selling even work?" is misplaced.
Theranos could dismiss this entire charade, if they could only provide evidence that what they claim to have built actually works.
- tyre 11y agoHonestly, I don't think they have the data. I'm not saying their product works or that she did the right thing. I do, however, question what the after-the-fact self-righteousness does for anyone. Should no one be working on this problem? How do we invest in potentially innovative ideas in more complex fields before they have proven it out?
- dbcooper 11y agoAfter 10 years a company should have data ... It's very difficult to take them seriously as a diagnostics company.
- CPLX 11y ago> Should no one be working on this problem? You have to understand that's a ludicrous fallacy of the excluded middle argument you're making. There is a long way between wanting nobody to work on this problem, and thinking it's a good idea to give tens of millions of dollars to a bright but utterly inexperienced college student to work on this problem because she happened to be school friends with some VC's daughters. [0] https://www.brainpickings.org/2014/01/03/baloney-detection-kit-carl-sagan/ https://www.brainpickings.org/2014/01/03/baloney-detection-k...
- gherkin0 11y ago> Should no one be working on this problem? No. > How do we invest in potentially innovative ideas in more complex fields before they have proven it out? Honestly, you invest in carefully proving out those potentially innovative ideas before you release them. That way you have good data convince people who claim your ideas don't work.