11 ms·
There's a very relevant section in this book ( The Second Machine Age: Work, Progress, and Prosperity in a Time of Brilliant Technologies - http://amzn.to/1KFJ1
by davidw 11y ago
There's a very relevant section in this book ( The Second Machine Age: Work, Progress, and Prosperity in a Time of Brilliant Technologies - http://amzn.to/1KFJ1Iu http://amzn.to/1KFJ1Iu ) , that I just read last night:
> "His view is strongly supported by the work of economist Andrew Oswald, who found that joblessness lasting six months or longer harms feelings of well-being and other measures of mental health about as much as the death of a spouse, and that little of this decline is due to the loss of income; instead, it arises from a loss of self-worth."
The idea being that a basic income is fine, but having people sit around idle probably isn't.
- sama 11y agoI think this is one of the most important components to study.
- dmix 11y agoWill this be possible to simulate if the participants know they are taking part in a study?
- Balgair 11y agoThat's always a hard thing to tease out of psychological studies. The tests have to be very clever to do so, and they'd have to be wide ranging. Essentially, yes, but it'll cost a lot of money.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoAnd in particular, if they know they cannot count on the basic income indefinitely? Studies on this in the past have hit that exact problem.
- mediocrejoker 11y agoI think if a basic income is eventually introduced nationally it will be the result of a hard-fought political battle with many proponents and detractors, and there are plenty of cases of laws like that being reversed within a few years. I don't know this would be too unrealistic for the study.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoStudies typically have a set duration. If you offer people a basic income for the duration of the study, they'll need to plan differently than if they have some reasonable chance of having a basic income indefinitely.
- Riseed 11y agoThis is certainly true. However, for many cases there may be little difference. A year or two of basic income is sufficient to start a business, learn skills to enable a career switch (exceptions, of course), care for a newborn, deal with short-term illnesses, etc.
- PT_2014 11y agoThere are long term studies of unemployed in multiple countries that have social safety nets that would be worth reviewing (for example: http://amzn.to/1nosUtx http://amzn.to/1nosUtx Cultures of Unemployment: A Comparative Look at Long-Term Unemployment and Urban Poverty published by Amsterdam University press in 2006) For many the impact of unemployment (for instance following closure of UK coal mining and steel industries) its not just the loss of job in the economic sense, but the disconnect from the workplace, community, changes in sense of self-worth for individuals and long term cultural and regional impact. There are proven strategies that work and lots of examples that failed. Learning from these and seeing which opportunities map to actions that start-ups can effect through mobile, social and learning technologies might be a useful starting point.
- highCs 11y agoWhat happens now if everybody is jobless, does the jobless still feel bad about it?
- danieltillett 11y agoBased on what happens in remote communities here in Australia the result is not pretty. We basically have a basic income here in Australia via our welfare system. What we have found when everyone is jobless is there are huge levels of drug use, domestic violence, child abuse and general criminality. Other than this it works quite well.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI can't say I know much about Australian welfare systems, but here in the US it can be a bit of a trap, since welfare benefits drop fast once your savings or income rises, resulting in a huge disincentive to get off welfare, and furthering the sense of hopelessness, and presumably, the drug and alcohol use. To what extent does Australian welfare gradually taper off as a means to incentivize saving, instead of punishing it?
- danieltillett 11y agoThe Australian welfare system has lots of perverse incentives, but the tapper off is not too bad. The effective marginal tax rate is quite low and we have a very high minimum wage by OECD standards. The real problems come when everyone in the community is unemployed. We really need to work on new societal structures to make sure that we don't follow the same path our remote communities have fallen into.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI'm not sure how well it would work, but one of my longest-standing justifications for basic income is capitalism itself. If you have enough to live on from what you get from the state, then you'll be content at best, or spin your wheels and with racks of VB at worst. But if your neighbor was in the same situation and works to increase their earnings, and you see them driving nicer cars and wearing nicer clothing, then you'll want to live at that level as well. Then again, it might remind them of their own failures and they get double drunk that night. I'm not sure.
- jdoliner 11y agoI've always wondered if its actually the joblessness that degrades people's self worth or the job search that must not be going to well and thus keeps them jobless. Would a person without a job but with a basic income and thus not feeling pressure to get a job experience the same hit to their self worth?
- theseatoms 11y agoThe reduced sense of self-worth is likely a result of the cultural stigma against joblessness. Hopefully, merely collecting a universal/basic income will not be similarly stigmatized.
- creshal 11y agoHow long is it going to take for society to accept it as the new norm? Decades?
- theseatoms 11y agoFive to ten years would be my guess.
- djrogers 11y ago> The reduced sense of self-worth is likely a result of the cultural stigma against joblessness. And is this a problem? Societally speaking, shame and stigma are great motivators. If we remove them as motivation for work, will society really be better off?
- Riseed 11y agoIsaac Newton was neither shamed nor stigmatized into developing calculus. Most of that work was done during "idle" time, while his university was closed for the Plague. I daresay society's great achievements are not derived from shame and stigma. What real benefit does society derive from meaningless jobs [1]? We've tried shame and stigma. We should see whether society is better off when the thinkers and doers are free to use their time thinking and doing what they feel called to think and do. [0] http://cudl.lib.cam.ac.uk/view/MS-ADD-04004/1 http://cudl.lib.cam.ac.uk/view/MS-ADD-04004/1 [1] http://strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/ http://strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/
- logingone 11y agoBeing unemployed isn't the same as feeling unemployable.
- anc84 11y agoAffiliate tag free link: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00D97HPQI/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00D97HPQI/
- davidw 11y agoI have a standing offer to buy a beer for anyone who visits me here in Bend with the entire 10's of cents I get every month with those links. But hey, at least it's a free beer for someone, rather than Jeff Bezos.
- esonderegger 11y agoAnd in Bend that would be a delicious beer! I'm thrilled Deschutes Brewery has started distributing here in DC. Also, count me among the many who have no issue with the use of Amazon affiliate links.
- davidw 11y agoDeschutes Brewery is just the tip of the iceberg - they're the 'big company' brewery these days! I actually get a discount at 10 Barrel because I signed up for their bike team, so one beer could probably become several before exhausting my vast haul from affiliate links.
- thinkingkong 11y agoWe have to clearly start differentiating between "work", and a "job". You can work hard at something which provides immense satisfaction and personal value (perhaps even value to others). But a job is strictly something you do in exchange for money. A job doesn't necessarily contribute to your self-worth. Meaningful work, does.
- johnchristopher 11y agoWay to miss the point. If you don't have a job, even if you have some kind of meaningful work or hobby on the side, your self-worth will still suffers from that.
- thinkingkong 11y agoMy point is that if we're going to introduce a concept like basic income then we need to start being really clear about the difference between effort in exchange of money, and effort which contributes to your satisfaction. Not sure how I'm missing the point.
- johnchristopher 11y ago> Not sure how I'm missing the point. Here: > A job doesn't necessarily contribute to your self-worth. Meaningful work, does. No, having a job like the vast majority of others around you (or the supposed ideal) contribute actively to your self-worth way more than have a meaningful hobby or unpaid meaningful work on the side. It has to do with the humane need of feeling integrated in the group. You really have to work hard on yourself to keep your self worth for ten years by not « working » and having only a meaningful job/work/hobby. It's not the job or the hobby or the meaningfulness that matters to your self worth. It's the sense of belonging to the group. With that said, I completely agree with that: > if we're going to introduce a concept like basic income then we need to start being really clear about the difference between effort in exchange of money, and effort which contributes to your satisfaction. Benevolent activities are going to be cast under a different light.
- robertbenjamin 11y ago
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThis assumes people on basic income without jobs are idle. What about stay-at-home spouses and parents? What about community volunteers? What about people who take care of sick friends and relatives? Furthermore, what is the economic benefit of the activities listed above? What would be lost if those activities were either abandoned or required to be paid at a fair market price? I know, charging grandma by the hour is a silly idea, but I say so to illustrate the benefits to society by activities not reflected in GDP, and to invite discussion about whether society would be better served by individuals living on basic income alone who spend their time helping others, without having to worry about making next month's rent.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoAaand, it is not currently the imperative of gov't to provide people with a sense of self-worth. That may be a worthy thing to shoot for, but it isn't currently a purpose of government. Even if one accepts uncritically the self-worth imbue-ing power of labor it's not necessarily the only way to impart a sense of self-worth to the individual.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoWell, that's exactly my point. A lot of people do things that satisfy themselves and can often help others, but when you need to work to live you get greedy with your time and money. A state that provides basic income frees people to find their sense of self-worth, not assign it to them.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoSo, pair a basic income with abolishing the minimum wage.
- Riseed 11y ago> having people sit around idle probably isn't Basic income doesn't aim for people to sit idle, and in practice basic income doesn't seem correlated with idleness. Some studies show an increase in work hours [0], and another showed a slight decrease in work hours among new parents and teenagers [1]. Loss of self-worth need not occur when people are given the freedom to say "no" to unfulfilling and unproductive jobs, the freedom to take time off to care for their own or another's health issues, and the ability to pursue their passions -- teaching inmates, launching a startup, or becoming a world-class gamer. [0] e.g. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2268552 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2268552 [1] http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf
- davidw 11y agoThe suggestion in the book is a negative income tax: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax
- Riseed 11y agoOne big difference between basic income and negative income tax is who receives them. Basic income is given to everyone, and negative income tax is only given to those below a threshold amount -- creating two classes of people: givers and receivers, us and them. The negative income tax experiment in New Jersey showed that the negative income tax created a disincentive to work, and increased family breakups. [0] Negative income tax, by virtue of being tied to the tax system, operates on a year-based system and pays retroactively. Regardless of whether the year's overall income would qualify for negative income tax, the individual still needs to self-fund any time off. A negative income tax does nothing to help those who are temporarily out of work, or who only want a few months off to help with childcare, learn a new skill, or address an illness. [0] http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/NegativeIncomeTax.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/NegativeIncomeTax.html
- davidw 11y ago
- bryanlarsen 11y agoI think the key here is to help people redefine who they are. There's not a huge material difference between people who call themselves "starving artists" vs those who call themselves "unemployed", but it is a huge mental difference.
- hitekker 11y agoRelated though not necessarily helpful section from Brave New World (1956): > of course we could give them shorter hours. Technically, it would be perfectly simple to reduce all lower-caste working hours to three or four a day. But would they be any the happier for that? No, they wouldn't. The experiment was tried, more than a century and a half ago. The whole of Ireland was put on to the four-hour day. What was the result? Unrest and a large increase in the consumption of soma; that was all. Those three and a half hours of extra leisure were so far from being a source of happiness, that people felt constrained to take a holiday from them. The Inventions Office is stuffed with plans for labour-saving processes. Thousands of them." Mustapha Mond made a lavish gesture. "And why don't we put them into execution? For the sake of the labourers; it would be sheer cruelty to afflict them with ex- cessive leisure. It's the same with agriculture. We could synthesize every morsel of food, if we wanted to. But we don't. We prefer to keep a third of the population on the land. For their own sakes-because it takes longer to get food out of the land than out of a factory. Besides, we have our stability to think of. We don't want to change. Every change is a menace to stability. That's another reason why we're so chary of applying new inventions. Every discovery in pure science is potentially subversive; even science must sometimes be treated as a possible enemy. Yes, even science."
- boxy310 11y agoI don't like it, but it's definitely relevant. In a broad sense, the shift towards a services-based economy is a type of "make-work" in the shadow of heavy automation in first agriculture then manufacturing. This is very much Parkinson's Law writ large: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law
- ryandrake 11y agoIs there any evidence that shows that Basic Income (that you DON'T lose if you happen to find work, as in the USA system) will cause people to sit around idle?
- Riseed 11y agoNot "idle" exactly, but in the Canadian Mincome experiment, teenagers and new parents decreased work hours (to focus on studies and childcare, respectively). http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf
- ryandrake 11y agoBut studying and caring for children is not idleness. We're talking about "sitting around idle" which, admittedly needs to be defined, but I'd argue doesn't include productive activities.
- Riseed 11y agoDefining "productive" and "unproductive" activities is difficult. Sitting around playing video games is a classic example, but it's a way to become a better video game developer or a world-class player, both of which are fulfilling and well-paying endeavors. Even sitting and doing nothing (i.e. meditating) can be one of the most productive things an individual can do. [0] What constitutes a "productive activity" is quite subjective. And even seemingly unproductive things can be productive: if they help de-stress and refocus, they're still contributing to productivity. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10186082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10186082
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoProductive is really hard to define because we all value what we produce differently. If I'm playing minecraft and optimize a factory in an hour, that is a productive hour of gaming. But to my father, that entire time was wasted because he cares naught for video games and would instead be out working his farm. But I look at the small scale farm and realize that for what it produces, it would be cheaper to just buy the produce and thus don't see it as productive. Is watching football and prime time TV productive? What if you have someone who doesn't like either but is doing so only so they can be a better culture fit at work since that is what everyone else at work is doing?
- a3n 11y agoThere will always be idle people, some of them poor and some of them rich trustafarians. Basic income can liberate a lot of people to focus on bettering their situations, rather than just trying not to drown from day to day.
- martythemaniak 11y agoIndeed, I'm skeptical of anything that promises to free people from work. I think of it as a mobility scooter for healthy people - the idea of not having to walk and be tired might sound appealing, but the actual use will leave you in much worse shape. Japan seems to have one solution to this problem. It's a culture that highly discourages idleness, yet also aims to look after people's welfare, so they have a very large number of (practically speaking) quite useless jobs - crossing guards on parking lot exits and streets with no traffic, platform attendants, park attendands, etc. It was quite weird seeing this at first, but once I started thinking about it as a socially acceptable form of welfare, it made a lot of sense. I don't think their system will work here (serving people is seen quite positively there, whereas here it is often looked down upon here), but it is a good working example.
- robertbenjamin 11y agoThis is a huge component that should be considered when arguing for / against basic income. Does this lack of self worth stem from actually not having a job? Or simply not putting quality time into something valuable? Did they study people who found other ways to spend their time on something productive and interesting, like volunteering or learning a hobby? Did they measure people who were jobless by choice?
- marincounty 11y agoOswald's research was published on 2004. Andrew Oswald is a British economist who earnestly tried to study happiness with statistics, and government data. The study tries to corollate government data, excludes detailed information on black wages, and tries to draw conclusions based an statistics, and questionable government data. What jumped out of the paper(around page 25) was that Europeans have been just Happy! Why are first 12 members of the EU Happy over time? I'll let you speculate. Now to entitled--usually white upper class men--who have been telling the poor what to do since biblical times. Dummy up! I've had seen too many people die early because they became homeless. I think what most of these researchers fail to comprehend is the difference between poor, and poor with no safety net. No parents. No friends couch to crash on. Just the inviting, wet thicket of Scotch Broom to crawl into, and being woken by gently nudge of a police officers' latest extension of their authoritarian arm. Real poverty is homelessness. It's ugly. I don't know why we are even debating someting, like a minimum income, at this point in time. I have seen friends die way too early because of their homeless stints. It seems by the time they get a little help, it's too late. They just die early? I'm not going to list off my gripes about making a living in this enviorment, but a lot of us tech workers are very succeptable to being homeless. At least half the guys I know without roofs over their heads were former Programmers. At one time they we happy, and young, banging away with Fortran. (Willie Brown is actually the first one I heard, wondering out loud, exactly what we are going to do with all the future homeless tech workers. They now sit in coffee shops fiddling with our discarded toys. Basic income at this point--yes. I actually think if some of these poor people were given a little bit of help, they might just start business, and who know where it will end. There's only one benefit from being poor; some of you see the world a different way. We have never had a basic income in the United States. Let's give it a shot? I look around at what's happening in the United States, and I don't like the trend. It was better in the past. (Yea, what if it gets worse. Go back to this wonderful system of privileged elitism. I won't be back, so any comments--I will miss out on. Oh, yea as to sitting idle--the subsided poor I know, are busy. See the world is funny place. Even if you get the couch in the subsidized house, you are expected to do/fix all sorts of things, including being a amature psychiatrist. The poor always pay in some way. Think about it. Did you really ever get a completely free lunch, outside of maybe grade school, or when you were young and pretty. Pretty is gender neutral.)
- dev1n 11y agoEasily solved: Basic income is paid out to people to go and work on infrastructure projects.
- chc 11y agoThat's not a basic income, that's just a government job. The point of a basic income is that it is not contingent on services rendered.
- Mz 11y agoSo, you want communism or forced labor camps? I don't want Basic Income only to be told where and how to work. If I have to work for it, I want to go find work my damn self that I find palatable. Which is (part of) why I don't want Basic Income at all. (Edited for clarity)
- wstrange 11y agoIsn't the whole concept of Basic Income that there are no strings attached?
- Mz 11y agoThere are a long list of reasons I do not want Basic Income. I really don't feel like writing an opus in comments here today. I think my last three blog posts have been about my objections to Basic Income. You are welcome to read those if you wish to get an inkling of my opinion on the subject. http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/01/the-conversation-we-need-to-have.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/01/the-conversa... http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/01/ubi-we-tried-this-before-and-its.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/01/ubi-we-tried... http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/01/the-dubious-ubi-and-delusion-that.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2016/01/the-dubious-...
- eyko 11y agoThe whole point of basic income is that you don't have to work for it, just like you don't have to work for access to universal health care.
- tempestn 11y agoIt's definitely an excellent point that a basic income would only solve part of the problem associated with lower need for labour. I'm sure there are many more startups that could be founded around the expected increase in numbers and breadth of retired people. There are plenty of things that people can do to be active and engaged when not working; it's just that often they don't. Making these activities more accessible, or accessible in different ways, surely provides some opportunities.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 11y agoPersonally, I think this is a big part of the reason UBI will work. Most people want to do something, and generally want to feel productive. How many stories have you heard about unhappy office drones leaving a job where they spent all their time on the internet to something more rewarding? But where will this productive energy go? Plenty of people will still have jobs, likely doing something more in line with their interests. Others will volunteer their time and participate in the community. I think lots of people would love to spend more time mentoring young people, being with their families, etc. It could be a revolution in community participation and lead to a more healthy society. Satisfying and productive work doesn't need to be paid work.