I love SoftLayer. They've been amazing. Dedicated boxes only, but you can get something decent for under $150, and they can get you new hardware in about two

I love SoftLayer. They've been amazing. Dedicated boxes only, but you can get something decent for under $150, and they can get you new hardware in about two hours, which is great. Granted our needs are a bit larger than yours at this time, but even when I just had a single server, I thought they were a great host. Amazing support, simple plans, etc...