3 ms·
> Spinning motion is an illusion and doesn't exist as a fundamental form of movement If there is no objective space, then "movement" in general is not a fundam
by pdonis 11y ago
> Spinning motion is an illusion and doesn't exist as a fundamental form of movement
If there is no objective space, then "movement" in general is not a fundamental concept; but you are assuming that at least some kinds of movement are fundamental (tarikjn points out something similar to this).
> similar to how lack of gravity in orbit is an illusion, in that you are continuously falling downward but missing the earth.
Actually, you have this backwards; it's the "falling downward" because of "gravity" that is the "illusion", according to our best current theory, general relativity. In a free-fall orbit, you are moving in a straight line through spacetime; you can tell this by the fact that you are weightless.
- colordrops 11y agoRegarding gravity, that was probably a bad analogy. Regarding movement, movement relative to other objects is fundamental. You are begging the question by assuming objective space is required for movement. Mind you, I'm not arguing that space doesn't exist, only that Newton's argument is flawed.
- pdonis 11y ago> movement relative to other objects is fundamental I agree that "objective space" in the sense of "a space that is the same for everyone", is not required to give an account of movement of objects relative to other objects. However, the only reason we know that is that we have an alternative: a theory of objective spacetime that gives an account of movement of objects relative to other objects. In other words, according to our best current classical theory, general relativity, Newton's argument was flawed not because nothing objective is needed to account for the bucket experiment, but because he got wrong what thing was objective: he thought it was space, but it's actually spacetime. More precisely, it's the geometry of spacetime. On the GR viewpoint, we can indeed view the rotation of Earth, for example, as relative in this sense: we can adopt a "cosmic" frame in which the Earth is spinning and the rest of the universe is at rest; or we can adopt a "geocentric" frame in which the Earth is at rest and the rest of the universe is spinning. Both frames are valid; neither one is "preferred" by the laws of physics. But both frames are describing the same underlying objective thing: the same geometry of spacetime. They are just describing it from different viewpoints.