6 ms·
Spinning motion is an illusion and doesn't exist as a fundamental form of movement, similar to how lack of gravity in orbit is an illusion, in that you are cont
by colordrops 11y ago
Spinning motion is an illusion and doesn't exist as a fundamental form of movement, similar to how lack of gravity in orbit is an illusion, in that you are continuously falling downward but missing the earth.
Spinning objects are made of particles that are all actually going in straight lines but forces against each other are causing them to change direction, cummulatively appearing to be spinning, like an extremely coherent eddie current or vortex. Their movement is in relation to each other, and there is no need for an objective space in which to spin.
- tarikjn 11y agoSuppose your object is the only thing in space, how do you tell that it is spinning? How do the particles in the object can tell that the object as a whole is spinning? What you describe are particules going in straight lines, but over what space/grid are they going on a straight lines? If they are going over straight lines on something then your description is one of an objective space. If pulling forces are still exerted on its edges in proportion to said "spinning", then there exist a static field in space for which the object is in static alignment when the pulling force are at minima. Interestingly the same observation could be made of two objects in orbit or the electrons orbiting individual atoms in the object, with the static alignment being observed when the acceleration between the objects is at a maxima i.e. they are falling into one another.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 11y agoThey are going in straight lines in relation to the other particles in the object. Then the force of one particle exerts on another particle as they get closer or further from each other, causing them to change direction. This happens for innumerable numbers of particles, appearing like a singular object that is spinning, since the forces are too great to pull the object apart. If you spin it fast enough, the particles will overcome the atomic forces holding it together, and the object will break apart, with the individual pieces continuing to move in a straight line.
- pdonis 11y ago> Spinning motion is an illusion and doesn't exist as a fundamental form of movement If there is no objective space, then "movement" in general is not a fundamental concept; but you are assuming that at least some kinds of movement are fundamental (tarikjn points out something similar to this). > similar to how lack of gravity in orbit is an illusion, in that you are continuously falling downward but missing the earth. Actually, you have this backwards; it's the "falling downward" because of "gravity" that is the "illusion", according to our best current theory, general relativity. In a free-fall orbit, you are moving in a straight line through spacetime; you can tell this by the fact that you are weightless.
- colordrops 11y agoRegarding gravity, that was probably a bad analogy. Regarding movement, movement relative to other objects is fundamental. You are begging the question by assuming objective space is required for movement. Mind you, I'm not arguing that space doesn't exist, only that Newton's argument is flawed.
- pdonis 11y ago> movement relative to other objects is fundamental I agree that "objective space" in the sense of "a space that is the same for everyone", is not required to give an account of movement of objects relative to other objects. However, the only reason we know that is that we have an alternative: a theory of objective spacetime that gives an account of movement of objects relative to other objects. In other words, according to our best current classical theory, general relativity, Newton's argument was flawed not because nothing objective is needed to account for the bucket experiment, but because he got wrong what thing was objective: he thought it was space, but it's actually spacetime. More precisely, it's the geometry of spacetime. On the GR viewpoint, we can indeed view the rotation of Earth, for example, as relative in this sense: we can adopt a "cosmic" frame in which the Earth is spinning and the rest of the universe is at rest; or we can adopt a "geocentric" frame in which the Earth is at rest and the rest of the universe is spinning. Both frames are valid; neither one is "preferred" by the laws of physics. But both frames are describing the same underlying objective thing: the same geometry of spacetime. They are just describing it from different viewpoints.
- jerf 11y agoPhysicists are rather aware of these things, seeing as you they are the ones who taught them to you in the first place. This is an old, venerable question that, as the article says, dates back to before Einsteinian relativity and remain unresolved to this day. Physics 101 is not capable of resolving the matter.
- colordrops 11y agoAppeal to authority is worse than actually trying to figure out a problem from first principles, especially in the field of physics.
- jerf 11y ago"Appeal to authority" is more than "mentioning the existence of authorities". This is not an appeal to authority. The point is, if the answer was as simple as that, it wouldn't be a problem. This is not news. This is a century+ old conundrum, and you can't solve it by simply reciting Physics 101 as if that's it, book closed. It's the equivalent of listening to a operating systems researcher describe a thorny problem in the creation of a multitasking operating system on a hundred-core NUMA system, and then pedantically, slowly, patronizingly explaining back to them how functions work by pushing things on to a stack and then popping them afterwards. When they favor you afterwards with a deeply shocked expression, it's not in amazement at your penetrating insights.
- colordrops 11y agoStill sounds like "Appeal to authority" to me. To speak to your analogy, I am involved in the field of computers, and I've seen first hand "experts" in this field build big complicated systems, that maybe had some merit at some point in time, but as the context changed with new developments and technologies, a young upstart built something much more simple that made the expert's system look like a mess. This is relevant because the context of what we understand is very different from Newton's time. School children have a more accurate depiction of the laws that govern our reality than the tops minds at the time, who believed in such things as phlogiston and the earth-centric universe.
- danbruc 11y agoI am actually not sure that this is true. I used to think exactly like you, that rotations are just piles of small translations with time varying directions, but there is a problem with this, linear momentum and angular momentum are two different conserved quantities. If it were the case that rotations are just translations then you should be able to get rid of angular momentum and its conservation and explain it in terms of linear momentum and I don't think that you can do that. Linear momentum is tied to the homogeneity of space while angular momentum is tight to the isotropy of space. You could actually do the exact opposite, say that translations are just rotations about a point infinitely far away, but I think that won't work either. I really don't know for sure, I mean I am not really, really, really confident about it, but as far as I can tell rotations and translations are fundamentally different. Unaccelerated translations make only sense as relations between two objects but you don't need any reference to detect acceleration, you can just release an object from your hand and see if it drops to the floor because of gravity, hits the wall behind you because your space ship is accelerating or flies away tangentially because you are on a carousel. Rotation requires continuous acceleration (I am avoiding the term constant acceleration because only the magnitude is constant but not the direction) of all the particles towards the center of rotation or otherwise they would fly away tangentially. But if rotation requires continuous acceleration and you can always detect acceleration without reference to some other outside objects then you can always detect rotations and that is not true for translations, you can not detect unaccelerated translations. It is the difference between velocities and accelerations and the fact that rotations always require accelerations that makes rotations more than just a pile of translations. You won't notice any difference if you translate everything in space by the same amount, you won't see any change if you rotate everything in space by the same amount, there is also no difference if you change the velocity of everything by the same amount but you will immediately notice if you change the acceleration of everything. Or maybe that is at least partially nonsense, unfortunately I haven't yet mastered that topic myself.
- colordrops 11y agoAngular momentum is an abstract concept, and an emergent property. It doesn't exist inherently in an object.
- leppr 11y agoSo you're saying there's a final fractional digit to PI? That's good news.
- colordrops 11y agoThat's a non sequitur.