5 ms·
These lawsuits expose a couple of things, one there needs to be more kinds of work classifications than employee and contractor. Two, the benefits system, heal
by mc32 11y ago
These lawsuits expose a couple of things, one there needs to be more kinds of work classifications than employee and contractor. Two, the benefits system, healthcare, whatever, is still not fixed and has a long way to go to cover all citizens, regardless of employment type and status.
Another thing, is these platforms have more than one kind of participant, ones who utilize them as their main source of income, and those who utilize them as complementary source of income or as a part time/college/uni job.
If these platforms would simply be a platform (who like yelp) let the provider sink or swim based on ratings, then they could avoid the problems stemming from their requirements [which makes the platform less ad hoc and more rule based thus leaning toward employee - yet the fear would be a degradation in service to end users and thus a threat to platform viability]
One thing I'd like to know is whether people doing lyft or über full time do on average better or worse than their yellowcab counterpart.
- tyingq 11y agoUber and Lyft get out of more than just paying benefits by classifying their workers as independent contractors. They also avoid paying their portion of the payroll taxes, liability for workman's comp, protective laws (minimum wage, unemployment coverage, for example). Edit: For those downvoting...you really think these exact things weren't discussed when Uber & Lyft were deciding how they would comp drivers? Heh.
- tzier 11y agoPortion of payroll taxes is ~7.5%, plus an extra 2.5-10% for workers comp/etc depending on your rates. If they had to reclass as employees, they would just raise prices to end consumer 10-20% to compensate (or fund it via other's money like they're doing now to price out rest of market). They'd also put a cap on hours per week so drivers couldn't drive more than 30 hours per week. Companies aren't legally required to give benefits to part-time workers (up to 30 hours). The big draw of independent contractors is that you've just converted labor from a fixed cost to a variable cost. There are tons of Uber/Lyft drivers (namely, anyone not doing it full-time, which is the majority of drivers) who prefer this since they can drive as much or as little as they want.
- azylman 11y ago> If they had to reclass as employees, they would just raise prices to end consumer 10-20% to compensate (or fund it via other's money like they're doing now to price out rest of market). I think saying that they would "just" raise prices 10-20% is trivializing the problem. One of the reasons that Uber took off was because it was so much cheaper than regular taxis. Would Uber look the same now if it had had 20% higher prices from the beginning? Almost surely not.
- rayiner 11y agoI take Uber almost daily from the train to my office because it's about 30% cheaper than a cab. If it wasn't I'd just grab a cab at the cab line. It's so much easier.
- harryh 11y agoOf course if uber has to raise rates because their employee costs go up, you'd have to expect cab companies to do the same because all their employees aren't getting benefits either.
- tyingq 11y agoThey are, however, paying their portion of the payroll taxes, disability, unemployment, etc. And perhaps softer benefits that still have costs, like paid time off.
- harryh 11y agoI am nearly certain that's not true in the majority of circumstances. Cab drivers are generally self employed and issued 1099s not W2s.
- tzier 11y agoYou're correct - taxi drivers have been suing for decades to get employee status. You don't hear about it because Uber is the first major national player that everyone recognizes.
- SilasX 11y ago>They also avoid paying their portion of the payroll taxes, No, they don't. They might avoid being assessed the payroll tax, but the economic incidence (the reduction in purchasing power after prices have adjusted in light of the taxes) is, per a well known result, independent of who assess the tax on, and completely dependent on the shape of the supply/demand curves.[1] "Making" employers "contribute" half of FICA is just a shell game. If (on normal employees) you made employers pay all of it, they would (likewise) just cut wages by the exact same amount, as everyone's after-tax income would remain the same and no one would have reason to deviate. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence >>The key concept is that the tax incidence or tax burden does not depend on where the revenue is collected, but on the price elasticity of demand and price elasticity of supply.
- tzier 11y ago> One thing I'd like to know is whether people doing lyft or über full time do on average better or worse than their yellowcab counterpart. A good indicator is that most cab drivers (at least in SF) have switched over to Uber. The only ones who aren't doing Uber either (a) got low reviews on Uber and kicked off the platform or (b) have some odd loyalty to cab companies (e.g. maybe they're a part owner in a medallion). Most taxi cab drivers are treated more poorly than Uber/Lyft drivers. They have to drive to a centralized location to pick up / drop off the car, don't have their own car to take care of, have to pay a per day fee that they don't always pay back if they don't get enough business, etc.
- mc32 11y agoIt's less than perfect. People could be migrating more because lyft and über are siphoning away fares. So they go where there is money, even if it's less than historically. Which makes me want to clarify things. Are über lyft drivers better off than yellow cabs where these platforms have not yet disrupted? In other words, are they better off on über now or yellow cab historically? The answer, I suspect, will remain the same, but its far from cut and dried, I think.
- tzier 11y agoThis ultimately comes down to the debate between capitalism vs socialism - if people are still driving at lower rates, then we weren't at a market equilibrium. But should they have basic coverages? I expect the ODE to become a huge topic for the 2016 election, since (at a high level) it's a manifestation of the Republican vs Democratic platforms.
- tyingq 11y agoI think it's more difficult to get to the truth. This article seems credible: https://pando.com/2015/01/09/the-hidden-cost-of-being-an-uber-driver-and-why-fare-cuts-really-do-hit-their-bottom-line/ https://pando.com/2015/01/09/the-hidden-cost-of-being-an-ube... But, what it shows as the "income after op cost" isn't the real truth. That figure ($12.62/hr in Chicago, $34.04/hr in NYC) would be basically 1099 income. You would have to pay self employment tax (not trivial), and forgo whatever benefits a cab company might provide their employees. If you look for average salary for cab drivers, and compare to the above, you would gather that cab drivers do better than Uber drivers in Chicago, but worse in NYC. I can't find any credible sources where it seems 100% clear that the comparison is thorough, and apples to apples.
- st3v3r 11y ago"These lawsuits expose a couple of things, one there needs to be more kinds of work classifications than employee and contractor." Why?
- mc32 11y agoBecause it forces classifying workers as either employee or contractor when a case could be made for another classification of flex-employee. So, for example a good number of über drivers are part timers, which is fine, but if this becomes a normal aspect of the economy, we need to be able to make it automatic for this class of people to get some kind of benefits. Not as much as employees, and more than [$0] as in contractors who need to do their own taxes, benefits, healthcare, etc.
- st3v3r 11y agoI guess I'm not seeing a reason for a third kind. It's pretty clear that drivers are employees. The only reason to introduce anything else would be because Uber/Lyft have lobbied to try and prevent full employee status. This "flex-employee" doesn't seem like something that needs to exist, and would only be used to justify not giving benefits.
- mc32 11y agoSometimes people just want some part time work and don't want to be tied in to one company --allowing them to choose different things on different days, seasons, etc. Long term über and lyft etc won't need drivers, so it's more for the more high touch industries.
- tyingq 11y agoThere are lots and lots of people that have 2 concurrent part time jobs, right now. Not trying to be coy, just trying to understand why we need a new classification.
- st3v3r 11y agoSo they're employees, just part time. Problem solved, without needing yet another classification that will end up doing nothing for workers.