3 ms·
The Schrödinger equation was not derived, a more accurate word would be guessed. It's a fundamental law, like F = ma (although that is actually more of a defin
by cyphar 11y ago
The Schrödinger equation was not derived, a more accurate word would be guessed. It's a fundamental law, like F = ma (although that is actually more of a definition than a law). There is no fundamental explanation why electrons obey the Schrödinger equation, just like there's no fundamental explanation why macroscopic objects obey F = ma.
- krastanov 11y agoA lot of things can be derived from more basic or at least more beautiful principles. It makes perfect sense to say that Schroedinger's equation can be derived from Lagrangian Mechanics, even if this is not historically how it happened. An especially beautiful constraint is "Schroedinger's equation has to be linear because otherwise you can build a (quantum) computer that can solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time". Schroedinger did not know about NP-completeness, but this notion does give us clues why the equation is what it is. It is always instructive to see how a "fundamental" law can be derived or at least constrained from other laws. Thermodynamics and the notion of entropy would not have been invented if engineers did not "rederive" what was considered fundamental at the time.
- nilkn 11y agoI think you're both right. The grandparent post is right in the sense that reductionism always reduces, ultimately, to a guess (in this case, Lagrangian mechanics is the guess). You're right, though, in that a basic framework can be established, using minimal assumptions and axioms, in which most of classical physics and even much of quantum physics can be derived via (mostly) rigorous mathematical arguments. But that framework itself is, at the end of the day, a guess. It's simply the best guess we have at the given moment in time that fits the evidence (e.g., by allowing us to derive from it known rules and patterns that past generations have verified fit the evidence).
- calhoun137 11y agoIt's actually not true to say that Schrodinger's equation, or F=ma, cannot be derived. This is because in order to derive something, you need to first start from a set of assumptions. You can pick any assumptions you want, that is your privilege, as it is mine. If you want F=ma to be an assumption, you can go on and derive things from that. But truly, F=ma is not the most general assumption in theoretical physics. If you look in any decent book on classical mechanics, you will find that F=ma in fact is derived from a much more general principle, the Lagrangian. That is the same Lagrangian that is the subject of the OP, which is used to derive the Schrodinger equation; and it's not just a coincidence.
- cyphar 11y ago> It's actually not true to say that Schrodinger's equation, or F=ma, cannot be derived. I don't think I said it couldn't be derived. I said there wasn't a "fundamental reason why the Schrödinger equation is X". Using Lagrangians to derive it then begs the question "but why must electrons obey the Lagrangian?". > This is because in order to derive something, you need to first start from a set of assumptions. You can pick any assumptions you want, that is your privilege, as it is mine. If you want F=ma to be an assumption, you can go on and derive things from that. Well, F = ma was a bad example, I grant you. It's actually a definition of what a force is, nothing more. But it's relevant, because it has a similar purpose (except in a different field of physics). A better example of a fundamental law would be action-reaction or something. But yes, you're free to pick any assumption you like. But if you assume X, which came about because of assumption Y, it shouldn't be a shock that X can be used to derive Y. At that moment, they are just different notations for the same assumption. You might argue (and hell, I might even agree) that Lagrangians are so much more mathematically pleasing, so make a better assumption. But that doesn't change the fact that you're dressing up assumption Y as assumption X. > But truly, F=ma is not the most general assumption in theoretical physics. > If you look in any decent book on classical mechanics, you will find that F=ma in fact is derived from a much more general principle, the Lagrangian. The Lagrangian is great for solving many problems. But it is definitely not more general than Newtonian mechanics. It can't deal with friction, or quite a few other non-conservative forces. On the plus side, solving oscillating systems is much easier. And it's so much nicer when not using Cartesian coordinates. > That is the same Lagrangian that is the subject of the OP, which is used to derive the Schrodinger equation; and it's not just a coincidence. While this is correct, Lagrangian mechanics refers to concepts such as energy which are defined from forces. In particular, Lagrangian's deal with systems with only conservative forces (but total energy may change with time). So it's really a circular argument to say "this concept can be derived from this even more abstract concept, which was actually defined from the first concept and at the end of the day is a guess." There's nothing wrong with guessing fundamental laws. That's how the scientific method works, after all. You ask a question, guess the answer, predict what your guess would imply and test your predictions.
- momzer 11y ago