4 ms·

I am a strong supporter of globalization, but pessimistic about government's ability to help the people who you describe as being left behind. Retraining has th

by nickff 11y ago

I am a strong supporter of globalization, but pessimistic about government's ability to help the people who you describe as being left behind. Retraining has the worst record of the programs you describe, and 'education' usually does little (probably because of signalling). I am most vigorously opposed to government-backed 'education loans', which do little more than drive up tuition. I am generally opposed to welfare, because is does little to ameliorate the human issues related to joblessness, and basic income is little better, though BI can give people some flexibility to make their own choices. A globalization 'bonus' or temporary boost in BI might be worth considering (and testing), but we should also encourage people to adapt to the new world instead of building up resentment while refusing to change. It also seems that we should each take some personal responsibility, and help whomever we can. It is too often that we pawn off our responsibilities and moral duties on society.

trhway 11y ago
> I am generally opposed to welfare, because is does little to ameliorate the human issues related to joblessness, it is a safety net, a helping hand society extends to let people to not starve to death on the streets, it is not a tool to solve structural economical/political/social issues.
Outdoorsman 11y ago
>It also seems that we should each take some personal responsibility, and help whomever we can. It is too often that we pawn off our responsibilities and moral duties on society.< So very true...the single most important thing a person can do to strengthen a community--interpret community as broadly as you like--is to spend time helping those in your immediate vicinity...I'm prescribing this because of it's accessibility; it's a course of action available to anyone, usually costs little, and leaves you feeling pretty darned good... First-hand case in point: A boy who lives a couple of miles away from me started dropping by occasionally to visit...he'd pedal by on his bicycle and stop to chat if I was out in the yard... During our visits I learned about his circumstances...his father, a drug user, committed suicide in the shower of their home when he was 6 years old...his mother had had a series of boyfriends, and there were 3 partial families--14 people--living in his house, a 3 bedroom trailer... As we got to know each other a bit better he asked me one day,"Hey, everyone around here calls you the computer man; how could I learn about computers?" I told him I could teach him a few things, and did...he would drop by when my schedule permitted and was willing to sit for as long I was willing to teach him things...just basics, a few tricks... I could tell that he had a quick grasp of the material, and asked him how school was going, his grades, etc...turned out he had around a 3.7 GPA, and admitted that he never studied outside of school... I told him one day that he should consider college...the next day he said he had mentioned what I said to his mom and she flatly told him,"We can't afford something like that". To make a long story short, the state that I live in offers a program that essentially pays (combined with grants, and college scholarships) for those below a certain income level to attend 5 years of in-state college...I spent several days gathering information, presented it to him, and told him I thought he could do it...he just needed to sign up in the program right away, and keep his grades up... Rather predictably, his mother was initially skeptical, so at his invitation I visited with her and explained how this would work... I'll leave the story here...he's a junior in high school now and is on track to enter college in 2017...he would have never become aware of the opportunity if I hadn't mentioned it to him, and all it cost me was about 2 days of research and another day helping him apply... we'll see how it goes...
- sehr 11y ago
  From someone who was in a similar situation in high school: thank you. The person who helped me out singlehandedly changed my life, I hope it works out just as well for y'all
JoBrad 11y ago
I would strongly disagree that education loans only drive up tuition. I know several people (including myself) who would not have been able to finish college without a combination of Pell Grants and subsidized student loans. I now have a very well paying job and have contributed far more in taxes than I took in loans - plus I'm paying off my loans. So I can personally vouch for their effectiveness as a tool to enable achievement. I do agree that rising college cost is a problem, but blaming it mostly or entirely on government-backed student loans is far too simplistic, and ignores the benefit that it has provided.

by nickff 11y ago

trhway 11y ago

> I am generally opposed to welfare, because is does little to ameliorate the human issues related to joblessness, it is a safety net, a helping hand society extends to let people to not starve to death on the streets, it is not a tool to solve structural economical/political/social issues.

Outdoorsman 11y ago

>It also seems that we should each take some personal responsibility, and help whomever we can. It is too often that we pawn off our responsibilities and moral duties on society.< So very true...the single most important thing a person can do to strengthen a community--interpret community as broadly as you like--is to spend time helping those in your immediate vicinity...I'm prescribing this because of it's accessibility; it's a course of action available to anyone, usually costs little, and leaves you feeling pretty darned good... First-hand case in point: A boy who lives a couple of miles away from me started dropping by occasionally to visit...he'd pedal by on his bicycle and stop to chat if I was out in the yard... During our visits I learned about his circumstances...his father, a drug user, committed suicide in the shower of their home when he was 6 years old...his mother had had a series of boyfriends, and there were 3 partial families--14 people--living in his house, a 3 bedroom trailer... As we got to know each other a bit better he asked me one day,"Hey, everyone around here calls you the computer man; how could I learn about computers?" I told him I could teach him a few things, and did...he would drop by when my schedule permitted and was willing to sit for as long I was willing to teach him things...just basics, a few tricks... I could tell that he had a quick grasp of the material, and asked him how school was going, his grades, etc...turned out he had around a 3.7 GPA, and admitted that he never studied outside of school... I told him one day that he should consider college...the next day he said he had mentioned what I said to his mom and she flatly told him,"We can't afford something like that". To make a long story short, the state that I live in offers a program that essentially pays (combined with grants, and college scholarships) for those below a certain income level to attend 5 years of in-state college...I spent several days gathering information, presented it to him, and told him I thought he could do it...he just needed to sign up in the program right away, and keep his grades up... Rather predictably, his mother was initially skeptical, so at his invitation I visited with her and explained how this would work... I'll leave the story here...he's a junior in high school now and is on track to enter college in 2017...he would have never become aware of the opportunity if I hadn't mentioned it to him, and all it cost me was about 2 days of research and another day helping him apply... we'll see how it goes...

sehr 11y ago
From someone who was in a similar situation in high school: thank you. The person who helped me out singlehandedly changed my life, I hope it works out just as well for y'all

JoBrad 11y ago

I would strongly disagree that education loans only drive up tuition. I know several people (including myself) who would not have been able to finish college without a combination of Pell Grants and subsidized student loans. I now have a very well paying job and have contributed far more in taxes than I took in loans - plus I'm paying off my loans. So I can personally vouch for their effectiveness as a tool to enable achievement. I do agree that rising college cost is a problem, but blaming it mostly or entirely on government-backed student loans is far too simplistic, and ignores the benefit that it has provided.