4 ms·
If people said that then they were silly, because JPEG and GIF solve different problems. JPEG didn't displace GIF because JPEG doesn't actually do a good job of
by mikeash 11y ago
If people said that then they were silly, because JPEG and GIF solve different problems. JPEG didn't displace GIF because JPEG doesn't actually do a good job of compressing the images that GIF is good at compressing. Note that once a format came along that was good at those, namely PNG, it did displace GIF pretty much entirely for the still-image use case.
- jobu 11y agoDoes anyone know why the APNG format was rejected by the PNG group? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APNG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APNG) It seems like a great replacement for animated GIFs.
- jcranmer 11y agoAPNG was rejected primarily because it used image/png when it was clearly a video, and the WG felt that images shouldn't handle video. When video/png was offered instead, Mozilla rejected that because it felt backwards compatibility was more important. So, basically, it was rejected due to a pissing contest on the least important part of the specification.
- maxst 11y agolibpng is a reference implementation of the PNG format. They don't have to support every third-party extension. But libpng provides callback methods for "unknown" chucks, so the application can read and handle them. So it's possible to process APNG with libpng.